Inconstant Quality: Sometimes it's great and sometimes it's lousy. Sometimes, we've found the gluten free pizza at Acre Pizza/Petaluma to be some of the best around. However we cannot count on having good pizza there. In recent months: once it was severely burned and black (the server told me that's normal and I insisted they redo it). Another time the thick crust pizza was like raw dough in the middle (clearly not cooked enough). Sometimes the pizza is flooded with cheese (fine by me). Tonight there was hardly any cheese or sauce and the flat surface of the pizza had large, bare sections. Sometime the sauce has nice flavor. Tonight it was acidic and the pizza was pretty tasteless. Several times, the veggie pizza has come with black olives. On another occasion it didn't and the cashier refused to add them even when I said I'd pay extra. Sometimes there are sun-dried tomatoes on the veggie pizza and sometimes not. We live 20-25 minutes away and used to look forward to Acre Pizza. But I doubt we're going to continue to make the trip when the quality simply isn't reliable and the price on the higher end.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
Josie Schmitt
We spent close to $80 on two small pizzas and two drinks. One pizza came out with charcoal burnt veggies across the top which made the entire thing taste horrible. When we mentioned it, it was ignored. The second pizza was thin as a piece of paper with no flavor. Very disappointing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Jerry Volkin
Good pizza!
Chris Voet
They take extra care with their dough. So thin, so crispy. Cool place with 5 pinball machines, pool table, shuffleboard.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Robert Eckart
This used to be a nice Petaluma coffee shop until Covid. Now it's a spacious hall with pinball machines and loud music. Average pizzas with maximum prices. Just sayin'...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Melissa Martin
Great food and fun casual environment. Pizza slices are amazing. Love the pool table and pin ball machines!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike P
We came here for lunch to try some vegan pies, and they definitely exceeded our expectations! I ordered the fungi pizza and the potato pie, and both were amazing. We almost finished them completely! The crust was wonderfully baked and definitely worth eating. They also made for great leftovers during the rest of our road trip. I'm sure their non-vegan pizzas are excellent too!
Garry Graffort
Great choice for pizza! Highly recommend the Detroit style!
This post was made in connection with a Toast promotion.
Daniel R
This place is cool pizza is good and it’s family friendly got a lot of games and 2 big screen tvs. Got to check this place out
Kathy Howard
I have driven by here many times, and finally went in to check out the place. What caught my eye was the signage, pizza + pinball= Two Of My Favorite Things! Atmosphere was inviting, nice family tables, some booths, self serve area for water, cups, napkins, Parmesan cheese, red pepper flakes, silverware, etc. They offer slices, which I ordered. The pepperoni slice with hot honey, n cheese, caught my eye, they heated my slice and I went to check out the Pinball machines. They also have a pool table.
Pizza shaped as a Heart, only at Acre, only on V-Day. Great crust and great toppings. Make it a V-Day tradition.
Benjamin Sutsos
The gabagool is crazzzzy like one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. Wow wow and I'm eating it reheated 1 hr later still the best.
C
So grateful to have such an amazing pizza place so close to home!! Vegan options are amazing! Way better employees than those at the Cotati location. For value however I must give 4 stars instead of 5 because $30+ per pie is more expensive than even the best pizzas in San Francisco, which are closer to $20. Plus tax and tip you could easily be paying $90 for two pizzas, which is bonkers.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
CorissaMarie
Really enjoyed the Chicago sausage. It was the perfect size for 2 people to split if you’re not super hungry.
Inconstant Quality: Sometimes it's great and sometimes it's lousy. Sometimes, we've found the gluten free pizza at Acre Pizza/Petaluma to be some of the best around. However we cannot count on having good pizza there. In recent months: once it was severely burned and black (the server told me that's normal and I insisted they redo it). Another time the thick crust pizza was like raw dough in the middle (clearly not cooked enough). Sometimes the pizza is flooded with cheese (fine by me). Tonight there was hardly any cheese or sauce and the flat surface of the pizza had large, bare sections. Sometime the sauce has nice flavor. Tonight it was acidic and the pizza was pretty tasteless. Several times, the veggie pizza has come with black olives. On another occasion it didn't and the cashier refused to add them even when I said I'd pay extra. Sometimes there are sun-dried tomatoes on the veggie pizza and sometimes not. We live 20-25 minutes away and used to look forward to Acre Pizza. But I doubt we're going to continue to make the trip when the quality simply isn't reliable and the price on the higher end.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 4
We spent close to $80 on two small pizzas and two drinks. One pizza came out with charcoal burnt veggies across the top which made the entire thing taste horrible. When we mentioned it, it was ignored. The second pizza was thin as a piece of paper with no flavor. Very disappointing.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Good pizza!
They take extra care with their dough. So thin, so crispy. Cool place with 5 pinball machines, pool table, shuffleboard.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
This used to be a nice Petaluma coffee shop until Covid. Now it's a spacious hall with pinball machines and loud music. Average pizzas with maximum prices. Just sayin'...
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Great food and fun casual environment. Pizza slices are amazing. Love the pool table and pin ball machines!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We came here for lunch to try some vegan pies, and they definitely exceeded our expectations! I ordered the fungi pizza and the potato pie, and both were amazing. We almost finished them completely! The crust was wonderfully baked and definitely worth eating. They also made for great leftovers during the rest of our road trip. I'm sure their non-vegan pizzas are excellent too!
Great choice for pizza! Highly recommend the Detroit style!
This post was made in connection with a Toast promotion.
This place is cool pizza is good and it’s family friendly got a lot of games and 2 big screen tvs. Got to check this place out
I have driven by here many times, and finally went in to check out the place. What caught my eye was the signage, pizza + pinball= Two Of My Favorite Things! Atmosphere was inviting, nice family tables, some booths, self serve area for water, cups, napkins, Parmesan cheese, red pepper flakes, silverware, etc. They offer slices, which I ordered. The pepperoni slice with hot honey, n cheese, caught my eye, they heated my slice and I went to check out the Pinball machines. They also have a pool table.
Restaurantji Recommends
Pizza shaped as a Heart, only at Acre, only on V-Day. Great crust and great toppings. Make it a V-Day tradition.
The gabagool is crazzzzy like one of the best pizzas I've had in a long time. Wow wow and I'm eating it reheated 1 hr later still the best.
So grateful to have such an amazing pizza place so close to home!! Vegan options are amazing! Way better employees than those at the Cotati location. For value however I must give 4 stars instead of 5 because $30+ per pie is more expensive than even the best pizzas in San Francisco, which are closer to $20. Plus tax and tip you could easily be paying $90 for two pizzas, which is bonkers.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Really enjoyed the Chicago sausage. It was the perfect size for 2 people to split if you’re not super hungry.
All very rich!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 3
Loading...