New York Pizzeria
546 Myrtlewood Dr, Calimesa
(909) 795-2424
Customers' Favorites
XL Pizza Pepperoni Pineapple Sausage
Two Three Toppings Pizza Special
Calimesa Pizza Peperoni
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Smothered Schnitzel
Calimesa Special
Antipasto Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Lasagna Dinner
Menu
Photos
+8 photos
+7 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Got the Calimesa Family deal. Not disappointed reminded me of back when I was a kid and my dad would pick up pizza / Chicken and a Movie on a Friday night 🔥 little hiccup with the delivery, Maybe drivers should be advised to check the address on the receipt upon arrival. Don’t trust the internet lol 😂 overall satisfied.
Orderd a pepperoni pizza with a lasagna and breadsticks, came about to 32 bucks. Staff was super friendly too. Place is really clean but its pretty old style, color and mood of the place is like a haunted house from the 90's.
1. Pizza was fluffy and balanced well with a nice cheese to sauce ratio (as seen in picture)
2. Lasagna was ok but honestly bigger portions than other places.
3. Garlic bread wasn't too oily...
1. Pizza was fluffy and balanced well with a nice cheese to sauce ratio (as seen in picture)
2. Lasagna was ok but honestly bigger portions than other places.
3. Garlic bread wasn't too oily...
You May Also Like
The HAUS Bistro - 534 Myrtlewood Dr
![]()
Bar, American, Modern European, New American
Best Wok - 1129 Calimesa Blvd
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian
21 Sushi House - 530 Myrtlewood Dr
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Japanese, Vegan, Vegetarian
A&W. So most of my review is there for New York Pizza. New York pizzas food was delicious. Then went down hill when it was sold. With the exception of Laura. She is a wonderful person & is pretty much the bright star there now . I am going back lately. But I always
ask for an extra side topping . I ask for extra sauce & cheese. There aren't many choices. Of places to eat around here....