We found Amici Pizza through TikTok, and it definitely lived up to the hype! The vodka sauce pizza was absolutely delicious, and the cheesy garlic knots were amazing. I love how you could build your own pizza and combine two flavors together. It was a little busy, so we had to wait for a bit, but the food was well worth it. On top of that, the prices feel like a really good deal for the quality. I would definitely come back and recommend it to anyone looking for great pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
alexaa diaz
Was excited to try this place out since going viral. Walking in were greeted and sat and got our drinks taken. Maybe it was a bad day to get a shirley temple but it forsure didn’t live up to its crispiness they hype about. About 15 mins we get our order taken. We order a half hawaiian half buffalo chicken pizza and fried mushroom/zucchini mix. The appetizers were pretty good. The pizza was definitely something with how salty it was and how skimpy they are with toppings . each slice only had about 4 slices of tiny chicken. the other half was the same with ham. we did ask for extra sauce on our pizza im not sure how that was missed. the server acknowledged us about 2 times and just flew by hopping we didnt need anything. nobody really smiled at you in there not even the owner. This place is nothing special in my opinion, there’s always better somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
James Pinnick
Ordered two large and pasta. Slices had one pepperoni on each slice. Sausage had 2 piece on each slice. Minimal cheese woth bare spots. Son asked for a little pizza sauce dip that was 75 cents extra. If you're coming to QC to hold customers, this was a rough one. How would I come back and give you another $71? Being cheap on ingredients is one thing, but trying to cut costs already is not good. We order pizza weekly but won't here. Folks find another place for your dollars.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
Kerri Barrett
The place smells amazing the second you walk in, and the vibe feels like New York but way cleaner. The service was outstanding, the food was delicious with big portions at fair prices, and they even gave my son pizza dough to play with which was such a nice touch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Isa Ay
was in the area, and decided to stop by here for the first time ever. coming in the restaurant we were seated immediately since there wasn’t many people in the dining room. ordered some pastas, some appetizers, and a slice of speciality pizza. Appetizers came out first which were the garlic knots & mozzarella sticks. Garlic knots were swimming in oil, looked very unappealing & had an overpowering smell of garlic. however, we ate them and the taste & flavor wasn’t there either. Pastas are supposed to come with a side salad & bread yet when the pastas came out they were missing them completely. Shrimp scampi was drowned in oil & again looked very unappealing. Shrimp shells were left on each shrimp piece I got, which was only about 4 (we counted them) LOL. salad came out after we had to ask and remind them of it. The Caesar salad was nothing special, more edible than the garlic knots or mozzarella sticks. It looked like they threw it together & were like “here damn” just to shut me up. Service was okish, kind of felt like we were forgotten & the server didn’t pay close attention to see that we were missing things. Overall food was very MID and NOT WORTH THE HYPE AT ALL. very upset I spent money on a mid ass meal. Save your money and go elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Amber Walker
Best fettuccine alfredo in the valley!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Christian Lara
Both times that I have gone have been amazing the food is always delicious and the staff services was great always checking in to see if anything was needed! Definitely give this place a try and you won't regret it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
mad tel
I was really looking forward to trying Amici Pizza, but unfortunately I was disappointed. I ordered medium wings and they came with barely a teaspoon of sauce—practically plain and dry. The wings looked naked with almost no flavor. Since my order was delivered, I wasn’t expecting piping hot food, but I was still let down when everything arrived cold. My dasher mentioned there had been a delay on amici’s end, the food wasn’t ready in time, but even then the food should not have been this cold. Overall, I had higher expectations and was really looking forward to this meal, but it just didn’t deliver. Sadly, I wouldn’t recommend.
Food: 2
Andres Francisco
First time trying this place and it did not disappoint, definitely recommend.
Sadly I need to revise this down a bit. They no longer have a selection of fresh slices after 3, and what they serve is pretty dry stale. Slices are the telltale signs of a pizza shops quality, and sadly Amici has fallen into the same spiral that killed Buono's here.
Great place for traditional NYC pizza. For a while this place had gone downhill but the old management is back and the great quality is back as well. I highly recommend Buono's when you really want a good simple slice of pizza.
Dominick Alcorta
Gotta be the best pizza in the valley and the zeppoles are a great way to cap off the meal for desert.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erin Seitz
I wanted to love this place but between the amount of grease and and lack of condiments it just isnt happening, and I've tried both locations. 4 out of 6 of us diners got sick from the amount of grease/oil thats used. Stomachs were out of commission for 2 days before full meals could be ate again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
Mark Pryor
We came in Sunday afternoon. It was very busy but We were sat right away (party of 5). We ordered two waters, three sodas, the garlic knots a large pizza and an anti pasta salad. We wanted to try the basics to see if it was worth coming back too, and we will be coming back. Everything was amazing from the food to the service and the atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Emerie Guzman
Food was delicious and service was great. Definitely worth all the hype on it
We found Amici Pizza through TikTok, and it definitely lived up to the hype! The vodka sauce pizza was absolutely delicious, and the cheesy garlic knots were amazing. I love how you could build your own pizza and combine two flavors together. It was a little busy, so we had to wait for a bit, but the food was well worth it. On top of that, the prices feel like a really good deal for the quality. I would definitely come back and recommend it to anyone looking for great pizza.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Was excited to try this place out since going viral. Walking in were greeted and sat and got our drinks taken. Maybe it was a bad day to get a shirley temple but it forsure didn’t live up to its crispiness they hype about. About 15 mins we get our order taken. We order a half hawaiian half buffalo chicken pizza and fried mushroom/zucchini mix. The appetizers were pretty good. The pizza was definitely something with how salty it was and how skimpy they are with toppings . each slice only had about 4 slices of tiny chicken. the other half was the same with ham. we did ask for extra sauce on our pizza im not sure how that was missed. the server acknowledged us about 2 times and just flew by hopping we didnt need anything. nobody really smiled at you in there not even the owner. This place is nothing special in my opinion, there’s always better somewhere else.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Ordered two large and pasta. Slices had one pepperoni on each slice. Sausage had 2 piece on each slice. Minimal cheese woth bare spots. Son asked for a little pizza sauce dip that was 75 cents extra. If you're coming to QC to hold customers, this was a rough one. How would I come back and give you another $71? Being cheap on ingredients is one thing, but trying to cut costs already is not good. We order pizza weekly but won't here. Folks find another place for your dollars.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 2
The place smells amazing the second you walk in, and the vibe feels like New York but way cleaner. The service was outstanding, the food was delicious with big portions at fair prices, and they even gave my son pizza dough to play with which was such a nice touch.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
was in the area, and decided to stop by here for the first time ever. coming in the restaurant we were seated immediately since there wasn’t many people in the dining room. ordered some pastas, some appetizers, and a slice of speciality pizza. Appetizers came out first which were the garlic knots & mozzarella sticks. Garlic knots were swimming in oil, looked very unappealing & had an overpowering smell of garlic. however, we ate them and the taste & flavor wasn’t there either. Pastas are supposed to come with a side salad & bread yet when the pastas came out they were missing them completely. Shrimp scampi was drowned in oil & again looked very unappealing. Shrimp shells were left on each shrimp piece I got, which was only about 4 (we counted them) LOL. salad came out after we had to ask and remind them of it. The Caesar salad was nothing special, more edible than the garlic knots or mozzarella sticks. It looked like they threw it together & were like “here damn” just to shut me up. Service was okish, kind of felt like we were forgotten & the server didn’t pay close attention to see that we were missing things. Overall food was very MID and NOT WORTH THE HYPE AT ALL. very upset I spent money on a mid ass meal. Save your money and go elsewhere.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Best fettuccine alfredo in the valley!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Both times that I have gone have been amazing the food is always delicious and the staff services was great always checking in to see if anything was needed! Definitely give this place a try and you won't regret it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I was really looking forward to trying Amici Pizza, but unfortunately I was disappointed. I ordered medium wings and they came with barely a teaspoon of sauce—practically plain and dry. The wings looked naked with almost no flavor. Since my order was delivered, I wasn’t expecting piping hot food, but I was still let down when everything arrived cold. My dasher mentioned there had been a delay on amici’s end, the food wasn’t ready in time, but even then the food should not have been this cold. Overall, I had higher expectations and was really looking forward to this meal, but it just didn’t deliver. Sadly, I wouldn’t recommend.
Food: 2
First time trying this place and it did not disappoint, definitely recommend.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Worth all the hype. So good!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Sadly I need to revise this down a bit. They no longer have a selection of fresh slices after 3, and what they serve is pretty dry stale.
Slices are the telltale signs of a pizza shops quality, and sadly Amici has fallen into the same spiral that killed Buono's here.
Great place for traditional NYC pizza.
For a while this place had gone downhill but the old management is back and the great quality is back as well. I highly recommend Buono's when you really want a good simple slice of pizza.
Gotta be the best pizza in the valley and the zeppoles are a great way to cap off the meal for desert.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I wanted to love this place but between the amount of grease and and lack of condiments it just isnt happening, and I've tried both locations. 4 out of 6 of us diners got sick from the amount of grease/oil thats used. Stomachs were out of commission for 2 days before full meals could be ate again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 3
We came in Sunday afternoon. It was very busy but We were sat right away (party of 5). We ordered two waters, three sodas, the garlic knots a large pizza and an anti pasta salad. We wanted to try the basics to see if it was worth coming back too, and we will be coming back. Everything was amazing from the food to the service and the atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Food was delicious and service was great. Definitely worth all the hype on it
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...