Buffalo Bill's Tavern & Museum

Great location, food and service just as you get into Show Low! Looks like they host fun activities too in the evenings so we will be back

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This was the third time we visited this restaurant in three years and it has gone downhill from the beginning. My husband ordered a cheesesteak sandwich without peppers and they totally overloaded it with onions. The meat was dry and tasteless. His macaroni and cheese was OK. I ordered the half rotisserie chicken Lemon herb flavor. The skin was incredibly salty. The asparagus was very undercooked and tasted partially raw. And the corn on the cob was chewy – dry and overcooked. Service was fine but we will not go back. The food was subpar and the prices were higher than they were a year ago. Don’t waste your money and don’t waste your time. We were very disappointed.

Great steak and BBQ and great atmosphere and staff

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I ordered the cheese steak sandwich, Fry's and a craft beer. IT was great. Service was very good. The hole group had fun and left full and happy 😊. Stopped at the tap room for some to go 🍺.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

We were traveling through Show Low with our dog and were thrilled to discover there is a dog-friendly patio at Buffalo Bills. The grilled chicken artichoke pesto flatbread was amazing- my husband and I were fighting for the last piece. We also shared the brisket sandwich and it was soooo good! The fries were also top tier. The patio is spacious and was perfect for our anxious pup as she was able to be near us but distanced from other guests. We also played corn hole on one of the 3 sets. The patio is well-designed, clean, and the owners thought of every detail for an enjoyable time! We loved our time spent at Buffalo Bills and plan to swing back by to visit the museum on our return trip!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

It must of been an off day. Pork tenderloin was the driest ever. Steaks were undercooked, potatoes were cold. Service was nice but completely unknowable of the food items. Atmosphere was ok outside, better inside. Just because of the food itself, wouldn't recommend and will not come back

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 2

Multiple places to eat and hang out here. From small tasting room, to tavern style dining, nice indoor dining, large nice bar, a couple patios...pick your vibe. Food was good at the tavern. Had tuna melt, wings and a tasty pilsner. My buddy had 2 beer flight's and loved, or at least like them all. 2nd time here, and would go again.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Injoy old west atmosphere . The nostalgic history brings back days of my childhood.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Good food and service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 5

We went in for my birthday. Monique, in the grill side, was our server and was excellent! The food had amazing presentation as well as quality and flavor. Portions were perfect! My cocktail was prepared perfectly as ordered.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I was with a group. The food and Service was outstanding. I really enjoyed the western and Wm. Cody memoribila.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Was a fun place to eat. The museum was very interesting.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 4

Went to dinner here for a friends birthday. The food was excellant and our server was great. She joked around with us and brought my friend a free desert for her birthday. Was a great experience and will definitely be back.

Fun place. Great food!

I ordered two meals for takeout. The online menu listed the 14oz Rib Eye at $36.40. I was in the mood for a good steak and decided to splurge. My wife always gets the Spaghetti Bolognese here—it’s always great.

When I went to pick up the order, the host told me the total was $70.09. I asked how much the Rib Eye was, and she said $44.00. I told her I thought it was in the $30s—that’s why I ordered it.

When I got home, I double-checked the website: sure enough, it still showed $36.40. Later, I stopped back in and tried to explain. I showed the hostess the menu from this website, and her response was, “What website are you looking at?”

She immediately dismissed it, saying, “That’s not our website,” and handed me a menu from BuffaloBillsAZ.com. Even after I showed her that the site had their building’s picture on it, the only thing she said was that she’d “tell the media guy.” No apology. No refund. Very rude and unprofessional.

We’ve been regulars here, but after this encounter—especially with the short, middle-aged woman with blond or gray (possibly bleached) hair—we won’t be back often.

To top it off, while the Rib Eye was cooked and seasoned well, it was disappointingly tough.