New York Pizzeria
546 Myrtlewood Dr, Calimesa
(909) 795-2424
Customers' Favorites
XL Pizza Pepperoni Pineapple Sausage
Two Three Toppings Pizza Special
Calimesa Pizza Peperoni
Deep Dish Cheese Pizza
Buffalo Chicken Pizza
Smothered Schnitzel
Calimesa Special
Antipasto Salad
Pepperoni Pizza
Lasagna Dinner
Menu
Photos
+7 photos
+6 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
Quiet with a pleasant aroma reminded me of pizzerias back home and the pizza was better than I expected the counter person was very pleasant i will return at some time in the future there’s plenty of space to get around which is imortant since I have to get around using a wheelchair well done ny pizza
The staff is very attentive. Mrs. Laura is very friendly and helpful.
The pizzas ? simply exquisite. We tried all kinds and they were all surprising!!!!
I highly recommend this place, it is very cozy. And the prices are very reasonable too.
The pizzas ? simply exquisite. We tried all kinds and they were all surprising!!!!
I highly recommend this place, it is very cozy. And the prices are very reasonable too.
Pizza is still good from many years of coming here, honestly it used to be better! But it's okay. The atmosphere is old, it still has the same tables and chairs for over 25 years, and they add to the old smell of the place. Take your food to go. Also I understand the prices all around are getting worse, but to double charge for a topping is ridiculous! It's too bad. My stomach turned just from the old smell.
You May Also Like
The HAUS Bistro - 534 Myrtlewood Dr
![]()
Bar, American, Modern European, New American
Best Wok - 1129 Calimesa Blvd
![]()
Chinese, Vegetarian
21 Sushi House - 530 Myrtlewood Dr
![]()
Sushi, Sushi Bar, Japanese, Vegan, Vegetarian