Pie Society Bar

353 E 17th St, Costa Mesa
(949) 313-6333

Recent Reviews

Samantha T.

Really poor service. Asked for assistance three times for the same item and eventually had to get up to get it myself because the same girl kept saying oh yea, I'll get that for you and than she was just dancing around in the kitchen area not paying attention. Went to the booth next to us to clear the table while we still waited for the boxes to go for 10 minutes. The pizzas were just okay, I've had better. The pizza was burnt and very bland. Really sad because people have hyped up this place and it was a true disappointment.

Sean Sloan

Always a pleasure, great crowd.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Aaron Hudson

Everyone else is spot on. Cute place with a great vibe. Walked vet the road from another bar that was a bit bog standard meat market and it just felt nicely welcoming and alternative. That might have been the Alana Morrisset playing, or the very wide age group of 20-70years old but I liked it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5

Miss Cactus

Laid back spot with an entrance from the exit sign. Has a welcoming vibe. Nice place to grab drinks with friends. It's connected to PitFire Pizza. The food menu is the same as the restaurant. The food is on point and goes well with a nice cold beer.The bartenders are super friendly! The place is cozy and intimate!Vegetarian options: Vegan Pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

P T

Gets a Lil loud if a lot of people.

Atmosphere: 4

Service: 5

Christine Williams

What a gem of a place! We went at 6pm on a Saturday and there were a few groups there but it really picked up by 7. Low light and fun atmosphere would make this a great date spot. And you can’t beat the prices of the drinks. Plus you can order food off the Pitfire menu! This might be my new go to bar.Vegetarian options: Tons of vegetarian options, and they will remove meat or put it on the side of your pizza if you request it.Parking: Big free parking lot. It does fill up at busy times.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 4

Juli Tsang

Had a wonderful time at the bar, great service, food, drinks and vibe!Vegetarian options: None of us were V but we all three ended up ordering as such, and laughed about it. Field Mushroom, Margherita, Burrata, didn't even miss the meat! Excellent!!Parking: we were there early enough to have it not be an issue. but I can see where it could be.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Field Mushroom Pizza

Mason B.

The pizza isn't cooked correctly . The only reason it was cool because it was a hidden door... the chicken wings were not even edible and the pizza cheese literally fell right off the crust. It's not cooked correctly or the oven isn't right.

Eric S.

Awesome speak easy inside Pitfire. The bartender here introduced me to east sides, which are my new favorite gin drinks!

C

Awesome little speakeasy style spot behind pit fire pizza. Drinks were on point and the food was amazing!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Breandon V.

Amazing cheesy knots and even better pizza! Along with a beautiful glass of liquid gold

Dora S.

Dive bar - speakeasy feel inside. Some drinks were great (i especially loved their clarified piña colada and the pretty bird) while others fell flat in my opinion, but props to the bartenders!! They work hard and definitely show passion in their work. Love the pizza over at pit-fire as well, so great spot for food and drinks overall.

Dave

Hidden gem. Great cocktails, friendly staff, pretty solid food. Prices are also not outrageous

Michelle L.

This place has been on my list for a while since they have a vegan cheese option you can add to your pizza. Upon entering your order at the counter and then take your number and sit down. I do wish they had a smaller pizza size so that I could get one pizza and half that be my serving. This is about two servings for me and so I it ended up being a little bit more expensive than I wanted to spend but I had leftovers. The vegan cheese is very delicious. They use on the pizza. I added some tomatoes olives, and bell pepper. The pizza was really delicious. However I was not that big of a fan of the thick crust. I usually really enjoy pizza crust, but I wasn't that big of a fan so I ended up leaving the crust and not eating it.The server was nice and checked on us multiple times and brought us a water and glasses, which was nice to have. Inside they have a lot of booths and it is a very casual vibe. There was a birthday party going on and for a Tuesday night the ambience was casual and pretty quiet. I have heard it gets busy here on weekends.

Tracy L.

Dark date vibes speakeasy with really good pizza! There's two entrances; one from the back parking lot and another through the kitchen inside the restaurant. Small and cozy inside. Saw a lot of couples on dates, even first dates (I'm nosy lol). Ordered the pepperoni and enough to feed two people. Drinks were good too. Everything is decently priced for the area. Service was also attentive and friendly. Found seats right away on a Tuesday evening.

Load More