Y'all, if you so one thing in Williams, make sure it's a small trip to Oh Sweetie! You won't regret it. Best I've cream I've ever had. My family had the same reaction. It's a small little dessert shop in downtown, and you see everyone walking around with their cone. They have the most unique flavors, and not one disappointed. I ordered a scoop of Moose Fart (coconut, choc chips and graham cracker) and it was out of this world good. My mom ordered a scoop of carrot cake and you can literally see the chunks of carrot cake mixed into the ice cream. My sister ordered a scoop of brown sugar oreo and she was absolutely thrilled. My brother raved about the peanut nutter butter scoop he ordered. It's about $6 a scoop, but it's also a nice size scoop! I'm telling you, GO!
Kim S.
Some the best ice cream ever! We were traveling thru Arizona and stopped in Williams for a treat and boy did we pick the right spot! Now I wish I had gotten a cookie!
Saoirse Teaghan
I love the Red Velvet Cookie, it’s so good! Tastes so yummy and the people here are super kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brown Sugar Oreo, Ice Cream Cone
Scnottaken
I don't know why anyone visits an place like crumbl when small places like this exist. Sure the cookies might not photograph as well as those cookies and they might not make you Instagram famous, but one cookie has more flavor than the entire crumbl bakery. Cookie is a bit tough for my liking but the taste more than makes up for it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tactical Reef
Awesome Owner, he’s from South Texas just like us, and was super engaging and friendly with our kids. Amazing atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sara Jackson
THE BEST BANANA PUDDING ICE CREAM!! I can tell there is much attention to detail in the flavor and texture of his other flavors I tried as well! Owner was kind and informative, you can see his passion :) Was just passing through town for the night but I wish I bought a gallon!! I’d pass through this town again to stop here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeovanni Rios
Great service, amazing staff. Probably the best ice cream I’ve ever had. A must visit when in Williams. I brought my English bulldog and the owner was kind enough to give him a scoop of vanilla on the house. We had to go back the next day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone
naveena grubbs
I absolutely love their ice cream! Friendly service! The gentlemen whom i never get his name on each occasion i drive from Pinetop to get the ice cream from lol. Keep up the amazing job and ill be requesting that oatmeal cookie ice cream soon =)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Michelle E.
FANTASTIC service and great fudge! My husband and I stopped in here on a whim while walking around Williams. We weren't planning on purchasing anything but the gentleman working was a phenomenal salesman... he offered us samples but we were hooked! SERVICE - I didn't catch his name but I believe he's the owner... he did a great job of engaging in conversation by asking where we were from, what brought us to the area, etc. We ended up getting some fudge after trying the samples even though that wasn't planned. PRICING - The total was $14.74 after tax and before tip for a peanut butter stuffed Oreo ($3), the fudge ($10), and a 3% service charge ($0.39). We ordered 1/8 lb of two different kinds of fudge which would be 1/4 lb total but were charged for two orders of 1/4 of fudge ($5 each). I didn't notice it until after we left so I'm going to give the benefit of the doubt and assume it was an honest mistake. CHOCOLATE COVERED OREO (9/10) - I mean, how can you go wrong by stuffing an Oreo with peanut butter and then covering it with chocolate? Absolutely delicious! It was sealed well in a bag so you don't have to eat it right away (although you'll definitely want to). BROWN SUGAR OREO FUDGE (8/10) - This was the flavor we sampled because it sounded unique... it was very good! The brown sugar definitely adds a different flavor but it pairs so well with the Oreo. I enjoyed this more than a standard "cookies and cream" (which they also have). PEANUT BUTTER FUDGE (7/10) - Very standard but delicious! The texture is great and the peanut butter flavor is strong but not overpowering. There just isn't much that's special about this one. We didn't try any ice cream but were offered samples of that as well... it did look delicious though! If you're looking for some sweet treats while in Williams, I'd recommend stopping by Oh Sweetie to either enjoy there in the shop or take with you.
Marla Hansen
Wow! What super yummy ice cream. Do not drive past. Trust me. You will thank me.I refrained from buying another dessert but there was gooey looking brownies calling my name.
Amazing place, I had the coffee toffee single scoop with caramel syrup and it was so good! The banana cream pie flavor is a must as well. Definitely recommend this little shop, so cute and tasty!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Renee Vander Yacht
Unusual flavors of fudge! Plus standards, of course. Great local business. Loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
kirkdk8 deed
The BEST banana ice cream ever. Also Moose Fart! Great homemade ice cream and treats. A ‘must visit’ in Williams.
The best brownies I've ever had! Perfect gooey fudge center , great crust that is not over cooked and crinkled top.
Sasha P.
Not exaggerating but this might be the best ice cream we've ever had. We stopped in for some ice cream after dinner and it was absolutely delicious! Mike was so friendly and helpful, great service. We had the Moose Fart and Banana Cream Pie -- both were incredible. Easily the best banana ice cream I've had. We also tasted the Brown Sugar Oreo and Nutter Butter which were so hard to choose between. Quaint little shop! Will be back again (probably tomorrow).
Y'all, if you so one thing in Williams, make sure it's a small trip to Oh Sweetie! You won't regret it. Best I've cream I've ever had. My family had the same reaction. It's a small little dessert shop in downtown, and you see everyone walking around with their cone. They have the most unique flavors, and not one disappointed. I ordered a scoop of Moose Fart (coconut, choc chips and graham cracker) and it was out of this world good. My mom ordered a scoop of carrot cake and you can literally see the chunks of carrot cake mixed into the ice cream. My sister ordered a scoop of brown sugar oreo and she was absolutely thrilled. My brother raved about the peanut nutter butter scoop he ordered. It's about $6 a scoop, but it's also a nice size scoop! I'm telling you, GO!
Some the best ice cream ever! We were traveling thru Arizona and stopped in Williams for a treat and boy did we pick the right spot! Now I wish I had gotten a cookie!
I love the Red Velvet Cookie, it’s so good! Tastes so yummy and the people here are super kind.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brown Sugar Oreo, Ice Cream Cone
I don't know why anyone visits an place like crumbl when small places like this exist. Sure the cookies might not photograph as well as those cookies and they might not make you Instagram famous, but one cookie has more flavor than the entire crumbl bakery. Cookie is a bit tough for my liking but the taste more than makes up for it.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome Owner, he’s from South Texas just like us, and was super engaging and friendly with our kids. Amazing atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
THE BEST BANANA PUDDING ICE CREAM!! I can tell there is much attention to detail in the flavor and texture of his other flavors I tried as well! Owner was kind and informative, you can see his passion :) Was just passing through town for the night but I wish I bought a gallon!! I’d pass through this town again to stop here.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great service, amazing staff. Probably the best ice cream I’ve ever had. A must visit when in Williams. I brought my English bulldog and the owner was kind enough to give him a scoop of vanilla on the house. We had to go back the next day.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Ice Cream Cone
I absolutely love their ice cream! Friendly service! The gentlemen whom i never get his name on each occasion i drive from Pinetop to get the ice cream from lol. Keep up the amazing job and ill be requesting that oatmeal cookie ice cream soon =)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
FANTASTIC service and great fudge! My husband and I stopped in here on a whim while walking around Williams. We weren't planning on purchasing anything but the gentleman working was a phenomenal salesman... he offered us samples but we were hooked! SERVICE - I didn't catch his name but I believe he's the owner... he did a great job of engaging in conversation by asking where we were from, what brought us to the area, etc. We ended up getting some fudge after trying the samples even though that wasn't planned. PRICING - The total was $14.74 after tax and before tip for a peanut butter stuffed Oreo ($3), the fudge ($10), and a 3% service charge ($0.39). We ordered 1/8 lb of two different kinds of fudge which would be 1/4 lb total but were charged for two orders of 1/4 of fudge ($5 each). I didn't notice it until after we left so I'm going to give the benefit of the doubt and assume it was an honest mistake. CHOCOLATE COVERED OREO (9/10) - I mean, how can you go wrong by stuffing an Oreo with peanut butter and then covering it with chocolate? Absolutely delicious! It was sealed well in a bag so you don't have to eat it right away (although you'll definitely want to). BROWN SUGAR OREO FUDGE (8/10) - This was the flavor we sampled because it sounded unique... it was very good! The brown sugar definitely adds a different flavor but it pairs so well with the Oreo. I enjoyed this more than a standard "cookies and cream" (which they also have). PEANUT BUTTER FUDGE (7/10) - Very standard but delicious! The texture is great and the peanut butter flavor is strong but not overpowering. There just isn't much that's special about this one. We didn't try any ice cream but were offered samples of that as well... it did look delicious though! If you're looking for some sweet treats while in Williams, I'd recommend stopping by Oh Sweetie to either enjoy there in the shop or take with you.
Wow! What super yummy ice cream. Do not drive past. Trust me. You will thank me.I refrained from buying another dessert but there was gooey looking brownies calling my name.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brown Sugar Oreo, Peanut Butter Cups, Ice Cream Cone
Restaurantji Recommends
Amazing place, I had the coffee toffee single scoop with caramel syrup and it was so good! The banana cream pie flavor is a must as well. Definitely recommend this little shop, so cute and tasty!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Unusual flavors of fudge! Plus standards, of course. Great local business. Loved it!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The BEST banana ice cream ever. Also Moose Fart! Great homemade ice cream and treats. A ‘must visit’ in Williams.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Brown Sugar Oreo, Cinnamon Toast Crunch, Ice Cream Cone
The best brownies I've ever had! Perfect gooey fudge center , great crust that is not over cooked and crinkled top.
Not exaggerating but this might be the best ice cream we've ever had. We stopped in for some ice cream after dinner and it was absolutely delicious! Mike was so friendly and helpful, great service. We had the Moose Fart and Banana Cream Pie -- both were incredible. Easily the best banana ice cream I've had. We also tasted the Brown Sugar Oreo and Nutter Butter which were so hard to choose between. Quaint little shop! Will be back again (probably tomorrow).