Brooklyn New York Pizza & Wings I

Don't get lost! Its inside the gas station. I can't believe how tasty the Gramma PIZZA was! And the onion rings were crispy and hot.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 5

Service: 5

Bit pricey for a couple slices, but the food was very, very, good. I can't think of another place where you can customize each slice. Highly reccomended. Super fresh ingredients.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Horrible wife got super sick off the food and they said we were liars.. Also if you order on slice the food looks nothing like the pics they have on there.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

7/28/25 Review at end:
This place, tucked in a little gas station is great! Best wings for MILES and I'm from Buffalo! The pizza is made in a pizza oven with great ingredients. The owner, from Brooklynn, takes pride in everything he creates. Beware, this place gets BUSY!

Update: We live in the neighborhood and frequent the gas station multiple times a week. We were crushed when Brooklynn Pizza was sold to a young couple without business experience. Although they were trained by the owner, they did not retain what they learned. Quality went down even though the ingredients remained the same. What was missing, was experience and that New York pride that went into every dish.

I don't think they made it a year before it was sold again. I don't know how many people are involved but there is generally just one man in the restaurant. As regulars of that gas station, I can tell you I wouldn't eat there if you paid me. The things you can see hanging out looking through that giant window is just scary. Sanitation, food handling, personal cleanliness... Scary.
The telling tale is The lack of customers. Rarely do we ever see more than one person or couple waiting for their food, and the days of stacks of pizzas to be delivered are long gone.
I'm still not found another pie as good as the original Brooklyn Pizza here in Mesa. The quest continues...

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Authentic New York Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza, Pizza with Mushrooms

We'll, it's a pizza place in back of a gas station.. we had some boneless wings. They were like meatballs but made of chicken - something we could probably find in the frozen section of Costco or Sam's 🤷‍♂️

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Our family decided to try out a new pizza place and enjoyed the food! It did take extra time to wait post estimated pick up time, so I would schedule your order an hour ahead of time - but with two people working & the amount of orders coming in - working all with a smile positive interaction - was impressive! We enjoyed the wings, grandmas pizza, meat lovers and cheese bread along with cannolis for dessert it was all good!

Good pizza. But the guy cooking everything is super slow. Order an hour ahead. When I showed up he hadn't even starting cooking the pizza. Waited nearly 30 minutes more. Some help is needed.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 4

Service: 1

Food was delivered late and cold. Pizza was cut in squares. Bone in wings was burnt and very very salty. Called restaurant they said to contact Grub Hub. Will never order anything from this place. They just don't care. Very poor Attitude .....

Food: 1

Service: 1

Read the review of a lady going in for her pizza and them not starting until she gets there. I called my order in bc they didn't refund her via app. I went in 30 minutes later and they still had not started. They wanted me to wait another 10 minutes. I canceled and walked out. I was told 15 to 20 minutes is all it would take and I arrived30 min. later. One other person was there waiting for their order and another just ordered.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Best gas station pizza I've had in Mesa!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

You know, for a place inside a convenience store I wasn't expecting much the first time I ordered. However, this is now our go-to pizza! It is always good and hot. The fellas that work there are very nice and friendly. Definitely recommend of you want some good pizza.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

You won't believe how good this pizza is. Give it a try, you won't be disappointed.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Authentic New York Pizza

Delivery drivers do not get paid to wait.This place never ever has the order ready, please adjust your times so you're not requesting. Doordash or grubhub to pick up the order if it's not ready

Add 45 min to any time they give you at this place. The pizza is not worth the wait.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

I ordered a pizza, wings and a salad for 50 bucks from this place thru the online app slice. I like to support local businesses over big businesses. I didn’t order it ASAP because I had an errand to run before I picked up the order. I walked in the door 5 minutes before the order was supposed to be done and waited 5 minutes before the only person working came to the front. He asked me what my name was and looked up my order. He then walked to the fridge and grabbed some pizza dough and started tossing it. He stopped tossing it and got another pizza out of the oven and sliced it up and handed it to another customer. He told me he was getting my order ready and walked back to the dough. I then asked him if that was my pizza and he said yes. I told him it was supped to be ready at 6 not just getting started and then I told him to cancel my order and I wanted my money back. He said he could not cancel the order because I ordered it thru Slice. I then called Slice and asked for a refund because my order was nowhere close to being ready to pick up. They put me on hold and called him, he told them he would not authorize my refund because my order had been started already! He had pulled out the dough 5 minutes after I walked in the door! I am now waiting for slice to refund my order! I get it, small business is hard especially restaurants. All this guy had to do was tell me the truth and say he is by himself and behind! But no he lied to me and the Slice person! DO NOT GO HERE!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1