Humble Sea Tavern | Felton

6256 CA-9, Felton
(831) 704-2150

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Jay X

Tried to go on Saturday after it was supposed to be open, and it was closed. No sign stating why it was closed. Called the posted phone # and no answer. We were in the area for a couple more hours and noticed it wasn't open still.

Service: 1

Jon Bell

Great Cold beer, excellent service

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Cristina Tortora

The place itself is fine, but the prices are way too high for the quality. We ordered a “Caesar” salad for $20 — it was just lettuce, dressing, grated cheese, and capers. Very disappointing. I even asked for bread or croutons, but they said no. Definitely not worth the price.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 1

Rebecca Rainbolt

Very nice afternoon, and the beer was cold. It's a bit too loud for me inside. They had nice and clean bathrooms. Service was very nice. We only had the fries to go with our beer, but they were delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

T D

Pretty good vibes in there! Probably the hipest spot in Felton.

Drinks are $8 and up, doesn't seem like they have a happy hour.

Always seems to be problems with the bathrooms. 💁

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 2

Mark Trueman

Over in San Francisco from Perth Australia and popped in for a couple of beers, awesome spot and great beers, staff were super friendly and even grabbed some merch, get yourselves over and support these guys and have a cracking pint or four

Michael Day

I sat down with my granddaughters at a table for 20 minutes and no servers came to greet us, inform us about wait time or serve us. There were several servers there but they scurried around without avoiding eye contact.

It was lunch hour on the Sunday of Memorial Dat weekend. Obviously didn’t need our business, so I gave up and left.

Service: 1

Mairo Dog

Amazing visit in may 2025, great place

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Marianne Wyllie

Shout out for CHLOE. She poured us beer at Happy Hour on Thursday. The place had gotten really crowded; thirsty customers were lined up. Chloe exhibited “Grace under fire.” She remained calm and pleasant. That’s not easy!

Service: 5

Aaron Clark

Awesome spot. Super unique.The food is epic. Hours suck. So they are always packed. Which I’m sure is ideal for the servers. They seem to have designed it that way. They hustle hard which makes you feel like man they really are doing a great job…. But it also seems intentionally under staffed? Especially since there’s a very small tight crew of servers, the vibe is they are absolutely slaying it with tips. Which is great! For them. For you on the other hand, You have to wait in line. Stand in line to get a drink. Then if you want food you have to go wait in a different line. Again. Yet 20% gratuities still seem expected. Don’t get me wrong I love to hook up my people and tip well, always. But even if I’m “waiting” on them? Twice? I feel conflicted. And it seems to consume a lot of the night. Or connection you’d other wise be building with your comrade.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 2

Kevin Ryan

Great beers on tap

Claire Judson

So happy to have a place in town that has oysters and the best burgers.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Tony R

This place fell short to say the least. We ordered our food spent 100 between the two of us, couldn’t get silverware all the forks were gone, asked the front of the house to be told look in the draw which had none, went back she said I’ll be right back forgot, continued to help other customers order food so we walked away an sit down. The Cesar salad arrived to be grossly overdressed we didn’t even finish half of it, the spicy chicken sandwich was sloppily covered in ranch and was hard to hold together, the Frites Duck Confit was the only thing that was decent but overtly salted, then to top it off they forgot both the cannolis we ordered. Definitely will not be coming back and I say that with confidence!

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

KDG

Cool little place in the heart of Felton with great beer and tasty grub. Bartenders were incredibly friendly.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Amy Miller

Gourmet fine dining! Had the mackerel and squash, which was outstanding.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...

Humble Sea Tavern | Felton

6256 CA-9, Felton, CA 95018
(831) 704-2150