Riders Pizza

2738 Dunsmuir Ave, Cumberland
(250) 400-7433

Recent Reviews

Shane White

This place is deadly! Food is amazing, very creative takes on some classic pizza choices as well as some originals. Excellent drink selection and very friendly staff!Food: 5/5

Maureen M.

Noisy and busy. Don't take reservations so they sat our group of 12 outside. It was very hot and no children's choices. From an adult perspective the pizza was excellent.

Jarryd Rees

This just might be the best pizza on the island.They also have an excellent BC craft beer selection.

Laurel Bliss

Really Really good. Especially since we drove all the way from Nanaimo to get it :)

Ted Usher

First time trying Riders and we were not disappointed. We walked in and it was full so they took my name and phone number so we could wandered the area. Came back and we sat at the bar which was cool because we could watch the goings on in the kitchen. One size of pizza but lots of choices. Good selection of ciders and beer. The amount of take out was incredible but that did not delay jus getting our pizza in a reasonable amount of time. Service was great. Staff were very friendly including one of the owners (headband) who chatted with us. We will certainly be back. Great place in Cumberland so give it a try.

Daniel O'Brien

Very good pizza, the Sasquatch was amazing, staff were quick, knowledgeable, and accommodating; great local beer selections, and an immaculate bathroom experience. Would highly recommend.

Emily Peck

Super delish pizza! A regular sized pizza is good to share between 2 people. Would highly recommend the Sasquatch! Also their selection of craft beers is ?.


Another amazing meal here. Took my little Neice for pizza. We are both slow eaters. I could tell it was close to closing time. But these guys definately didnt make us feel rushed. We did end up taking the rest to go. (Cause its just as good later) You guys have the best service as well as food. Thank you for making this an exceptional experience for my Neice, and always for me. ??

Gisele Verrier

Delicious pizzas. Fantastic crust. So many varieties it was hard to choose. Thankfully we could order two different halves on one pizza. This allowed us to try four different pizzas instead of only two. Who would have thought that fried capers and yams could taste so good on pizza?

Hew Padmore

I'm not adventurous enough for some of the less conventional pies on the menu so we got the pepperoni. The all important crust was truly top notch and the service was 5 stars. Liked the looks of the tap list too.

Rieley Kay

Snuck in on a busy Saturday evening. Great selection of craft beers and deadly pies! That crust... ? andI could use a jug of the buttermilk ranch! ?


I eat out way too much. Usually once or twice a day. The locals were bragging about this place so I thought I'd give it a try. The atmosphere was cool, but the food...meh. I'd go again but the menu ,in my opinion, needs some work.

Kathryn Bridge

The pizza, dessert, service & ambiance were the best bar none & kudos to the owner or owners for having such a well oiled & devoted team working there. It was an amazing experience watching them & it was clear that every one of them loves their job. The takeout orders were also flying out the door. ?❤️?

Ryan Leverette (Ryan Drives Canada)

I’ve had their pie in the past and it’s fantastic. But tonight they completely forgot my order. I walked in, ordered pizza and polenta fries and a beer…I sat at the bar for an hour waiting. I didn’t think much of it because it was a busy Sunday evening. Eventually, someone came to me and apologized stating that they had not even started my order yet. They refunded my money. I walked away hungry and very disappointed. I wasn’t the only one. They were making orders for everyone except the people in their restaurant.

Wilson L.

We ordered the BBQ Chicken pizza from here and it was amazing. We've been meaning to try this place every time we're in the Comox Valley and haven't had a chance till now. It was 100% worth the visit and we can't wait to have Rider's Pizza again!

Load More