Fried Style! We tried cream of the crop ice cream tonight after dining at Belly nearby and the ice cream is amazing. The vegan chocolate is rich and delicious but the lemon cream pie ice cream...fried style was amazing. Fried style is better than any fried ice cream we've tried before. Can't wait to come back and try it again!
Amanda C.
Delicious ice cream tucked away in a cool marketplace. Got the cookies n cream and mr. Turtle! The cookies n cream was one of the best cookies n cream I tried - lots of cookies mixed in and creamy texture. Mr. Turtle is great if you love chocolate and pretzels. Had caramel too for a sweet and slightly salty taste. Wish I lived closer!
Gabrielle
The owner is really cool and the ice cream is so delicious can’t wait to go back and try more!!!
Michelle D.
Absolutely our favorite ice cream spot! Most ice creams bother my stomach but for some reason this place doesn't and I am so thankful! It's delicious! Love all their unique flavors and their cones are to die for! Service is always friendly and helpful and I just love the creativity of the flavors. Best hidden gem in Gilbert!! Must try!!
Erin R.
So fresh and delicious, our go to ice cream shop in Gilbert! It's pricey splurge but it's better than any chain ice cream shop.
Wendy Rodriguez
Went in tonight for the second time. Kids said they wanted to go back so we took them. My daughter a 6 year old tapped the glass to Point out what flavor she wanted and and the employee working that night Lillie looked at her and said please don’t touch the glass. How else is your kid supposed to let you know what flavor she wants. I guess the glass doesn’t get cleaned or is too much to add to her to do list. Absolutely won’t be back! Instead of showing customer service it was the complete opposite.
Food: 4
Tracey Wise
Sweetest Ice Cream Shop Ever!!! Great service. Very Welcoming. Unique Ice Cream Flavors. This shop put Joy in my mouth. London Fog Vegan Ice Cream. Earl Grey, Lavender, Orange Zest. It's a mouth full of Joy. Thank you Cream of the Crop. Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vee Zon
We absolutely LOVE cream of the crop. Their flavor choices are spot on.Yesterday I had a winter white - which chocolate, lime, and pink peppercorn - chef's kiss.Their portions are generous and the vibe is really cute. If you love coffee ice cream, they paired up with Peixoto for an incredible flavor.They often do seasonal flavors so follow their instagram to know about the latest drop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 2 Scoop of Ice Cream
Jennifer V.
When I scream, you scream, we all scream for IcE CREAM! What a delightful experience at Cream of the crop this week! We enjoyed it so much we came back for more two times in one week. We visited for the first time on Wednesday and brought new friends tonight. I loved that Romain- the amazing employee that helped us out on Wednesday remembered who we were 2 days later. He was so nice and excited about telling us the flavors. The ice cream shop was small and cute inside Barone. The vibes were super cute! Turns out the flavors change often too. Looking forward to see what new flavors are offered the next time we are back.
Rebecca K.
I love going to this place and it is my favorite ice cream in the world. But recently they went up $1 and it feels like I dont see any size increase, and most of the time the ice cream doesn't even fill the small size of the cup and barely looks 4 ounces. I wish there was some way they could be more consistent with the size especially for 6$ price tag for a small.
When it comes to ice cream, this spot really is my Cream of the Crop. The best way to top off a relaxing day in Agritopia, which is truly becoming a hot spot in Gilbert, is by enjoying a couple delicious scoops from this Barnone vendor! The Peixoto coffee (no surprise) is one of the best coffee ice creams I've had -- strong yet creamy and made with high-quality local beans. But if you're at Cream of the Crop, you *must* try their unique flavors. They won't disappoint. One of their current rotating flavors is made with a blend of white chocolate, pink peppercorns, and lime, and I was sooo pleasantly surprised at the taste. I had to get a scoop! There isn't a lot of seating, but there are a ton of local restaurants, vendors, and bars to check out, all within a 5 minute walk in the lot while you enjoy your ice cream. I can't wait to come back and try more flavors!
Jaimie L.
This is hands down the best icecream I've had in Arizona- the vegan dark chocolate tastes like cake batter and the seasonal flavors are so high quality and delicious!
General Blitz (bry)
Wow just wow. Came here by accident and I ate the best mint icecream I have ever tried in my whole life. Everything else just pales in comparison. Everyone needs to try this place, super homemade, you never tasted ice cream that felt so fresh and organic lol
an idiot
ice cream is good and the place is adorable!! i love the little origami cranes ♡
Tim H.
I mean cmon. Ice cream that is delicious. What more do you want. Small batch. Rotating flavors. Settled away in the Barnone place it's great. So far every staff member has been really nice and informative of the flavors. Samples available. No seating inside as it's really a counter shop and walk around kinda vibe. Definitely will come back to try more.
Fried Style! We tried cream of the crop ice cream tonight after dining at Belly nearby and the ice cream is amazing. The vegan chocolate is rich and delicious but the lemon cream pie ice cream...fried style was amazing. Fried style is better than any fried ice cream we've tried before. Can't wait to come back and try it again!
Delicious ice cream tucked away in a cool marketplace. Got the cookies n cream and mr. Turtle! The cookies n cream was one of the best cookies n cream I tried - lots of cookies mixed in and creamy texture. Mr. Turtle is great if you love chocolate and pretzels. Had caramel too for a sweet and slightly salty taste. Wish I lived closer!
The owner is really cool and the ice cream is so delicious can’t wait to go back and try more!!!
Absolutely our favorite ice cream spot! Most ice creams bother my stomach but for some reason this place doesn't and I am so thankful! It's delicious! Love all their unique flavors and their cones are to die for! Service is always friendly and helpful and I just love the creativity of the flavors. Best hidden gem in Gilbert!! Must try!!
So fresh and delicious, our go to ice cream shop in Gilbert! It's pricey splurge but it's better than any chain ice cream shop.
Went in tonight for the second time. Kids said they wanted to go back so we took them. My daughter a 6 year old tapped the glass to Point out what flavor she wanted and and the employee working that night Lillie looked at her and said please don’t touch the glass. How else is your kid supposed to let you know what flavor she wants. I guess the glass doesn’t get cleaned or is too much to add to her to do list. Absolutely won’t be back! Instead of showing customer service it was the complete opposite.
Food: 4
Sweetest Ice Cream Shop Ever!!! Great service. Very Welcoming. Unique Ice Cream Flavors. This shop put Joy in my mouth. London Fog Vegan Ice Cream. Earl Grey, Lavender, Orange Zest. It's a mouth full of Joy. Thank you Cream of the Crop. Highly
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We absolutely LOVE cream of the crop. Their flavor choices are spot on.Yesterday I had a winter white - which chocolate, lime, and pink peppercorn - chef's kiss.Their portions are generous and the vibe is really cute. If you love coffee ice cream, they paired up with Peixoto for an incredible flavor.They often do seasonal flavors so follow their instagram to know about the latest drop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: 2 Scoop of Ice Cream
When I scream, you scream, we all scream for IcE CREAM! What a delightful experience at Cream of the crop this week! We enjoyed it so much we came back for more two times in one week. We visited for the first time on Wednesday and brought new friends tonight. I loved that Romain- the amazing employee that helped us out on Wednesday remembered who we were 2 days later. He was so nice and excited about telling us the flavors. The ice cream shop was small and cute inside Barone. The vibes were super cute! Turns out the flavors change often too. Looking forward to see what new flavors are offered the next time we are back.
I love going to this place and it is my favorite ice cream in the world. But recently they went up $1 and it feels like I dont see any size increase, and most of the time the ice cream doesn't even fill the small size of the cup and barely looks 4 ounces. I wish there was some way they could be more consistent with the size especially for 6$ price tag for a small.
Restaurantji Recommends
When it comes to ice cream, this spot really is my Cream of the Crop. The best way to top off a relaxing day in Agritopia, which is truly becoming a hot spot in Gilbert, is by enjoying a couple delicious scoops from this Barnone vendor! The Peixoto coffee (no surprise) is one of the best coffee ice creams I've had -- strong yet creamy and made with high-quality local beans. But if you're at Cream of the Crop, you *must* try their unique flavors. They won't disappoint. One of their current rotating flavors is made with a blend of white chocolate, pink peppercorns, and lime, and I was sooo pleasantly surprised at the taste. I had to get a scoop! There isn't a lot of seating, but there are a ton of local restaurants, vendors, and bars to check out, all within a 5 minute walk in the lot while you enjoy your ice cream. I can't wait to come back and try more flavors!
This is hands down the best icecream I've had in Arizona- the vegan dark chocolate tastes like cake batter and the seasonal flavors are so high quality and delicious!
Wow just wow. Came here by accident and I ate the best mint icecream I have ever tried in my whole life. Everything else just pales in comparison. Everyone needs to try this place, super homemade, you never tasted ice cream that felt so fresh and organic lol
ice cream is good and the place is adorable!! i love the little origami cranes ♡
I mean cmon. Ice cream that is delicious. What more do you want. Small batch. Rotating flavors. Settled away in the Barnone place it's great. So far every staff member has been really nice and informative of the flavors. Samples available. No seating inside as it's really a counter shop and walk around kinda vibe. Definitely will come back to try more.