The Bagel Mill
212 Western Ave, Petaluma
(707) 981-8010
Customers' Favorites
Closed Lox on Whole Wheat Everything Bagel
Roasted Strawberry Cream Cheese
Toasted Everything Bagel
Classic Lox Open
Avocado Toast
Garlic Bagel
Lox Sandwich
Pizza Bagel
Drip Coffee
Pesto Bagel
Menu
Photos
+60 photos
+59 photos
Add a photo
Order Online
Recent Reviews
The Jorge exceeded our expectations, I had to call them and let them know. I had mines on the pesto bagel with the Sriracha mayo on the side. The dip was a melodic chef's kiss. I haven't mmm'd and mmm'd in so long. Straight 🔥 🔥 🔥 fiirreee! My companion had theirs on a pizza bagel with the mayo on. Oh my Jorge!! Seriously, go get in line!!
This was my first time coming here and oh my gosh 10/10!!! This has to be the best bagel shop that has the traditional open face lox and cream cheese special!! The sliced salmon was super fresh, cream cheese was delicious!! The onions were thinly sliced, and the capers were just amazing!! I was really shook!! My favorite place is in New York City, but this comes right behind! I seriously recommend this place!! The staff here is wonderful, super friendly!!! This is my new spot!!!
I'm a big fan of The Bagel Mill. I eat here a few times a week, and have tried most of the menu. I think the quality of the ingredients is beautiful, and sometimes I'm just blown away by something that could be very simple, such as Avocado Toast, and how they have made it into a small work of art. I really like the staff here. They are kind, dedicated, and sometimes extremely patient describing items. My favorite item on the menu is the Apple Butter latte. It is...
You May Also Like
Stockhome - 220 Western Ave
![]()
Mediterranean, Scandinavian, Vegan, Vegetarian
Street Social - 29 F Petaluma Blvd N
![]()
American, Wine Bar, New American, Vegan
Hallie's Diner - 125 Keller St
![]()
American, Pet Friendly, Vegan, Vegetarian