I would like to give it a 3.5 star rating. Customer service is great Mary does a great job. I think they put a little too much cheese on their pizza. I like the crust and I like the sauce. overall I like it. I go there about three times a month.
Charles Wang
Always hits the spot, super fast and delicious!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Aimee warren
Wonderful pizza, some fun video gamesAnd good service tonite. Thank you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Kai Blackwell
Great pizza as always and fantastic dynamic customer service, shout out to Mary for making fantastic conversation and keeping a good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
P.Y. H.
awesome pizza. we like the meaty pizza. highly recommend a stop here if you're in the area and crave pizzas.
Taylor W.
Pizza was delicious and our server Mary was the best! She gave great recommendations. The bread sticks were great too.
Brent Carlson
Best family pizza in the valley.
Brittanyy W.
Do yourself a favor and order the chicken Cesar pie. I started ordering it 20 years ago when I was in middle school and lived here and now it is a tradition every time we come back to visit. So good, warm savory comfort food.
David Pressley
The pizza here was very good. The pizza was deep but the dough was still crispy and not soggy or greasy. The bread sticks rocked too. I had never had ranch as a dipping sauce for bread sticks before coming to California, but now I'm a believer! Service was excellent.
Q B.
i'm a 12 year resident of carmel valley. this place has definitely been hit or miss for me. i've ordered here about 10 times over the years. haven't been there for a few years so thought i would give it a try. phone ordered a medium thin crust pizza with 2 toppings and a personal thin crust pizza and a caesar salad. came out to ~$45. REVIEW: 1 of the toppings was missing on the medium pizza, not close to thin crust and there was so much sauce on it that the that the dough was absolutely gooey. yuck. the personal margaretta pizza was not thin crust at all and the report back was it was pretty good. the salad was not that fresh, definitely chucky cheese quality and the dressing so fishy we thought it was turned. didn't eat it. won't be going back anytime soon here for anything to eat. I CAN'T RECOMMEND TO ANYONE I KNOW. bummer...
I love their pizza with very fresh ingredients, especially their added touch of grilled onions and garlic. The crust is always perfect and when you want extra added ingredients they really add extra. One of the best pizza around and I've had plenty from local/Us to Other countries.
Gerald Ackerman
This place is excellent
teris952
Best pizza I've eaten in years! Great outdoor patio, excellent service, conveniently located in the heart of the village. Locals appear to frequent this place alot.
marciebaggsm
Excellent pizza !! love the location, customer service and the really yummy roasted garlic. Great buffalo wings too!!
Jon K.
I live nearby to the Stirrup Cup Pizza, and I am so pleased they are my local pizza parlor. Stirrup Cup is our go to for conventional Pizza, and by that I mean American style, not fancy California style. If you were seeking upgrade California style pizza, I recommend nearby corkscrew or Café rustica. But Stirrup Cup consistently comes through with a fine pie. My test for Pizza, is the bottom crust thoroughly cooked? Are the toppings generous and fresh? Stirrup Cup always satisfies; haven't had a failure yet. On top of that, when Kathy answers the phone, she remembers our regular order and asked if we want our usual. You can't beat that for service! She usually says pizza will be ready in 20 to 25 minutes, and it is always been hot and ready in that timeframe. We tip well for the great pizza and service, and recommend the Stirrup CupWhole heartedly.
I would like to give it a 3.5 star rating. Customer service is great Mary does a great job. I think they put a little too much cheese on their pizza. I like the crust and I like the sauce. overall I like it. I go there about three times a month.
Always hits the spot, super fast and delicious!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wonderful pizza, some fun video gamesAnd good service tonite. Thank you.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great pizza as always and fantastic dynamic customer service, shout out to Mary for making fantastic conversation and keeping a good
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
awesome pizza. we like the meaty pizza. highly recommend a stop here if you're in the area and crave pizzas.
Pizza was delicious and our server Mary was the best! She gave great recommendations. The bread sticks were great too.
Best family pizza in the valley.
Do yourself a favor and order the chicken Cesar pie. I started ordering it 20 years ago when I was in middle school and lived here and now it is a tradition every time we come back to visit. So good, warm savory comfort food.
The pizza here was very good. The pizza was deep but the dough was still crispy and not soggy or greasy. The bread sticks rocked too. I had never had ranch as a dipping sauce for bread sticks before coming to California, but now I'm a believer! Service was excellent.
i'm a 12 year resident of carmel valley. this place has definitely been hit or miss for me. i've ordered here about 10 times over the years. haven't been there for a few years so thought i would give it a try. phone ordered a medium thin crust pizza with 2 toppings and a personal thin crust pizza and a caesar salad. came out to ~$45. REVIEW: 1 of the toppings was missing on the medium pizza, not close to thin crust and there was so much sauce on it that the that the dough was absolutely gooey. yuck. the personal margaretta pizza was not thin crust at all and the report back was it was pretty good. the salad was not that fresh, definitely chucky cheese quality and the dressing so fishy we thought it was turned. didn't eat it. won't be going back anytime soon here for anything to eat. I CAN'T RECOMMEND TO ANYONE I KNOW. bummer...
Restaurantji Recommends
I love their pizza with very fresh ingredients, especially their added touch of grilled onions and garlic. The crust is always perfect and when you want extra added ingredients they really add extra. One of the best pizza around and I've had plenty from local/Us to Other countries.
This place is excellent
Best pizza I've eaten in years! Great outdoor patio, excellent service, conveniently located in the heart of the village. Locals appear to frequent this place alot.
Excellent pizza !! love the location, customer service and the really yummy roasted garlic. Great buffalo wings too!!
I live nearby to the Stirrup Cup Pizza, and I am so pleased they are my local pizza parlor. Stirrup Cup is our go to for conventional Pizza, and by that I mean American style, not fancy California style. If you were seeking upgrade California style pizza, I recommend nearby corkscrew or Café rustica. But Stirrup Cup consistently comes through with a fine pie. My test for Pizza, is the bottom crust thoroughly cooked? Are the toppings generous and fresh? Stirrup Cup always satisfies; haven't had a failure yet. On top of that, when Kathy answers the phone, she remembers our regular order and asked if we want our usual. You can't beat that for service! She usually says pizza will be ready in 20 to 25 minutes, and it is always been hot and ready in that timeframe. We tip well for the great pizza and service, and recommend the Stirrup CupWhole heartedly.