Cream of the Crop Ice Cream Shop

This place never disappoints they always have fresh new seasonal flavors. Their staff is really friendly. I love that they always keep their signature flavor, cream of the crop because it’s my favorite!

I can’t believe how crisp and pure the cream of the crop tap water tastes alongside this ice cream; it’s like a mini palate cleanser between rich bites. The chocolate flavor is hands-down my favorite, with deep, bittersweet cocoa notes that never feel too heavy. Honestly, sipping that clean water then diving back into velvety chocolate feels like a perfectly choreographed dance for your taste buds.

This store having anything below a 5 star review is a disservice to any potential customers looking to come to this ice cream parlor. This is absolutely amazing ice cream! Nothing more can be said about this aside from you MUST eat here.

Love this ice cream 🍦

There’s something wonderfully unexpected about grabbing a glass of tap water at Cream of the Crop—an ice cream haven in Gilbert. From the very first sip, you notice a crisp smoothness. Perfectly chilled, it offers instant relief from Arizona’s heat, making it feel like a mini oasis alongside your sweet treat.

This refreshing water also does wonders for your palate. After each delightful scoop—whether vegan dark chocolate or starry night—a sip resets your taste buds and amplifies every nuance. By the time you finish your cone, the tap water at Cream of the Crop feels like the perfect complement to every flavor.

The best. By a mile.

Awesome little ice cream shop tucked away in the agritopia area. Small selection of flavors, but extremely tasty.

Awesome place! Their homemade ice cream is a hit. I tried the Reese's swirl and my husband had the Almond Joy. Both were absolutely delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: 2 Scoop of Ice Cream, Gelato

Such a cute lil shop and on the day we stopped by the employee was the BEST!

He quickly greeted us and told us he would be right with us as he was already helping another couple out. Once our turn, he asked us how our day was going and if we wanted any samples.

We ended up getting the cherry lemon flavored one in a cup and the cream of the crop / cookies and crème in a cone. All three flavors we picked were delicious. They were creamy and just the right amount of sweetness.

The inside is small but very cute. The décor is one of a kind! We will be back!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The vegan dark chocolate ice cream was so rich and delicious!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great ice cream nice little shop! Entire family loves this place! 5 out of 5!

The ice cream was so good - especially the mint chip! They said the mint comes from the farm nearby. So fresh!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Agritopia Mint Chocolate Chip

Ice cream was very tasty and had a nice creamy texture. My husband had cream of the crop which was a vanilla Cheesecake with a hint of lime and I tried the vegan dark chocolate! Both delicious!! We did have a hard time finding it at first but it’s inside Barnone. Will come again!

Best ice cream in the Valley!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I will never drink water from anywhere else ever again. The tap water here is delicious and cannot be replicated anywhere else. From now on all of my drinking water will be sourced from Cream of the Crop.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5