Stumbled upon this gem while at an nearby event. Pizza is amazing! The crust was perfect! The staff were very friendly and service was wonderful! Will be back if ever in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jamie Walin
best pizza around i swear 😩 so thin and delectable. if you think there's better pizza you havent been here yet. very affordable and delicious!! never eating pizza ANYWHERE ever again. The employees were so nice and friendly. Joao was a great server, and so was the guy with the bangs. Beautiful environment and aesthetic. Lovely establishment
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sauce, Pepperoni Pizza, My Personal Creation Pesto Mushroom Garlic Pepperoni, Carrot Cake, Cheese Pizza, Margherita Pizza, Corte Madera Classic Pizza, Pesto Chicken Special Pizza, Slice of Sausage Pizza, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Snickerdoodle, Red Velvet Cake, Chicken Wings, Caesar Salad - Salad, Boneless Chicken Tenders with Hot Sauce Ranch or BBQ Sauce, Hawaiian Pizza, Seafood, Calzone - Large 14''
Christie love
I ordered a pizza and and told the young boy I wanted the pizza extra extra crispy when I got the receipt it wasn’t on there he told me he did me favor not putting on there because I would have to pay extra I never heard of a place charging you to have your pizza cooked extra crispy 🙄😏
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
Mary Stewart
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ Stefano’s is our go-to pizza spot in Petaluma. The food is always delicious & the staff is friendly. We’ve taken family here when they visit from out of town, and it’s always a hit—especially the slices.
It’s casual, quick, and consistent..which is exactly what you want in a neighborhood pizza place. Whether we’re picking up dinner or grabbing a table with the kids, Stefano’s never disappoints.
Support your local spots—this one’s a keeper. 🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donghyun Kim
Taste was good and ingredients were fresh. Had combination pizza.
Linden Loutsch
BEST PIZZA EVER
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Chicken Special Pizza, Plain Slice of Pizza
Nilima Desai
We ordered vegetarian pizza, they had good choices. We could get half and half which helped taste two different varieties. Value for money.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marie Baker
My husband and I had pretty good slices and the price included fountain drinks - total lunch for two was under $16, which I think is a great deal compared to just about any other place to eat in Petaluma. The young man at the counter was very pleasnt, the place was clean and we enjoyed eating in a booth. We're seniors and happy to know that when we visit Petaluma we can sit down for a quick and filling lunch without paying $40+
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Carol Vargas
My friends and I love coming to this place. Their pizza and sandwiches are good. The place is clean and the customer services is good. They are kind.
We ordered an extra large, came out thin and undercooked, even though I never ordered a thin crust. The wings tasted old like they were re fried and dry, and the chicken inside was nasty. I've never been to a pizza place where the pizza was made with no love. I was very disappointed coming here. Pizza should taste good, cheese should be ozzing and crust should be cooked more. I would suggest the cook put more time in cooking pizza. I've never really ever had a bad pizza either.
Caroline Purtell
Always exceptional
Manolo Irizarry
My favorite pizza place is located an hour and fifteen minutes away. I go there twice a month. The pepperoni and roasted garlic pizza is delicious.
Aleksey Z
I'm honestly surprised this pizza place has such high reviews. The pizza wasn't great—overly salty, overcooked, not enough cheese and sauce, and the slices weren't even cut evenly. Plus, $29 for a large pie feels steep for what you get. Unfortunately, it just didn’t hit the mark for me. If you're looking for better pizza, I'd recommend trying The New Yorker a few blocks away—it’s a much better experience!
The Renaissarian
Pretty Decent Pizza... ABout AVerage... Only Plain and Pepperoni SLices To Go... At Least They Had SLices and NOT Just Pies... $7 Bucks For 2 Plain SLices... But My Friends Were Waiting For Thier Chicken Pesto Sandwiches So One Of Em Went to Ask... And Holy Sh!t The Sandwiches Were Sitting In the Back Cuz the Manager Left Em Without Saying Anything... Employees Were Kool...
Stumbled upon this gem while at an nearby event. Pizza is amazing! The crust was perfect! The staff were very friendly and service was wonderful! Will be back if ever in the area.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
best pizza around i swear 😩 so thin and delectable. if you think there's better pizza you havent been here yet. very affordable and delicious!! never eating pizza ANYWHERE ever again. The employees were so nice and friendly. Joao was a great server, and so was the guy with the bangs. Beautiful environment and aesthetic. Lovely establishment
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Sauce, Pepperoni Pizza, My Personal Creation Pesto Mushroom Garlic Pepperoni, Carrot Cake, Cheese Pizza, Margherita Pizza, Corte Madera Classic Pizza, Pesto Chicken Special Pizza, Slice of Sausage Pizza, Chocolate Chip Cookie, Snickerdoodle, Red Velvet Cake, Chicken Wings, Caesar Salad - Salad, Boneless Chicken Tenders with Hot Sauce Ranch or BBQ Sauce, Hawaiian Pizza, Seafood, Calzone - Large 14''
I ordered a pizza and and told the young boy I wanted the pizza extra extra crispy when I got the receipt it wasn’t on there he told me he did me favor not putting on there because I would have to pay extra I never heard of a place charging you to have your pizza cooked extra crispy 🙄😏
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 1
⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Stefano’s is our go-to pizza spot in Petaluma. The food is always delicious & the staff is friendly. We’ve taken family here when they visit from out of town, and it’s always a hit—especially the slices.
It’s casual, quick, and consistent..which is exactly what you want in a neighborhood pizza place. Whether we’re picking up dinner or grabbing a table with the kids, Stefano’s never disappoints.
Support your local spots—this one’s a keeper. 🍕
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Taste was good and ingredients were fresh. Had combination pizza.
BEST PIZZA EVER
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pesto Chicken Special Pizza, Plain Slice of Pizza
We ordered vegetarian pizza, they had good choices. We could get half and half which helped taste two different varieties. Value for money.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I had pretty good slices and the price included fountain drinks - total lunch for two was under $16, which I think is a great deal compared to just about any other place to eat in Petaluma. The young man at the counter was very pleasnt, the place was clean and we enjoyed eating in a booth. We're seniors and happy to know that when we visit Petaluma we can sit down for a quick and filling lunch without paying $40+
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My friends and I love coming to this place. Their pizza and sandwiches are good. The place is clean and the customer services is good. They are kind.
great service
Restaurantji Recommends
We ordered an extra large, came out thin and undercooked, even though I never ordered a thin crust. The wings tasted old like they were re fried and dry, and the chicken inside was nasty. I've never been to a pizza place where the pizza was made with no love. I was very disappointed coming here. Pizza should taste good, cheese should be ozzing and crust should be cooked more. I would suggest the cook put more time in cooking pizza. I've never really ever had a bad pizza either.
Always exceptional
My favorite pizza place is located an hour and fifteen minutes away. I go there twice a month. The pepperoni and roasted garlic pizza is delicious.
I'm honestly surprised this pizza place has such high reviews. The pizza wasn't great—overly salty, overcooked, not enough cheese and sauce, and the slices weren't even cut evenly. Plus, $29 for a large pie feels steep for what you get. Unfortunately, it just didn’t hit the mark for me. If you're looking for better pizza, I'd recommend trying The New Yorker a few blocks away—it’s a much better experience!
Pretty Decent Pizza... ABout AVerage... Only Plain and Pepperoni SLices To Go... At Least They Had SLices and NOT Just Pies... $7 Bucks For 2 Plain SLices... But My Friends Were Waiting For Thier Chicken Pesto Sandwiches So One Of Em Went to Ask... And Holy Sh!t The Sandwiches Were Sitting In the Back Cuz the Manager Left Em Without Saying Anything... Employees Were Kool...
Loading...