Absolutely stellar pizza beautiful quality and great cost. Absolute hidden gem and Sadiq is the most kind guy while serving my pizza and i couldn’t ask anyone else to do it. Beautiful place and stunning mural that goes with the scenery
Aaron Kasar
BEST SLICE SHOP IN TOWN!!!!!
Maile Williams
I placed an online order and when I went to pick up my order they forgot my mozzarella sticks. I waited about 10 mins and when I received my mozzarella sticks “fresh out the oil” 2 of them were still cold and the rest were barely warm. My pizza was also cold when I first got there and didn’t taste good. This was my first and last time coming here.
Mark Ruckman
Ordered my first pizza from NY Pizza on 2/20/25 and had it delivered. Ended up extremely disappointed because the entire pizza crust was burnt so bad it was Black. Called and spoke with employee and was offered a discount on a future pizza purchase. That doesn't work for me because I will NEVER eat a pizza at NY Pizza ever again. This has got to be the worst pizza I have ever eaten in my life! Beware
Jessica M
I called in and ordered a large cheese pizza w half pepperoni . He said the order would take 40mins and I was okay with that. The delivery driver seemed very incompetent on how to use the door at the apartment to be let inside. Very frustrating. Then I open the box and it’s only a cheese pizza with no pepperoni and I was charged $26. It’s very hard for them to comprehend English which made the whole experience unpleasant. Made it worse that the pizza didn’t even taste good.
A L (Tippet)
Having lived in NYC for several years, my first reaction was to about a restaurant called “New York Pizza”. How good could it be? So after 30+ years, I finally fried it for the first time. And I was pleasantly surprised. Pizza was very tasty and one of the better ones I’ve had. The ambiance and customer service is nothing to rave about, but it was adequate. But the pizzaiolos at New York Pizza know what they are doing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
AL (Tippet)
Having lived in NYC for several years, my first reaction was to about a restaurant called “New York Pizza”. How good could it be? So after 30+ years, I finally fried it for the first time. And I was pleasantly surprised. Pizza was very tasty and one of the better ones I’ve had. The ambiance and customer service is nothing to rave about, but it was adequate. But the pizzaiolos at New York Pizza know what they are doing.
Fernanda Vilchis
Came here for a slice of pizza and stood in front of the counter with two employees ignoring my friend and I for nearly 5 minutes. When one of them finally comes to the register, he seemed extremely annoyed to have to take our order? We ask if they have pizza by the slice and says no and acts like we just asked him the craziest question and assumed that would shoo us off but unfortunately we were hungry so we asked about the wings. In which he again seemed annoyed that we tried to put in an order that he didn’t even listen to what we were asking. We had to repeat “can we order buffalo wings” five times until his grumpy self understood. Got looked at like we just beamed in from another planet too for some reason. Hopefully they’re not racist and are like that with everyone lol. Once we received our wings they were the slimiest wings I’ve ever gotten in my life. My friend and I didn’t bother finishing them when we got home.
Reading half of these reviews, some spanning from even 6 years ago, it seems like not much has changed concerning quality of product and service. Maybe ask yourselves why you bother running an establishment where you serve the public if you hate interacting with people? Will warn as many folks as possible about this sad little spot.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings
ann m.
The pizza it’s good it has a great taste. The dough it’s not to thick or to thin and it has a great taste. I like that they sale pizza slices it’s very convenient for people that don’t want a whole pizza or they just crave a slice.
The pizza can show up many different ways. I've ordered from door dash and directly from the store at this point. When it's done with light cheese/sauce and thin enough crust the pizza is fantastic. Other times the dough will be substantially thicker, more, sweeter sauce(guessing prep cooks each have their own way), more cheese, and undercooked. Still a solid pizza either way, but when done right it's out of the park for "cheap ny pizza"
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Vince Ruso
Pizza was ok I have had better
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Duane Crother
I had 6 pizzas delivered to a company event. Everyone loved the flavors. Will definitely use again. Cheese, meat lover, vegetarian, combo, pepperoni, and hawaiian.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Austin Petersen
Incredible pizza!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Richard Sok
Slice shop, ordered plain pie, was devoured by the fam. Fing delicious.
Pizza taste really good
Absolutely stellar pizza beautiful quality and great cost. Absolute hidden gem and Sadiq is the most kind guy while serving my pizza and i couldn’t ask anyone else to do it. Beautiful place and stunning mural that goes with the scenery
BEST SLICE SHOP IN TOWN!!!!!
I placed an online order and when I went to pick up my order they forgot my mozzarella sticks. I waited about 10 mins and when I received my mozzarella sticks “fresh out the oil” 2 of them were still cold and the rest were barely warm. My pizza was also cold when I first got there and didn’t taste good. This was my first and last time coming here.
Ordered my first pizza from NY Pizza on 2/20/25 and had it delivered. Ended up extremely disappointed because the entire pizza crust was burnt so bad it was Black. Called and spoke with employee and was offered a discount on a future pizza purchase. That doesn't work for me because I will NEVER eat a pizza at NY Pizza ever again. This has got to be the worst pizza I have ever eaten in my life! Beware
I called in and ordered a large cheese pizza w half pepperoni . He said the order would take 40mins and I was okay with that. The delivery driver seemed very incompetent on how to use the door at the apartment to be let inside. Very frustrating. Then I open the box and it’s only a cheese pizza with no pepperoni and I was charged $26. It’s very hard for them to comprehend English which made the whole experience unpleasant. Made it worse that the pizza didn’t even taste good.
Having lived in NYC for several years, my first reaction was to about a restaurant called “New York Pizza”. How good could it be? So after 30+ years, I finally fried it for the first time. And I was pleasantly surprised. Pizza was very tasty and one of the better ones I’ve had. The ambiance and customer service is nothing to rave about, but it was adequate. But the pizzaiolos at New York Pizza know what they are doing.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 3
Having lived in NYC for several years, my first reaction was to about a restaurant called “New York Pizza”. How good could it be? So after 30+ years, I finally fried it for the first time. And I was pleasantly surprised. Pizza was very tasty and one of the better ones I’ve had. The ambiance and customer service is nothing to rave about, but it was adequate. But the pizzaiolos at New York Pizza know what they are doing.
Came here for a slice of pizza and stood in front of the counter with two employees ignoring my friend and I for nearly 5 minutes. When one of them finally comes to the register, he seemed extremely annoyed to have to take our order? We ask if they have pizza by the slice and says no and acts like we just asked him the craziest question and assumed that would shoo us off but unfortunately we were hungry so we asked about the wings. In which he again seemed annoyed that we tried to put in an order that he didn’t even listen to what we were asking. We had to repeat “can we order buffalo wings” five times until his grumpy self understood. Got looked at like we just beamed in from another planet too for some reason. Hopefully they’re not racist and are like that with everyone lol. Once we received our wings they were the slimiest wings I’ve ever gotten in my life. My friend and I didn’t bother finishing them when we got home.
Reading half of these reviews, some spanning from even 6 years ago, it seems like not much has changed concerning quality of product and service. Maybe ask yourselves why you bother running an establishment where you serve the public if you hate interacting with people? Will warn as many folks as possible about this sad little spot.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Wings
The pizza it’s good it has a great taste. The dough it’s not to thick or to thin and it has a great taste. I like that they sale pizza slices it’s very convenient for people that don’t want a whole pizza or they just crave a slice.
Restaurantji Recommends
The pizza can show up many different ways. I've ordered from door dash and directly from the store at this point. When it's done with light cheese/sauce and thin enough crust the pizza is fantastic. Other times the dough will be substantially thicker, more, sweeter sauce(guessing prep cooks each have their own way), more cheese, and undercooked. Still a solid pizza either way, but when done right it's out of the park for "cheap ny pizza"
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Pizza was ok I have had better
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
I had 6 pizzas delivered to a company event. Everyone loved the flavors. Will definitely use again. Cheese, meat lover, vegetarian, combo, pepperoni, and hawaiian.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Incredible pizza!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Slice shop, ordered plain pie, was devoured by the fam. Fing delicious.
Loading...