Alexander Baking Co.

210 S 1st St, Rogers
(479) 372-4474

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Rachel Crosslin

I ordered a custom red velvet cake with raspberry filling and 2 dozen iced cookies for my dog's birthday party last week (it was magic-themed, hence the Abracadabra Gaga cake and themed cookies). Everything turned out deliciously - and guests oohed and aahed over the gorgeous cake. People also gushed over the super cute cookies. I especially liked how delectable and soft they were! I did have to print out my own topper, but I tried to make sure the craftsmanship was on par with the beautiful cake. Working with Brooke from Alexander Baking Co. made the process super easy and I appreciated her knowledge and insight before finalizing the order. I would definitely go back to Alexander Baking Co. if ordering for a special occasion or dog birthday party again. Thank you so much!

Food: 5

Service: 4

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Iced Sugar Cookie

Charlotte Blake

Did exactly as we wanted.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

D Johnson

Stopped in to find a last minute cake and scored! Very helpful and the cake was delicious

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Kristal white

My family surprised me with the best cake for my birthday, Brooke did a fantastic job!! It was delicious & my daughter said it turned out exactly like the inspiration photo she gave her.

Food: 5

Service: 5

lexi white

Made a cake for my mom’s birthday with less than a weeks notice and it was AMAZING! No notes! Will never get a cake from anywhere else!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake, Wedding Cake, Cupcake, Decorated Cookies, Macaron and Brownies, Vanilla Cake, Brownie, Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookie, Carrot Cake Cookies, Gingerbread Cookies, Living Tree Birthday Cake, Iced Sugar Cookie, Mochi, Sausage Roll, Dessert Bar

Audrey Ogden

Limited storefront selection. I purchased a case cake for $35 and got home to try it. I could “taste the case” if that makes sense. Like when you store food in Tupperware you sometimes get a taste of the plastic if it was washed with soap, so not very good. Icing is overly sweet and grainy/thick.

Food: 2

Allyson Vanderclock

Our wedding cake was delicious and looked beautiful. Unfortunately I don’t have a picture yet. Communication was thorough and direct. No hiccups or bumps throughout our process. Thank you so much for making our wedding day magical.

Emily Powell

Oh my goodness! I have tried the macarons as well as her sugar cookies and chocolate chip cookies plus a lemon one and a snicker doodle. Each thing I had was perfection in both texture and taste 🧑‍🍳 Absolutely amazing

Sabrina Kubic

Called to get details and schedule a tasting for my wedding. Everything started out great until I asked questions. I was told there was no reason to be thinking about a wedding cake because of how far out my date is. I was calling for a tasting. When my date is shouldn’t matter unless I planned on choosing them. Can’t do that without a tasting. My wedding planning wasn’t up to their standards. They were very rude. Cut me off and kept talking over me. Got no details from them. No help at all. What they did tell me was my venue was too far and highly recommended not going with them. Probably the only thing we agreed on by the end of the call.

Alicia Pickens

I’ve now been here 3x - 1x for a cookie decorating class which was so fun and informative! And 2x more to pickup sweets. The gooey butter cake and the lemon gooey butter cake are out of this world! The sugar cookies are great and not overly sweet! I also really enjoyed the salted caramel macaroon. I will definitely be back to try more!

Sherry Laemmle

Drove out of our way to stop at the bakery. Not sure if it was the owner that was working or not, but unfriendly and seemed like she sure didn’t want to be working in a bakery. We were so excited to stop because they did the wedding cake for a family wedding we attended and we just loved it. Told her that but she seemed to care less that we were returning customers. Bought cupcakes during our visit and they were small and underwhelming. Won’t drive out of my way to go back. Good luck.

Dusty Woolman

Cutest cow cupcakes!🩷

amy Loyola

Cinnamon rolls are to die for. The best, real cream cheese icing cinnamon roll.

Tracy Parnell

Delicious cookies. The pumpkin snickerdoodle with cream cheese frosting is delicious! The lemon cookies delicious!

Marvin Laird

My wife likes sea Turtles so I asked if she can add a sea turtle to her Birthday cake, she said she could do something like that, it is sooo cute! my wife loved it!
Thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Birthday Cake

Loading...