Petaluma Creamery Ice Cream & Cheese Shop

We stopped in to grab some lunch and cheese curds. The cheese selection is great! And loved the five options to sample.
The sandwich was huge! And lots of meat and cheese. Really tasty! The girl working could not be less interested in being there. But she did make great sandwiches.

I'm rooting for this place! They have some new leadership behind the counter and she seems eager to reinvent the experience once she gets her ideas rolled out, which is an exciting prospect. The service we've received, dropping in on a semi-weekly basis for some ice cream, has been great. Outdoor seating is sunny in the afternoons, and there is a small greenbelt with large leafy trees right across the street. It's a pleasant and mellow place with a seasoned, down to earth charm (the business is more than 100 years old). We plan to be regulars this summer.

Great shop

We’ve been buying cheese from this creamery in Southern California, and it is delicious.
We stopped to visit on our way to our friends.
Their ice-cream is fantastic too

Absolutely THE BEST cheese and ice cream!!! The garlic jack cheese is outstanding and pistachio ice cream us delightful!

Good ice cream
Goood chesse.

McKayla was so nice and offered some suggestions on what cheeses we would like (the spicy jack on sourdough was a great combination for grilled cheese). We were able to get a tour and Kevin was so knowledgeable! You can taste the difference in quality and approach at this local creamery.

This place has gone downhill quite a bit. They are short on food. Didn’t have lettuce or the Tri-tip and the bread was old

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: Sandwiches

Don’t even try going here. Came all the way from San Jose just to find out that they were closed on a Saturday at 2:30? Doors were locked and the employee was just looking from the inside, not even acknowledging us. Left and headed down to Angela’s WHICH WAS OPEN and very kind to us. Y’all lost a customer and I hope you lose more 🤞

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

Staff was wonderfully, and the prices great. The sandwich was a great value and really good. The ice cream had very little flavor and seemed very icy, not very creamy at all

Great homemade ice cream!!! Phenomenal cheeses.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

This place is run by kids who have no idea what they are doing and care more about social media than listening to customers. The bread was stale, the cheese sample selection was slim and they gave a look when you ask for others that were out. They were out of the tri-tip sandwich, as well as any lettuce and tomato you wanted on the sandwich they did have. Ordered a grilled cheese with tomato and she put mayo on it, never said they didn’t have tomato. Then, they also ran out of bread (makes sense why it was stale). Didn’t bother with the ice cream since it looked sad. The girl also didn’t wash her hands in between handling money/using the register and making the sandwiches.
The business’ social media is what brought us to visit and it was an extremely disappointing experience. Also, if your friends are going to visit, maybe don’t act like you work there by standing behind the counter…
The cheese isn’t even anything to write home about.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

This is an amazing place to visit, the cheese is the creamiest most delicious and the prices are great.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Very delicious sandwiches and super filling!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Remarkable flavor. I tried their asiago and bought the 2 year aged white cheddar. The asiago was extremely delicious but a little out of my price range. I am happy with the block of cheddar, just the same.

Food: 5

Service: 5