Very good restaurant. The dishes are very tasty, the host is very pleasant and welcoming, we loved everything.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sonya Parkin
Great pizza - gf crust was great!!! (best I've had this year!) Friendly service, nice that it's open for lunch again
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Abentl
Your going to want to call ahead and see if they are open. Tried and they are closed. It appears they do not update this page.
Tracey Weiser
The food is reliably yummy! They do great takeout. They always make sure to provide lots of dressing in cups for the Manhattan salad so it doesn't get soggy.The staff were arguing about who was responsible for what, but they were very pleasant with the customers.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Manhattan Salad
Maddy Hart
Always shocked at the low reviews on here because we absolutely love it here! The food is always great and the staff lovely. The manhattan salad is a favorite and despite the other complaints on here, we all love the pizza crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Pizza
Barb Bricker
Jodi was great. Food was very good but not very hot and had to wait for some food. The disappointment was the manager who approached Jodi during the dinner rush to reprimand her. In front of all customers. Very distasteful. She could of waited or at least take her to another room.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
William T
Awsome pizza lunch. The big apple wow! I understand it's a 1920s New York recipe, it takes 4 hours to prepare the crust... nothing like it! Great service and price...love the venue.
jarrod dick
All you can eat pizza and pasta on a Wednesday night. Good food and prompt service.Kid-friendliness: Bring the kids, they will love it.Parking: Gotta park on the street. Lock your doors.Wheelchair accessibility: There is a step going into the restaurant.
Janine
Crust was very very dry! Either in the oven too long or something is wrong with the oven. Practically crumbed each bite.
We've patronized NYP for years and have never been disappointed. Lately we have especially enjoyed the House Salad. At times, either my wife or I have made a dinner of it. It is unusual and absolutely delicious. We would recommend it unreservedly, as we would most of the offerings. However, we've not had the pizzas, so can say nothing there.
Luansian Llewellyn
Awesome food and service! Went for dinner with my brother and parents and the atmosphere was great! Place seemed clean, our waitress was super friendly. We got seated by the window and I will say the table was a bit rickety. I was scared the food might slide down, but it all turned out fine. Otherwise the place was clean and had an overall great vibe (I looked for hair on the heaters after seeing that one review and couldn’t find any).I’m vegetarian, and they had really well-marked options. Ended up ordering one of the pizzas but it took me a while to decide, which is rare to come by in restaurants that don’t prioritize vegetarian/vegan options, so that was a nice surprise.When my pizza came, it was a lot bigger than I expected (not complaining). Lots of toppings, stacked pretty high too. Tasted really good, though. My parents shared the pasta and both really liked it.Overall love the entire atmosphere and vibe of the place, we’re planning to go again sometime soon.
Rick Breidenbach
I think their pizza is great! I liked the Empire and Soho pizzas the most. Quick delivery times too!
RattleShark the Pizza Daddy
I ordered the beef and tomato pizza, my kid had the lasagne, neither of us enjoyed our meal. I'm guessing they par bake their crust and then do a fast bake for the finished product. My toppings were refrigerator cold under hot cheese. My kid said her lasagne was bland and boring. It was a lot of money to fork out for something so sub par. With Pizza and Pasta in the title of the restaurant, I would expect you to be good at serving this kind of product. Most likely won't be back. The service was good and friendly so the evening wasn't a total loss. I'd rethink the par baked crusts, proper pizza can be made from raw dough, I can do better at home in under 40 minutes.
Tammy Humber
Flat out, the worst pizza I HAVE EVER HAD! Crust is dry and disgusting and absolutely flavorless! Had that opinion the first time, tried it a second time and NEVER again!
an excellent choice for your meal
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Very good restaurant. The dishes are very tasty, the host is very pleasant and welcoming, we loved everything.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza - gf crust was great!!! (best I've had this year!) Friendly service, nice that it's open for lunch again
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Your going to want to call ahead and see if they are open. Tried and they are closed. It appears they do not update this page.
The food is reliably yummy! They do great takeout. They always make sure to provide lots of dressing in cups for the Manhattan salad so it doesn't get soggy.The staff were arguing about who was responsible for what, but they were very pleasant with the customers.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Manhattan Salad
Always shocked at the low reviews on here because we absolutely love it here! The food is always great and the staff lovely. The manhattan salad is a favorite and despite the other complaints on here, we all love the pizza crust!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Pizza
Jodi was great. Food was very good but not very hot and had to wait for some food. The disappointment was the manager who approached Jodi during the dinner rush to reprimand her. In front of all customers. Very distasteful. She could of waited or at least take her to another room.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Awsome pizza lunch. The big apple wow! I understand it's a 1920s New York recipe, it takes 4 hours to prepare the crust... nothing like it! Great service and price...love the venue.
All you can eat pizza and pasta on a Wednesday night. Good food and prompt service.Kid-friendliness: Bring the kids, they will love it.Parking: Gotta park on the street. Lock your doors.Wheelchair accessibility: There is a step going into the restaurant.
Crust was very very dry! Either in the oven too long or something is wrong with the oven. Practically crumbed each bite.
Restaurantji Recommends
We've patronized NYP for years and have never been disappointed. Lately we have especially enjoyed the House Salad. At times, either my wife or I have made a dinner of it. It is unusual and absolutely delicious. We would recommend it unreservedly, as we would most of the offerings. However, we've not had the pizzas, so can say nothing there.
Awesome food and service! Went for dinner with my brother and parents and the atmosphere was great! Place seemed clean, our waitress was super friendly. We got seated by the window and I will say the table was a bit rickety. I was scared the food might slide down, but it all turned out fine. Otherwise the place was clean and had an overall great vibe (I looked for hair on the heaters after seeing that one review and couldn’t find any).I’m vegetarian, and they had really well-marked options. Ended up ordering one of the pizzas but it took me a while to decide, which is rare to come by in restaurants that don’t prioritize vegetarian/vegan options, so that was a nice surprise.When my pizza came, it was a lot bigger than I expected (not complaining). Lots of toppings, stacked pretty high too. Tasted really good, though. My parents shared the pasta and both really liked it.Overall love the entire atmosphere and vibe of the place, we’re planning to go again sometime soon.
I think their pizza is great! I liked the Empire and Soho pizzas the most. Quick delivery times too!
I ordered the beef and tomato pizza, my kid had the lasagne, neither of us enjoyed our meal. I'm guessing they par bake their crust and then do a fast bake for the finished product. My toppings were refrigerator cold under hot cheese. My kid said her lasagne was bland and boring. It was a lot of money to fork out for something so sub par. With Pizza and Pasta in the title of the restaurant, I would expect you to be good at serving this kind of product. Most likely won't be back. The service was good and friendly so the evening wasn't a total loss. I'd rethink the par baked crusts, proper pizza can be made from raw dough, I can do better at home in under 40 minutes.
Flat out, the worst pizza I HAVE EVER HAD! Crust is dry and disgusting and absolutely flavorless! Had that opinion the first time, tried it a second time and NEVER again!