NY Pizza Department

2743 S Market St #101, Gilbert
(480) 782-6973

Recent Reviews

Proxy 2431 (ALEXGABEZ)

Dawson the Manager went above and beyond, not only did we pickup just at close, we were missing an item and he immediately allowed for us to come back in and pick it up! 10/10 service ???

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lina Lee

After running errands we decided to check this place out for lunch and I’m glad we did!They have a very good assortment of pizzas you can buy by the slice. Many different types of lunch combos and I decided to get a slice of their Bianca pizza as I love ricotta, and a specialty salad. I was told I could even afford on additional toppings. So I added sausage and pepperoni- this was a flavor bomb. Delish!I also got a crispy chicken spinach salad as part of the lunch combo. I was very impressed with the amount of warm crispy perfectly seasoned chicken. With every bite I got spinach, bacon, red onion, mushrooms, sliced almonds, mozzarella and chicken. Also loved the dressing. It was light yet flavorful. Though it was a small sized salad, it was extremely satisfying and I was very full.The staff is very friendly and the manager even stopped by our table and asked how everything was.They have a self serve drink section and even have a very cute bar with a couple of TV’s.Really nice pizza restaurant with great food, service, and ambience.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Brooklyn Family Pizza Pepperoni

Paula Fow

Clean and fast.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carson Haley

Best pizza in the Valley!??

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Briana C.

In town for a softball tournament, followed the Yelp reviews to this spot, which was only a few minutes from our hotel. I called an order in right before they were closing and they were super sweet and accommodating. I got a large margherita pizza, garlic knots and a Caesar salad. Everything was delicious. I'd def go back!

Sarah Ee

We ordered from here on Valentines and the food was delicious. We ordered a large calzone, wings and a cheese pizza. They are #1 on my list. Their wing sauce is really good!! And the cute drawings on the to go box was super cute for Valentines.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Al Capone Calzone

Kristi S.

We ordered a Sicilian pizza and cheese garlic knots for takeout this evening. My husband got home and what was supposed to be a half pepperoni and mushroom and half cheese only, was half pepperoni and half mushroom. The girl who took the order on the phone, even repeated it back so it was not a misunderstanding. Also, invest in the little plastic things that prevent the box from hitting the pizza. Half the toppings came off and were stuck all over the top of the box. The garlic knots we barely cooked. The kicker was that when my husband called in to say that the pizza was incorrect, all the girl said was "oh sorry." Seriously? No offers to remake it correctly? Reimburse something? A future pizza? Nothing. Just a sorry and hangs up.

Lina L.

After running errands decided to check this place out for lunch and I'm glad I did! They have a very good assortment of pizzas you can buy by the slice. Many different types of lunch combos and I decided to get a slice of their Blanca pizza as I love ricotta, and a specialty salad. I was told I could even add on additional topping! So I added sausage and pepperoni- this was a flavor bomb. DELISH! I also got a crispy chicken spinach salad as part of the lunch combo. I was very impressed with the amount of warm crispy perfectly seasoned chicken. With every bite I got spinach, bacon, red onion, mushrooms, sliced almonds, mozzarella and chicken. Also loved the dressing, it was light yet flavorful. Though it was a small sized salad, it was extremely satisfying and I was very full. The staff is very friendly, and the manager even stopped by our table and asked how everything was. They have a self serve drink section and even have a very cute bar area with a a couple TV's. Really nice pizza restaurant. Great food, service, and nice ambience.

bernie m.

I am very impressed with this business! After my not so great experience last time, Nikki W, their business customer service rep, reached out to me. She mailed me an apology card along with a dining certificate for two lunch specials! Wow, very impressed with the follow through and the service. Today I went back and had a completely different experience from my last visit. The cashier even told me I could add any toppings onto their ready made slices since they're going to heat it anyway. I never knew that was an option! I added pepperoni and sausage to the supreme slice, and added mushrooms to the pepperoni slice. The supreme slice was so filling and satisfying that I had to box up the other slice. I've always liked their pizza and now that I know how great their customer service is, this establishment will be my go to for pizza.

Josh & Tricia Tranel

Excellent service! Pizza crust was the best I've ever had!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, Brooklyn Family

Charles Montgomery

My favorite pizza and their mozzarella is phenomenal.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza

Becky George

I honestly enjoyed our pizza! It was so hot and cheesy with the accessibility of table Parmesan, red pepper flanked and oregano. It’s just a bit pricey and prepare to wait at least $20 minutes for your pizza to be prepared. You can always order carry-out!

BJ T

Ordered a personal pizza for lunch. It was delicious! Great flavor and generous toppings. The staff were very friendly when I picked up and food was hot and ready when on time.

Food: 5

Service: 5

Brian Keith

Super friendly staff. I run a service truck, and am not the cleanest usually. I hate saying it, as I personally feel no one should be judged on appearance, but it's rare that I can walk into an establishment after a day's work, and be treated better than if I tried to order something at a fast food place... Keep up the great work, and thanks for a great meal, and service!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Jacob Heide

Everything from the service to the food here is top notch.We got the vinnys special and Tomato Pesto pizza. They said they messed up the Tomato pesto and instead made it a large for having to wait, and I wasn't even upset about the time as it had been within 30 min our order came to us and they gave us large cups while wait.It only FELT long as all of the food coming out to the people sitting down to eat looked and smelled incredible.Took our Za's home and it is hands down the absolute BEST pizza I have ever had. You'll pay a bit for the pizzas, but lemme tell you it couldn't be more worth it.We came here on a whim and I am very surprised with the quality of the food. The customer service was great, but we only put an order in tor take out. The wait staff looked and sounded great though and all of the other customers looked and sounded very satisfied.I will go nowhere else for pizza going forward.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Load More