I recently got a burger here and it was really good considering they recently started serving burgers
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
DreamalityCreations
I'm a 9 year old and you guys have the best pizza and everything there and good prices ? and you guys are the best workers ever I mean it?and the games are good to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amanda
Went in to try the new burger today, it was amazing. So flavorful and so cheesy. Thanks Pizza Eagar for always being my go to place to eat. Yum ?
Steven Francis
We were directed here as the best pizza place in the Eager/Springerville area, and it was pretty good. The location is small, but easy to find. Service was awesome, they ended up making one of the pizzas larger than ordered, bonus for us! They also threw in a little extra for my son just because, which was totally unexpected. The place was super clean, pretty much all the cooking is done out in view of the patrons and they did a great job of cleaning between pies and avoiding cross- contamination and mess. If you're in the area, give them a try!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Meat Pizza
Michelle Ansbach
We've lived in AZ for many years. But, we are from back east. I grew up with Chicago pizza, he grew up with NY style pizza. We are pizza connoisseurs, or maybe just pizza addicts. We tried 3 other competitors in town and somehow, we had missed Pizza. One Sunday, we wanted pizza and discovered Pizza and saw they were open. Because certain other competitor's are closed Sundays. And, we watch sports on Sundays. Pizza is essential on Sundays. Needless to say, their competition lost out. This pizza is the best we have had in a while. It tastes like local east coast pizza. We absolutely won't go anywhere else now. My husband had the opportunity to meet the owner today. She was so kind and the pizza was perfect, as always. I've only met the other employees and they're always super nice. We're really excited that they are expanding. They will have a dining area with video games and big screen tvs so we can watch the super bowl. So, mark your calendars and be there! What a great way to meet your neighbors, eat amazing food and watch a great sporting event together.
The food: The food was genuinely good for many reasons. They used healthy ingredients so the food doesn't feel too heavy, but it fills you up well. The different flavors of wings mixed with the great types of pizza they can make definitely make this place worth trying out. Service: I was able to watch them make everything and they were very receptive to conversation (keep in mind I went at a time that wasn't too busy). They made sure to stay consistent and they were also very clean. Atmosphere: Very welcoming and very warm hearted people. It feels like when you're at a family cookout but obviously it's pizza instead of bbq. Overall: For a small town, this place is very good and it's honestly better than most places I've had while traveling, dining, or even in my home town. I definitely recommend coming through and eating here.
Vegetarian options: Obviously there is pizza, however, they were very willing to talk me through what they had and (even though I'm not vegetarian) they did say that they do have a decent selection in case I was.
Kid-friendliness: There are many games and it's pretty open so there is much space for kids to entertain themselves.
Pizza Eager! Pleasantly surprised on how well the food is! We ordered a large bacon & onion pizza and a dozen wings. Garlic parmesan wings were BOMB! Pizza was cooked perfectly. Service was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Pepper Wings
yamini ayachitam
We really loved the freshness of the pizza. This is the best pizza we have had in a long time!
Ricky Hodges
Came in with an Award for Student of the Month for my daughter, set the order and waited for it to be ready. The gentleman, handsome fella with the hat, who took our order was kind, more than happy to give not only my daughter the food her award got her, but he also gave myself and my son pizza as well, and drinks too. Definitely the friendliest pizza place in town, and always courteous. Great food, kind people and a good sense of community by giving awards to our children in the Elementary. 11/10 in my opinion.
Donny Armstrong
Please don't let the on going construction and lack of a proper dining area drive you away, this place Isa hidden gem! We dined in on Sept 24, ordered a medium peperoni and sausage pizza & 12 wings, mixed between teriyaki & garlic parmesan. Everything was cooked perfectly and was delicious! It was a pleasant surprise and we willbe back agin!
Get the Smash Burger!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Smash Burger
I recently got a burger here and it was really good considering they recently started serving burgers
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
I'm a 9 year old and you guys have the best pizza and everything there and good prices ? and you guys are the best workers ever I mean it?and the games are good to!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Went in to try the new burger today, it was amazing. So flavorful and so cheesy. Thanks Pizza Eagar for always being my go to place to eat. Yum ?
We were directed here as the best pizza place in the Eager/Springerville area, and it was pretty good. The location is small, but easy to find. Service was awesome, they ended up making one of the pizzas larger than ordered, bonus for us! They also threw in a little extra for my son just because, which was totally unexpected. The place was super clean, pretty much all the cooking is done out in view of the patrons and they did a great job of cleaning between pies and avoiding cross- contamination and mess. If you're in the area, give them a try!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Meat Pizza
We've lived in AZ for many years. But, we are from back east. I grew up with Chicago pizza, he grew up with NY style pizza. We are pizza connoisseurs, or maybe just pizza addicts. We tried 3 other competitors in town and somehow, we had missed Pizza. One Sunday, we wanted pizza and discovered Pizza and saw they were open. Because certain other competitor's are closed Sundays. And, we watch sports on Sundays. Pizza is essential on Sundays. Needless to say, their competition lost out. This pizza is the best we have had in a while. It tastes like local east coast pizza. We absolutely won't go anywhere else now. My husband had the opportunity to meet the owner today. She was so kind and the pizza was perfect, as always. I've only met the other employees and they're always super nice. We're really excited that they are expanding. They will have a dining area with video games and big screen tvs so we can watch the super bowl. So, mark your calendars and be there! What a great way to meet your neighbors, eat amazing food and watch a great sporting event together.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, XL Pizza, Meat Pizza
Awsome place, great food and fun place for the kids
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
They have good pizza here I will be coming back to eat here again!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, XL Pizza, Meat Pizza
The food: The food was genuinely good for many reasons. They used healthy ingredients so the food doesn't feel too heavy, but it fills you up well. The different flavors of wings mixed with the great types of pizza they can make definitely make this place worth trying out.
Service: I was able to watch them make everything and they were very receptive to conversation (keep in mind I went at a time that wasn't too busy). They made sure to stay consistent and they were also very clean.
Atmosphere: Very welcoming and very warm hearted people. It feels like when you're at a family cookout but obviously it's pizza instead of bbq.
Overall: For a small town, this place is very good and it's honestly better than most places I've had while traveling, dining, or even in my home town. I definitely recommend coming through and eating here.
Vegetarian options: Obviously there is pizza, however, they were very willing to talk me through what they had and (even though I'm not vegetarian) they did say that they do have a decent selection in case I was.
Kid-friendliness: There are many games and it's pretty open so there is much space for kids to entertain themselves.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Pepper Wings, Meat Pizza
Great pizza , sweet people, very helpful a little pricey but worth it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza Eager! Pleasantly surprised on how well the food is! We ordered a large bacon & onion pizza and a dozen wings. Garlic parmesan wings were BOMB! Pizza was cooked perfectly. Service was great.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Lemon Pepper Wings
We really loved the freshness of the pizza. This is the best pizza we have had in a long time!
Came in with an Award for Student of the Month for my daughter, set the order and waited for it to be ready. The gentleman, handsome fella with the hat, who took our order was kind, more than happy to give not only my daughter the food her award got her, but he also gave myself and my son pizza as well, and drinks too. Definitely the friendliest pizza place in town, and always courteous. Great food, kind people and a good sense of community by giving awards to our children in the Elementary. 11/10 in my opinion.
Please don't let the on going construction and lack of a proper dining area drive you away, this place Isa hidden gem!
We dined in on Sept 24, ordered a medium peperoni and sausage pizza & 12 wings, mixed between teriyaki & garlic parmesan. Everything was cooked perfectly and was delicious!
It was a pleasant surprise and we willbe back agin!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Lemon Pepper Wings
This is by far the best place in town for pizza and we highly recommend it!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...