That's Amore Gelato

I haven’t been here for 6 months since trying the new owners recipe and service. It’s not the same as the original. And look at the owners responses on n the 1 and 2 star reviews. He never takes responsibility. Always the customer is wrong and tells them not to come back. His attitude is horrible. Go try Allora at Shea & Scottsdale. You’ll be happy.

Best gelato in Arizona. Very friendly service too.

I had an absolutely delightful experience at Amore Gelato! The gelato was creamy, bursting with authentic flavors, and made with clear passion. The staff was warm, welcoming, and eager to help me pick the perfect scoop. The cozy atmosphere and charming decor made it a perfect spot to indulge. Highly recommend this gem for anyone craving a sweet treat done right!

Enjoy espresso and limoncello gelato
So good. So Italy.!!!!
I always visit.

We love the gelato here. We even recently tried the gelato cake and it made my husband's birthday even more memorable. High quality service and gelato.

High quality authentic Italian gelato. Feels like you’re in Italy. And the staff is always super friendly. Love coming here

Cannot recommend this place enough. I lived in Italy for 6 months and this gelato is some of the best, if not the best I’ve had in Arizona. Prices are great and you can taste the quality in the gelato.

Amazing gelato. That’s all you need to know. I highly recommend if in the area. The Lemon sorbet is the best favorite in my opinion

Authentic delicious and great variety

Very authentic Italian gelato, desserts, music and ambience
Gelato is fresh and delicious. Many many flavors

Betty is the nicest person!

The server had a very special personality and was so upbeat and kind and customer oriented. She was amazing. She was running the show by herself. The gelato there is great! Really love this institution.

The gelato here is excellent, the atmosphere is charmingly old fashioned, and the service is top notch. Betty did a great job of managing a staggering number of orders single handedly while making sure every guest was having a good time. I will certainly be back.

Used to be Amazing—Now Sadly Disappointing
We used to love this place when it was owned by the original Italian siblings, but sadly it’s not the same anymore. We haven’t been back often since it changed hands, but stopped by tonight and were really let down. The stracciatella tasted more like plain vanilla—no visible chocolate shavings, and the flavor was flat. The coffee gelato was just as disappointing—barely any flavor at all. Banana was the only one that was passable.

At nearly $13 for two small gelatos, we expected something worth finishing, but instead ended up tossing most of it in the trash. Not sure we’ll be returning.

update to your response:

Given the noticeable drop in quality of your gelato, I can’t say I’m surprised by the tone of your response. Instead of addressing the real issue—flavor and quality—you deflected with a defensive reply that only reinforces my point. Stracciatella without visible chocolate and a coffee flavor that barely registers are not minor misses, especially from a place we’ve supported for over a decade. Your dismissiveness isn’t just disappointing—it’s telling. If this is how you handle honest feedback, it’s no wonder the gelato isn’t what it used to be.

This is the best gelato in Scottsdale.