OTL Fine Catering

144 American Alley, Petaluma
(707) 766-9810

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Carolyn Cole

OTL catered our wedding reception - they were wonderful to work with, very communicative and flexible and the food was delicious!!

John Alden

They did a great job for the couple and guests at Mountain House Estate last night.

Jennifer Schwam

Our wedding meal was absolutely unforgettable!

We opted for family-style service with a menu featuring salmon, tri-tip, roasted veggies, mushroom tarts, and garlic mashed potatoes—and every dish was a standout. The salmon was moist and flavorful, the tri-tip was tender and perfectly seasoned, and the sides added the perfect touch of warmth and richness.

Serving family-style created such a fun, inviting atmosphere that our guests loved. People are still talking about how incredible the food was! If you’re looking for a caterer to make your event truly memorable, we can’t recommend them enough!

Alicia Allen

Best of the Best!

Alicia Bling Bling Kona Consuelo

Best of the Best!

Chris Bertnick

We recently had OTL Fine Catering make all of the food for our wedding, and I have to say, they absolutely knocked it out of the park. Unbelievable.The owner, Bethany, is an absolute pleasure to work with. She bent over backwards to make everything on our wedding day perfect!ALL of the food was AMAZING! The team came to an outdoor venue, served amazing food, and provided exceptional wait service for 160+ people. I cannot express how impressed I was. Everyone at the wedding could not stop talking about dinner. I would put our wedding food up against any fine dining restaurant in Sonoma County.If I ever have a need for a caterer again, I'm making one phone call, and one phone call only. Thanks OTL!!

Chris Bertnick

We recently had OTL Fine Catering make all of the food for our wedding, and I have to say, they absolutely knocked it out of the park. Unbelievable. The owner, Bethany, is an absolute pleasure to work with. She bent over backwards to make everything on our wedding day perfect! ALL of the food was AMAZING! The team came to an outdoor venue, served amazing food, and provided exceptional wait service for 160+ people. I cannot express how impressed I was. Everyone at the wedding could not stop talking about dinner. I would put our wedding food up against any fine dining restaurant in Sonoma County. If I ever have a need for a caterer again, I'm making one phone call, and one phone call only. Thanks OTL!!

Erin Bennett

Super impressed. They did a fabulous job. Easy to work with, food was delish

Olivia Horan

We used OTL for our wedding and they were fabulous. We did passed appetizers and a buffet dinner. The buffet was executed beautifully and the food was simply amazing. I am not sure how they can make salmon for 130 people without it being overcooked, especially in a buffet setting, but Bethany and her team definitely pulled it off! They also killed it on the cakes. They were very flexible with last minute allergy requests, and the changing final head count. When you book with them, you are getting their head chef, Bethany, on site running the show. Their staff were super professional, efficient, and nice. They are a small team, so don't expect the incredibly fast turn around time with emails and phone calls that you get with the big catering companies. But we loved that about them! A very intimate and personalized experience. We trusted Bethany and George's process and didn't feel the need to be in contact with them constantly. Would definitely book with them again!!

Forni Farm

We used OTL for our picnic event; the food was delicious, and presentation was perfect. All of our guests love their individual lunch boxes. Not to mention they are such a pleasure to work with. Highly recommend for large or small events. We will be using them again for sure.

Melissa Rodriguez

They did an amazing job on our wedding day. safe, thoughtful, Delicious beautiful food, wonderful staff, going the extra mile for us and our family. we couldn't be happier. The owner Bethany, made us feel at ease and if something went wrong, we had no idea .. 10 star !

Diana Rangaves

Salmon pastry dinner absolutely outstanding outstanding.Wow! Thank you delicious and extraordinary. ♥️ Nice and easy heating instructions for me. 🙄Thank you. Very special dinner for my mother and me. Merry Christmas 📯 Diana Rangaves.

Alejandrina Cervantes

The food is delicious!!!! I want to say they are also the nicest people.

Loading...