Was passing through town and stumbled upon this gem. The young man who took the order was super welcoming and helpful. Ordered half cheese and half veggie. Pizza was delicious, fresh, and hot. This is real Pizza, not conveyor belt Pizza like other places. Got to meet the owner who was very friendly, professional, and welcoming. They only use the finest and freshest ingredients. Give them a shot you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Markee Andrade
Wow. It's absolutely amazing.. Wish we would have tried them sooner. Perfect bubble trouble crust and an undercarriage that holds up. Can't wait to try another pie. This is honestly the best pizzeria in Oakdale and the surrounding area. Goodfellas is San Francisco was my favorite, and they just changed and let us down. Now our favorite is Stevie's. I want to try a Greek style or something Mediterranean š¤ anyways and I can't express enough that the crust is out of this world. Update: the large can't feed 3 people. Only complaint. Update 07/12/2025. The owner and the pizza maker made me a pizza, not even on the menu, Completely satisfied my hard to please complexed palette. The pie was absolutely amazing. Having a small town pizzeria, make this delicious of a pizza and this style is unheard of for our town. This Sicilian style Margarita was the best pizza I've had. It's absolutely amazing. Gorgeous presentation, and I really appreciate the owner going above and beyond for me. Because he didn't have too. It made the $40 pizza worth every penny because it's honestly a priceless pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Paul Samsin
The second time my order was incorrect.. when I spend 40 dollars on a pizza and have a request for ālightā toppings and they put EXTRA of that topping.. thatās an issue for me, I hate to be that guy. But I even called and told them about it and rather than saying they would correct it, they said Iāll make note of it for next timeā¦sorry wonāt be a next time ābudā Iāll be telling everybody I know in my barber shop NOT to Come here.. overpriced and wonāt fix their mistakes. Iām 40 dollars for a pizza and they Messed up a simple request, that I repeated on the phone order 3x. A real disappointment. Mediocre pizza with poor customer service
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
Eric Johnston
First of all this was my first time there.
Honest review
Pizza has a lot flop, but good, under carriage was cooked nicely. Iād give it a 7/10
Wings āvery very dry meatā maybe just a bad experience but Iāll definitely try again, hopefully itās better next time. 2/10
The wing sauce ātheir signature buffalo garlicā was like 9/10 very good.
I did pay for a ranch I did not get. All good though accidents happen
Environment and Hospitality was great 9/10
Iāll definitely return again, hopefully the chicken will be better.
Thanks again guys!
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Kevin Cleary
Good pizza. Nice people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Jess Kneela
The Sicilian is delish! My new fav pizza spot in Oakdale. Always a good experience from ordering, picking up and eating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Refugio Antonio
Great Pizza, great service! My daughter and I were referred here while in the Modesto area. We took a nice drive and were not disappointed when we arrived. The staff were friendly and hospitable. This place is clean and modern without sacrificing originality and quality in their product. We definitely will be back with friends and family.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Sabrina Fischer
We have quite a few pizza places in our area and Stevieās is super unique and delicious. You canāt compare any other place to Stevieās. The crust is delicious, the bake is always perfection. The price is a little high BUT you get what you pay for so itās understandable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Classic New York Style Pizza
Shannon Thomas
Came here for a combination pizza, and I love how friendly the employees are here. Love small pizza businesses like this, and there Pizza's are made fresh, and cooked to the delightful flavors. The establishment is nice, and clean, as well the have just the right amount of seating, and a TV to sit and watch during the game, while enjoying the delicious entrees. First time I met Steve the owner, and I love his attitude to making the customer happy, and being friendly, and making sure you are pleased with his food. I will be coming here more often.
Stevie's is a very cool spot in Oakdale. They blow away all the chain pizza restaurants in town by far. It's definitely the best pizza in the area. It's impossible to find crust with a gum line in Oakdale! It's perfect every time! Definitely recommend! My kids LOVE the Cheese Bread!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza, New York Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
Bonnie Pacheco
The gentleman asked several times if we were good. He is super nice that was ehy we had returned....but the young gal that took order got things for couple near us at another table 3 times and not once while passing our table asked if we needed anything or were OK. Could be inexperience, but those types of things will make me go elsewhere!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
steven carmack
Stevieās pizza is the best ever and I will share that every where they will let me from order to walking out was the best experience of my life and Iām A fat boy raised on pizza plus pizza in riverbank my whole life and I am converted Stevie is awesome took the time to tell us his favorite to his back story to just being a great person I will forever keep going here until he stops serving pizza only complaint I have is that his size stops at xl he should have idk 60in pizza lol I could not get enough I wanted more and more weeeeeeeeee neeed more Stevie donāt limit us on your size lol. Ingredients were amazing crust was perfect and this coming from someone with not the best teeth in the world it was all perfect keep up the great work and I will 10000000000000% be back as soon as possible
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Erpat oku
Amazing food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Steven Carmack
Stevieās pizza is legit the best pizza I have ever had in my life and i am 100 percent a fat boy born and raised for 36 years on pizza plus pizza in riverbank through 2 of the 2 owners lol I will never want any other pizza now I will drive 30 plus min From Modesto past 6 plus other pizza places to go to Stevieās my experience was amazing from ordering to leaving the owner Stevie himself was there and had a conversation with us and made us feel like family you are 100% missing out if you donāt eat here like legit you are stupid to not stop my only issue is there wasnāt enough I wish we would have ordered 5 pizzas I legit didnāt want to stop eating can not say it enough I am 100 percent converted will not go anywhere else unless I absolutely have to yet again hate to be repetitive but itās legit the best pizza Iāve had stopped in tonight 9-1-24 and will forever be a customer till the day I die or he stops serving pizza whatever come first
Was passing through town and stumbled upon this gem. The young man who took the order was super welcoming and helpful. Ordered half cheese and half veggie. Pizza was delicious, fresh, and hot. This is real Pizza, not conveyor belt Pizza like other places. Got to meet the owner who was very friendly, professional, and welcoming. They only use the finest and freshest ingredients. Give them a shot you won't be disappointed.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Wow. It's absolutely amazing.. Wish we would have tried them sooner. Perfect bubble trouble crust and an undercarriage that holds up. Can't wait to try another pie. This is honestly the best pizzeria in Oakdale and the surrounding area. Goodfellas is San Francisco was my favorite, and they just changed and let us down. Now our favorite is Stevie's. I want to try a Greek style or something Mediterranean š¤ anyways and I can't express enough that the crust is out of this world. Update: the large can't feed 3 people. Only complaint. Update 07/12/2025. The owner and the pizza maker made me a pizza, not even on the menu, Completely satisfied my hard to please complexed palette. The pie was absolutely amazing. Having a small town pizzeria, make this delicious of a pizza and this style is unheard of for our town. This Sicilian style Margarita was the best pizza I've had. It's absolutely amazing. Gorgeous presentation, and I really appreciate the owner going above and beyond for me. Because he didn't have too. It made the $40 pizza worth every penny because it's honestly a priceless pizza.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
The second time my order was incorrect..
when I spend 40 dollars on a pizza and have a request for ālightā toppings and they put EXTRA of that topping.. thatās an issue for me, I hate to be that guy. But I even called and told them about it and rather than saying they would correct it, they said Iāll make note of it for next timeā¦sorry wonāt be a next time ābudā Iāll be telling everybody I know in my barber shop NOT to Come here..
overpriced and wonāt fix their mistakes.
Iām
40 dollars for a pizza and they Messed up a simple request, that I repeated on the phone order 3x. A real disappointment. Mediocre pizza with poor customer service
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 1
First of all this was my first time there.
Honest review
Pizza has a lot flop, but good, under carriage was cooked nicely. Iād give it a 7/10
Wings āvery very dry meatā maybe just a bad experience but Iāll definitely try again, hopefully itās better next time. 2/10
The wing sauce ātheir signature buffalo garlicā was like 9/10 very good.
I did pay for a ranch I did not get. All good though accidents happen
Environment and Hospitality was great 9/10
Iāll definitely return again, hopefully the chicken will be better.
Thanks again guys!
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Good pizza. Nice people.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza
The Sicilian is delish! My new fav pizza spot in Oakdale. Always a good experience from ordering, picking up and eating.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great Pizza, great service! My daughter and I were referred here while in the Modesto area. We took a nice drive and were not disappointed when we arrived. The staff were friendly and hospitable. This place is clean and modern without sacrificing originality and quality in their product. We definitely will be back with friends and family.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We have quite a few pizza places in our area and Stevieās is super unique and delicious. You canāt compare any other place to Stevieās. The crust is delicious, the bake is always perfection. The price is a little high BUT you get what you pay for so itās understandable.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Classic New York Style Pizza
Came here for a combination pizza, and I love how friendly the employees are here. Love small pizza businesses like this, and there Pizza's are made fresh, and cooked to the delightful flavors.
The establishment is nice, and clean, as well the have just the right amount of seating, and a TV to sit and watch during the game, while enjoying the delicious entrees.
First time I met Steve the owner, and I love his attitude to making the customer happy, and being friendly, and making sure you are pleased with his food. I will be coming here more often.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza and wings are fire
Restaurantji Recommends
Stevie's is a very cool spot in Oakdale. They blow away all the chain pizza restaurants in town by far. It's definitely the best pizza in the area. It's impossible to find crust with a gum line in Oakdale! It's perfect every time! Definitely recommend! My kids LOVE the Cheese Bread!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza, New York Pizza, Pepperoni Pizza
The gentleman asked several times if we were good. He is super nice that was ehy we had returned....but the young gal that took order got things for couple near us at another table 3 times and not once while passing our table asked if we needed anything or were OK. Could be inexperience, but those types of things will make me go elsewhere!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 2
Stevieās pizza is the best ever and I will share that every where they will let me from order to walking out was the best experience of my life and Iām
A fat boy raised on pizza plus pizza in riverbank my whole life and I am converted Stevie is awesome took the time to tell us his favorite to his back story to just being a great person I will forever keep going here until he stops serving pizza only complaint I have is that his size stops at xl he should have idk 60in pizza lol I could not get enough I wanted more and more weeeeeeeeee neeed more Stevie donāt limit us on your size lol. Ingredients were amazing crust was perfect and this coming from someone with not the best teeth in the world it was all perfect keep up the great work and I will 10000000000000% be back as soon as possible
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Amazing food
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Stevieās pizza is legit the best pizza I have ever had in my life and i am 100 percent a fat boy born and raised for 36 years on pizza plus pizza in riverbank through 2 of the 2 owners lol I will never want any other pizza now I will drive 30 plus min From Modesto past 6 plus other pizza places to go to Stevieās my experience was amazing from ordering to leaving the owner Stevie himself was there and had a conversation with us and made us feel like family you are 100% missing out if you donāt eat here like legit you are stupid to not stop my only issue is there wasnāt enough I wish we would have ordered 5 pizzas I legit didnāt want to stop eating can not say it enough I am 100 percent converted will not go anywhere else unless I absolutely have to yet again hate to be repetitive but itās legit the best pizza Iāve had stopped in tonight 9-1-24 and will forever be a customer till the day I die or he stops serving pizza whatever come first
Loading...