We ordered takeout. Ordering process and pickup was easy. From a high level the sandwiches appear expensive. However, one sandwich can serve two people easily. The ingredients are top notch and the focaccia bread is delicious. We ordered Tacchino Italiano 4.5/5 and Piccante Capicollo 5/5. Next time we will snag some cookies or brownies. They looked fantastic.
If eating in there is seating in a well lit clean dining room.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jennifer DiPietro
I need to start off by saying I’m so disappointed, in myself, for waiting so long to come here! My sandwich was exactly everything I wanted it to be. It was light and refreshing. I could taste all the ingredients which played very well together. As a side treat I got some chips (salty goodness) the lemon soda (super fun - a must!) and the brownie, which I will dream about. I cannot wait to try all the other sandwiches! For reference I ordered the #1
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jason Lacey
Best sandwich of my LIFE! I ordered the #2 Pistachio mortadella, cream of pistachio, burrata, olive tapenade, fire-roasted bell peppers + added spicy peppers. The bread is incredibly soft, ingredients are top-notch and the owners are super kind. Highly recommended!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chad K
My wife and I were in the area for Thanksgiving, and we decided to grab lunch one day. AGourmet had good reviews, so we decided to check them out. We were greeted when we walked in the door, and the place is clean and tidy. The customer service was fantastic, and so were the sandwiches! We plan on going back to try more things the next time we are visiting. AGormet Fine Sandwiches is absolutely worth going and checking out! You will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Natalia Rogers
SO GOOD! I’m so glad to have these delicious fresh sandwiches in Surprise! They have a beautiful case of fresh meats and cheeses and unique black truffle and Iberian ham potato chips. Simple and classic with high quality ingredients. The sweetest owners as well. This has become one of my favorite go-to spots!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pistachio Mortadella Sandwich
Liz Salt
Upon entering, there is only narrow bar stool seating along the wall. Ten seats face the walls on a narrow tabletop. The beverage cooler has lots of overpriced options.
I was highly disappointed to witness the female employee moving her hair from her face with gloves on. I then watched the male employee handle meat from a previous sandwich and had no regard for handling my vegetarian sandwich requests. Immediately from the meat to the bread- same gloves. If you are a strict vegetarian, I do NOT recommend this location for you. If you have allergies, I do not recommend it because I saw them drop some of the food into a different bowl, scoop it up, and spread it on a sandwich. If you have strict dietary restrictions, there are no special considerations—from meat to vegetables, cheese to ham—it's all handled with the same gloves. I do not finish food that does not respect my dietary restrictions. I was hired to taste it and give an honest review.
Regarding taste, it was different, but definitely not worth $17. The sandwich was cut in half, and each half was about the size of a regular bread slice ?
Check out the response below- that of a petulant child- not of an owner who wants to better the business and understand how improvement can be made. If this is who you are comfortable doing business with- best wishes ✌️?
Vegetarian options: 1 sandwich option Will come in contact with meat at some point. No vegetarian dietary considerations made.
Dietary restrictions: If you cannot eat pork- this place is not recommended. The meat touches everything.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Raul Flores
It took me a while to check out this spot, and dam do I wish I had checked it out sooner! I got the #9 Wagyu Beef Pastrami, and it was delicious, fresh, and hit the spot. I love sandwiches, and the bread, meats, and spreads were all on point. Definitely will be eating here more often.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagyu Beef Pastrami
Tiffany Hawks
Such a unique sandwich shop, and the couple that owns and runs it are so sweet. They truly care about the quality of the ingredients, the presentation, and whether their customers have a good experience. I adore this shop!
I have traveled all over the world and sandwiches are big on my food list. If you like a great gourmet Italian sandwich, this is the best there is. If this shop were in Scottsdale there would be a line out the door. Fresh everything. This guy and his family came here from Florence Italy and they are killing it
Amazing! So fresh and full of flavor. Me and my wife just moved to Surprise so we’re trying new spots saw the ratings. Decided to try it. very neat very clean as I said before fresh and tasty sandwiches. Looks like a family owned business (the guy on the website made my sandwich) very polite and informative gentleman. They will be getting more of my business!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Autumn Wallace
We have been dying to try A Gourmet for months and we were really excited to stop by today. I was initially shocked by the price but after watching them create these sandwiches and taking our first bite, they are worth every single penny! The quality of ingredients and care put into every sandwich is unmatched, not sure how it's even possible to put that much flavor in each and every bite.
We had the #7 and it was spicy, burrata-y and filled with flavor. You won't be disappointed! This is a real family business, and they deserve our support.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Focaccia
Jordan Poffenberger
The owners were really friendly and their food, amazing! A must visit if you are in Surprise. Support local small businesses!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prosciutto
Valerie Wuls
Fresh and delicious ingredients in these sandwiches. No ingredient overpowered the other, just a perfect blend. The owners were super friendly and take their time making each sandwich with perfection. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prosciutto, Focaccia
Robert Goolsby
Exceptionally good Italian sandwiches on focaccia bread. The bread is soo good, texture and flavor made it the best focaccia I have ever eaten. Ordered the Number 2 with Pistachio Mortadella, cream of pistachio burrito, olive tapenade and roasted peppers with olive oil and arugula.
Highly recommend, one of the best sandwiches ever!
Update second visit was as good as the first, ordered the Uncured Salami this time, sooooo delicious.
We ordered takeout. Ordering process and pickup was easy. From a high level the sandwiches appear expensive. However, one sandwich can serve two people easily. The ingredients are top notch and the focaccia bread is delicious. We ordered Tacchino Italiano 4.5/5 and Piccante Capicollo 5/5. Next time we will snag some cookies or brownies. They looked fantastic.
If eating in there is seating in a well lit clean dining room.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I need to start off by saying I’m so disappointed, in myself, for waiting so long to come here! My sandwich was exactly everything I wanted it to be. It was light and refreshing. I could taste all the ingredients which played very well together. As a side treat I got some chips (salty goodness) the lemon soda (super fun - a must!) and the brownie, which I will dream about. I cannot wait to try all the other sandwiches! For reference I ordered the #1
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best sandwich of my LIFE! I ordered the #2 Pistachio mortadella, cream of pistachio, burrata, olive tapenade, fire-roasted bell
peppers + added spicy peppers. The bread is incredibly soft, ingredients are top-notch and the owners are super kind. Highly recommended!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My wife and I were in the area for Thanksgiving, and we decided to grab lunch one day. AGourmet had good reviews, so we decided to check them out.
We were greeted when we walked in the door, and the place is clean and tidy. The customer service was fantastic, and so were the sandwiches! We plan on going back to try more things the next time we are visiting. AGormet Fine Sandwiches is absolutely worth going and checking out! You will not be disappointed!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
SO GOOD! I’m so glad to have these delicious fresh sandwiches in Surprise! They have a beautiful case of fresh meats and cheeses and unique black truffle and Iberian ham potato chips. Simple and classic with high quality ingredients. The sweetest owners as well. This has become one of my favorite go-to spots!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pistachio Mortadella Sandwich
Upon entering, there is only narrow bar stool seating along the wall. Ten seats face the walls on a narrow tabletop.
The beverage cooler has lots of overpriced options.
I was highly disappointed to witness the female employee moving her hair from her face with gloves on. I then watched the male employee handle meat from a previous sandwich and had no regard for handling my vegetarian sandwich requests.
Immediately from the meat to the bread- same gloves.
If you are a strict vegetarian, I do NOT recommend this location for you.
If you have allergies, I do not recommend it because I saw them drop some of the food into a different bowl, scoop it up, and spread it on a sandwich.
If you have strict dietary restrictions, there are no special considerations—from meat to vegetables, cheese to ham—it's all handled with the same gloves.
I do not finish food that does not respect my dietary restrictions. I was hired to taste it and give an honest review.
Regarding taste, it was different, but definitely not worth $17.
The sandwich was cut in half, and each half was about the size of a regular bread slice ?
Check out the response below- that of a petulant child- not of an owner who wants to better the business and understand how improvement can be made.
If this is who you are comfortable doing business with- best wishes ✌️?
Vegetarian options: 1 sandwich option
Will come in contact with meat at some point. No vegetarian dietary considerations made.
Dietary restrictions: If you cannot eat pork- this place is not recommended. The meat touches everything.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
It took me a while to check out this spot, and dam do I wish I had checked it out sooner! I got the #9 Wagyu Beef Pastrami, and it was delicious, fresh, and hit the spot. I love sandwiches, and the bread, meats, and spreads were all on point. Definitely will be eating here more often.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Wagyu Beef Pastrami
Such a unique sandwich shop, and the couple that owns and runs it are so sweet. They truly care about the quality of the ingredients, the presentation, and whether their customers have a good experience. I adore this shop!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pistachio Mortadella Sandwich, Focaccia, Pistachio Mortadella
Great food, great owner, highly recommend
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prosciutto
I have traveled all over the world and sandwiches are big on my food list. If you like a great gourmet Italian sandwich, this is the best there is. If this shop were in Scottsdale there would be a line out the door. Fresh everything. This guy and his family came here from Florence Italy and they are killing it
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing! So fresh and full of flavor. Me and my wife just moved to Surprise so we’re trying new spots saw the ratings. Decided to try it. very neat very clean as I said before fresh and tasty sandwiches. Looks like a family owned business (the guy on the website made my sandwich) very polite and informative gentleman. They will be getting more of my business!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have been dying to try A Gourmet for months and we were really excited to stop by today. I was initially shocked by the price but after watching them create these sandwiches and taking our first bite, they are worth every single penny! The quality of ingredients and care put into every sandwich is unmatched, not sure how it's even possible to put that much flavor in each and every bite.
We had the #7 and it was spicy, burrata-y and filled with flavor. You won't be disappointed! This is a real family business, and they deserve our support.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Focaccia
The owners were really friendly and their food, amazing! A must visit if you are in Surprise. Support local small businesses!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prosciutto
Fresh and delicious ingredients in these sandwiches. No ingredient overpowered the other, just a perfect blend. The owners were super friendly and take their time making each sandwich with perfection. Highly recommend!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Prosciutto, Focaccia
Exceptionally good Italian sandwiches on focaccia bread. The bread is soo good, texture and flavor made it the best focaccia I have ever eaten. Ordered the Number 2 with Pistachio Mortadella, cream of pistachio burrito, olive tapenade and roasted peppers with olive oil and arugula.
Highly recommend, one of the best sandwiches ever!
Update second visit was as good as the first, ordered the Uncured Salami this time, sooooo delicious.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pistachio Mortadella
Loading...