The owners are amazing people and they have a great staff! To me, their pizza reminds me of where I grew up in New England. They actually slice their onions like it should be done, not chunks. Their Philly cheese steaks are to die for. Best anywhere! ❤️
Brent S.
Always looking for high rated places in new places so opted here over another based on previous reviews while in town for a short getaway.
Ordered a small salad and a burger and fries for two. The salad was said to be good and did not taste like packaged lettuce. I thinks that’s good.
The burger was fresh although I’d advise asking for well if you like it that way. Fries were basic fries but very hot.
You can get the flavor of a small town in a small restaurant and my first impression of Cottonwood is it’s a friendly place. Every person who walked in while we dined in was greeted by name and had a usual. That’s means the place must be good. May come back in our short stay for the famed Philly Cheesesteak as it looked pretty good.
Cool artwork for sale on the wall too. Plenty of parking as they seem to claim everything in front of the place.
Good atmosphere and definitely Red Sox fans so this Angels fan had to endure but that’s easy this year as we just took 2 of 3 in Boston. lol
Kimba Clark
Very nice dining area, very clean. Pizza was nothing short of amazing. We had vegetable with steak. Hands down best pizza in Cottonwood.
Nancy Micielli
Every time I go to Acme, I bring somebody new and everybody has the same opinion of all their amazing food specially steak sandwich
Lisa
OMG WE CANNOT STOP EATING THIS PIZZA!!!!! Mediterranean and extra cheese. My daughter and I are obsessed. Sweetest people and phenomenal service. Can’t say enough good things!! This native Long Islander is hooked ☺️☺️
Leslie Pankey
Marinal pizza. Crust was premade. Green pepper was good, sausage not so much. Served on paper plates!? Don’t go for the pizza.
Mary Garner
I love this family owned pizza place the people that work here are amazing so nice and sweet. The service is perfect I love the friendly vibe you get when you walk in the doors. The food oh my the food is so good love it!!
R U
So happy to find a true back east pizza, lobster rolls, and clam strips! Service was friendly and everything was freshly prepared
Herb Dowler
We were looking for a family owned local pizzeria and found Acme. We ordered the New England clam chowder, a lobster roll and a pizza. Everything was amazing! The best part was the friendly service, a special message was even hand written on our pizza box! More than a week later we realized a jacket was left behind and sure enough I called and our server had put it away for us just waiting to be picked up! We can’t thank you enough for the hospitality!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll, Cheese Pizza
Craig Sipe
We passed through town with a large group looking for a highly rated local place to eat. From the moment we stepped into the establishment, the proprietors and staff gave exceptional service.
We ordered 3 pizzas, a meatball sub sandwich, fried avocado, fried zucchini, and drinks. Everything we ate was exceptional.
Also, the staff had to wait to close the restaurant for us.
Thank you Acme and staff for a tremendous experience. You are HIGHLY recommended.
Food was okay, they bread their wings . In which I'm not a fan of. , my kids got the kids meal, Mac and cheese is Kraft, pizza was ok. Nothing amazingly good. Seemed overly priced . And I'm probably not coming back.
The owners are amazing people and they have a great staff! To me, their pizza reminds me of where I grew up in New England. They actually slice their onions like it should be done, not chunks. Their Philly cheese steaks are to die for. Best anywhere! ❤️
Always looking for high rated places in new places so opted here over another based on previous reviews while in town for a short getaway.
Ordered a small salad and a burger and fries for two. The salad was said to be good and did not taste like packaged lettuce. I thinks that’s good.
The burger was fresh although I’d advise asking for well if you like it that way. Fries were basic fries but very hot.
You can get the flavor of a small town in a small restaurant and my first impression of Cottonwood is it’s a friendly place. Every person who walked in while we dined in was greeted by name and had a usual. That’s means the place must be good. May come back in our short stay for the famed Philly Cheesesteak as it looked pretty good.
Cool artwork for sale on the wall too. Plenty of parking as they seem to claim everything in front of the place.
Good atmosphere and definitely Red Sox fans so this Angels fan had to endure but that’s easy this year as we just took 2 of 3 in Boston. lol
Very nice dining area, very clean. Pizza was nothing short of amazing. We had vegetable with steak. Hands down best pizza in Cottonwood.
Every time I go to Acme, I bring somebody new and everybody has the same opinion of all their amazing food specially steak sandwich
OMG WE CANNOT STOP EATING THIS PIZZA!!!!! Mediterranean and extra cheese. My daughter and I are obsessed. Sweetest people and phenomenal service. Can’t say enough good things!! This native Long Islander is hooked ☺️☺️
Marinal pizza. Crust was premade. Green pepper was good, sausage not so much. Served on paper plates!? Don’t go for the pizza.
I love this family owned pizza place the people that work here are amazing so nice and sweet. The service is perfect I love the friendly vibe you get when you walk in the doors. The food oh my the food is so good love it!!
So happy to find a true back east pizza, lobster rolls, and clam strips!
Service was friendly and everything was freshly prepared
We were looking for a family owned local pizzeria and found Acme. We ordered the New England clam chowder, a lobster roll and a pizza. Everything was amazing! The best part was the friendly service, a special message was even hand written on our pizza box! More than a week later we realized a jacket was left behind and sure enough I called and our server had put it away for us just waiting to be picked up! We can’t thank you enough for the hospitality!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lobster Roll, Cheese Pizza
We passed through town with a large group looking for a highly rated local place to eat. From the moment we stepped into the establishment, the proprietors and staff gave exceptional service.
We ordered 3 pizzas, a meatball sub sandwich, fried avocado, fried zucchini, and drinks. Everything we ate was exceptional.
Also, the staff had to wait to close the restaurant for us.
Thank you Acme and staff for a tremendous experience. You are HIGHLY recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: French Fries
Restaurantji Recommends
Best GF pizza in town. Everything on the menu is a must try!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak, Bacon Cheeseburgah, French Fries, Wings, Onion Rings, Cheesesteak
Dietary restrictions: They offer vegan cheese, and were also happy to make a pizza without cheese for us, which was delicious.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great people & excellent food!! Highly recommend. Best pizza crust!! Seafood and burgers are all great. Extensive menu options.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Philly Cheese Steak, Cheese Pizza, French Fries, Wings, Veggie Pizza
Great place to sit down and eat
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was okay, they bread their wings . In which I'm not a fan of. , my kids got the kids meal, Mac and cheese is Kraft, pizza was ok. Nothing amazingly good. Seemed overly priced . And I'm probably not coming back.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Loading...