Domenico’s is one of those places you walk into once and immediately know you’ll be back. It’s a cozy little mom-and-pop Italian sandwich shop that feels like home the second you step inside. The owners are super friendly, always ready with a smile and a genuine “How ya doin’?” It’s the kind of spot where they remember your name, your usual order, and probably what you had last time too.
The sandwiches? Absolutely killer. Whether you're grabbing a classic Italian combo stacked with prosciutto, salami, and sharp provolone or diving into one of their warm, saucy meatball subs, every bite is packed with flavor. The bread is always fresh, the ingredients are top quality, and you can tell everything’s made with care. They don’t cut corners here—just thick slices of goodness and old-school flavor.
What really sets Domenico’s apart, though, is the vibe. It’s not just about great food (though there's plenty of that)—it’s about the people, the stories, and the feeling that you're part of something special. It’s the kind of place you tell your friends about, but secretly hope stays just enough under the radar. If you haven’t been yet, go. You’re seriously missing out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Sandwich, Italian Combo Sandwich, Pastrami, Chips, Italian Beef, Dutch Crunch Bread, Pepper, Cannoli, Prosciutto
Andrew Guenthner
Unassuming but delicious and friendly, this is a must-visit classic Italian deli if you're anywhere near Webster St. at lunchtime or in the afternoon. Great sandwiches and desserts, plus lots of daily special items. Can get crowded but there's usually some open seats in the back. Similar prices to fast food, a bit more if you have a nice dessert, but you get much better food and service for the price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Beef, Dutch Crunch Bread, Cannoli, Italian Beef with Au Jus
Genesis Nambo
Great place, try the pepper turkey.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike Rosenke
Delicious sandwich! Everything was super fresh and the staff is great! Will definitely be back here next time I'm in Alameda.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Tom Gardner
Best Pastrami sandwich in the Bay
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kao swa
Delicious sandwiches, very friendly staffs gave us a hand writing notes of what we ordered.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alfhonso D
Family owned business and they are super friendly and make delicious sandwiches! The owner Anne who takes order always remembers my name and offers amazing customer service! I highly recommend trying out the pastrami sandwich and the Italian beef, hot sandwich! They have a great selection of chips and soda!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jessica Hassan
Best sandwich
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Derrek Bryson
Best sandwiches ever!!
Kesha Lynne
I love sandwiches! Great meat, fresh breads , variety of drinks ….. and of course something for the sweet tooth😍 Finding a replacement for Genova’s of Oakland has been a decade plus challenge for me … until I discovered Domenico’s in Alameda! I pay attention to the staff’s unspoken language and if the owner is present I watch them too! Well I always say staff reflects leadership… pleased to learn both are great people. ‼️Mrs Domenico and son really set the standard. I’m terrible with names( he told me his and his mother’s name) so I don’t want to mention but if you go there you’ll know immediately who I’m speaking about . ‼️ I’m all about legacy and family tradition, this is a third generation establishment which holds the same love & respect to the craft and people. It’s in the service. Thank you for serving great quality food!
This place is an Alameda icon... I used to eat here as a child in the 1990's. Came back to the Bay Area for the first time in over 20 years. Domenico's is one of the few old school Alameda joints still around.
I got a Avocado & Turkey on Sourdough. Absolutely as delicious as they were in my childhood.
Cathy
Best sandwich spot in Alameda! This is a great old-school Italian deli. Try the Italian combo or the home-made Italian Roast Beef.
El Reader
HELLO EVERYONE! THIS IS EL READER!
I need to be honest—this was my FIRST time ever visiting this place, despite many people recommending it. One of the reasons I hadn’t gone until today was primarily because of the times they’re open as well as the location, which has very limited parking. (WE NEED TO BE A CYCLING AND WALKING CIVILIZATION!)
I went all out—possibly the most I have ever spent at a sandwich shop. I ordered the lamb sandwich (because I wanted to feel a bit bougie), the smoked turkey sandwich, spaghetti (ordered ahead), three meatballs, their tiramisu (OMG! SO GOOD!), their artichoke pasta salad, two bags of chips, and this little chocolate dessert that came in a box from Italy (I hope tariffs don’t make it more expensive—it’s so good).
The lamb sandwich was absolutely delicious. My eyes rolled so far back that I swear I saw my a$$ (Need to hit the gym). The spaghetti—well, let me tell you—I am not Italian, but I feel like if I had an Italian grandmother, I could taste her love in it.
The folks working behind the counter are wonderful people. They work hard and don’t have time to waste, so you better know what you’re ordering by the time they get to you—or better yet, just order ahead. I have never wanted to try every sandwich from any sandwich shop before, but this place might just add me to the growing homeless population in the Bay Area.
If you have a chance to come to Alameda, make sure you stop by. Be warned—it does get busy, and like I said, parking is limited. I chose to visit after the lunch rush and ordered ahead.
I just want to thank the wonderful people at Dominico’s for their excellent service and for letting me taste the passion, love, and pride in the beautifully crafted sandwiches and food they prepare.
10/10—will definitely go broke eating here again and again and again!
Jeff Mo
This is a classic sandwich shop with great customer service and amazing selection. Bought 5 different sandwiches and all were awesome! Tiramisu and connoli were great too! Will be back, thank you!!
Domenico’s is one of those places you walk into once and immediately know you’ll be back. It’s a cozy little mom-and-pop Italian sandwich shop that feels like home the second you step inside. The owners are super friendly, always ready with a smile and a genuine “How ya doin’?” It’s the kind of spot where they remember your name, your usual order, and probably what you had last time too.
The sandwiches? Absolutely killer. Whether you're grabbing a classic Italian combo stacked with prosciutto, salami, and sharp provolone or diving into one of their warm, saucy meatball subs, every bite is packed with flavor. The bread is always fresh, the ingredients are top quality, and you can tell everything’s made with care. They don’t cut corners here—just thick slices of goodness and old-school flavor.
What really sets Domenico’s apart, though, is the vibe. It’s not just about great food (though there's plenty of that)—it’s about the people, the stories, and the feeling that you're part of something special. It’s the kind of place you tell your friends about, but secretly hope stays just enough under the radar. If you haven’t been yet, go. You’re seriously missing out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Veggie Sandwich, Italian Combo Sandwich, Pastrami, Chips, Italian Beef, Dutch Crunch Bread, Pepper, Cannoli, Prosciutto
Unassuming but delicious and friendly, this is a must-visit classic Italian deli if you're anywhere near Webster St. at lunchtime or in the afternoon. Great sandwiches and desserts, plus lots of daily special items. Can get crowded but there's usually some open seats in the back. Similar prices to fast food, a bit more if you have a nice dessert, but you get much better food and service for the price.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Italian Beef, Dutch Crunch Bread, Cannoli, Italian Beef with Au Jus
Great place, try the pepper turkey.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious sandwich! Everything was super fresh and the staff is great! Will definitely be back here next time I'm in Alameda.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best Pastrami sandwich in the Bay
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious sandwiches, very friendly staffs gave us a hand writing notes of what we ordered.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Family owned business and they are super friendly and make delicious sandwiches! The owner Anne who takes order always remembers my name and offers amazing customer service! I highly recommend trying out the pastrami sandwich and the Italian beef, hot sandwich! They have a great selection of chips and soda!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best sandwich
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best sandwiches ever!!
I love sandwiches! Great meat, fresh breads , variety of drinks ….. and of course something for the sweet tooth😍 Finding a replacement for Genova’s of Oakland has been a decade plus challenge for me … until I discovered Domenico’s in Alameda!
I pay attention to the staff’s unspoken language and if the owner is present I watch them too! Well I always say staff reflects leadership… pleased to learn both are great people.
‼️Mrs Domenico and son really set the standard. I’m terrible with names( he told me his and his mother’s name) so I don’t want to mention but if you go there you’ll know immediately who I’m speaking about . ‼️
I’m all about legacy and family tradition, this is a third generation establishment which holds the same love & respect to the craft and people. It’s in the service.
Thank you for serving great quality food!
Restaurantji Recommends
This place is an Alameda icon... I used to eat here as a child in the 1990's. Came back to the Bay Area for the first time in over 20 years. Domenico's is one of the few old school Alameda joints still around.
I got a Avocado & Turkey on Sourdough. Absolutely as delicious as they were in my childhood.
Best sandwich spot in Alameda! This is a great old-school Italian deli. Try the Italian combo or the home-made Italian Roast Beef.
HELLO EVERYONE! THIS IS EL READER!
I need to be honest—this was my FIRST time ever visiting this place, despite many people recommending it. One of the reasons I hadn’t gone until today was primarily because of the times they’re open as well as the location, which has very limited parking. (WE NEED TO BE A CYCLING AND WALKING CIVILIZATION!)
I went all out—possibly the most I have ever spent at a sandwich shop. I ordered the lamb sandwich (because I wanted to feel a bit bougie), the smoked turkey sandwich, spaghetti (ordered ahead), three meatballs, their tiramisu (OMG! SO GOOD!), their artichoke pasta salad, two bags of chips, and this little chocolate dessert that came in a box from Italy (I hope tariffs don’t make it more expensive—it’s so good).
The lamb sandwich was absolutely delicious. My eyes rolled so far back that I swear I saw my a$$ (Need to hit the gym). The spaghetti—well, let me tell you—I am not Italian, but I feel like if I had an Italian grandmother, I could taste her love in it.
The folks working behind the counter are wonderful people. They work hard and don’t have time to waste, so you better know what you’re ordering by the time they get to you—or better yet, just order ahead. I have never wanted to try every sandwich from any sandwich shop before, but this place might just add me to the growing homeless population in the Bay Area.
If you have a chance to come to Alameda, make sure you stop by. Be warned—it does get busy, and like I said, parking is limited. I chose to visit after the lunch rush and ordered ahead.
I just want to thank the wonderful people at Dominico’s for their excellent service and for letting me taste the passion, love, and pride in the beautifully crafted sandwiches and food they prepare.
10/10—will definitely go broke eating here again and again and again!
This is a classic sandwich shop with great customer service and amazing selection. Bought 5 different sandwiches and all were awesome! Tiramisu and connoli were great too! Will be back, thank you!!
Mediocre food. Horrible service
Loading...