All great! Last evening it was Sicilian salad with "The Bomb" pizza. I would definitely have it again, but think there will be a new delicious equivalent to order next time we order from The Mad Sicilian!
SuzAnne R.
We shopped hungry, but we'll have amazing lunches this week! I had the Sicilian with pancetta and my wife had the Green Door! Absolutely fresh and delicious!
James Z.
It was my niece's birthday today and we stopped by Starbucks next door to grab a hot drink. The owner of the Mad Sicilian approached us while we were parking with a big smile. He told us that they were testing out their Pizza of the Month and invited us inside to try it. We happily obliged! And wow, it was D-Licious! The crust was crunchy and chewy at the same time and the pizza sauce was perfect. You could tell all the ingredients were of real high quality. They couldn't have been more friendly and I'll happily come back to try their other offerings, including yummy pasta! Thanks again Mad Sicilian- what a treat!
Bonnie H.
After Little Star, I never thought I'd fall in love with another deep dish pizza place, until Mad Sicilian. We've been getting deep dish from Mad Sicilian for a couple of years now. And it is for sure one of, if not, the best deep dish pizza in the Bay Area. Yes, better than Zachary's. For sure better than Patxi's. And sadly, as of late, better than Little Star. (Only because the last couple of times I went there, the quality seemed to have slipped). What makes it so good? The mountains of cheese stuffed inside this pizza. You can't tell right away because of the beautiful sauce on top. But it is loaded. And of course, the crust. Flavorful, slightly dusted with corn meal and brushed with an herb topping. It is sooo good. How much do we like it? We ordered Mad Sicilian for our wedding rehearsal dinner. You can tell that the owners love pizza, and they love THEIR pizza. They seem like the type of people who would never trade on quality. My wish is that they open a bigger location where there are more than 2 tables so that we can eat in more often. Being in Novato, the traffic deters us from going there to pick up a pizza and bring it back. But if there is a bigger location, we'd be okay with fighting traffic to eat in. Besides the deep dish, we've also had the sicilian which is also delicious with their herb coating all over the crust. Really yummy. And their service is also always excellent. Once the pizza was taking longer than expected, and they gave us some free dessert. You can just tell the owners want to take care of their customers and give them the best they can give you. I super appreciate that as well. Anyhow, if you like deep dish, give them a try! We've heard their regular pizzas are delicious too - but how do we not get the deep dish?!
Jodi W.
Just happened to walk by and the delicious enticing aroma caught my nose and we had to stop in for a taste. Found two lovely women, one a fellow Michigander, very pleasant and helpful with the menu. The pizza was very delicious and flavorful., the aroma didn't lie! The garlic breadsticks were especially yummy and the newly made pesto dip topped it off wonderfully. The owner had us try a new menu item, the flavor of the month pizza, I will be back to get another one. Very good!!! Stop in for a sniff of the delicious aromas and stay for a bite, you won't be disappointed!
Austin Leatham
Solid pizza. Killer service and bomb pizza. Go Chicago.
Tom Shapland
So delicious!
Jeremy R.
I was so excited to try Mad Sicilian so I put it on the list for my wife's birthday pizza crawl. This was our second stop and we came to celebrate our shared Chicago heritage with their stuffed pizza. We opted for a large with spinach, mushrooms and artichoke hearts.new settled in and waited for our pie. After about half an hour it was time. The pizza was beautiful with tasty sauce and gooey cheese. Unfortunately the vegetable fillings were scant and the whole thing needed another 5-10 minutes in the oven as the center was only warm and the bottom was soggy (Paul Hollywood would not have been pleased). They also only have bottled drinks, no cups or glasses. Staff were friendly and attentive. They have the basic Chicago style concept down, it just needs a little fine tuning.
Emy C.
Good pizza and really good menu with lots of options for everyone. They rotate a few creative recipes for anyone who is looking for something fun and different. Recommend ordering to go verses delivery. Crust just isn't quite right when it sits.
Amadeo D.
We've ordered for delivery twice now. The Sicilian pizza crust was bland and chewy. They screwed up our order but even the correct toppings would not have saved it. Skip the Sicilian style pies. The Mad pizzas are among the best we've had in town. High quality ingredients and a flavorful chewy crust. Recommend! I would not normally yelp about a salad from a pizza joint, but the Greek Salad is exceptional. The feta they use is creamy and salty and the Kalamata olives were plump. The dressing is pink colored (red wing vinegar?), loaded with herbs, and super tangy. Also highly recommended. Would have been an easy 4 stars, if the Sicilian had not been such a disappointment. Looking forward to ordering from them again and trying other menu options.
Food is outstanding and the owner is so nice!!! He was so kind to tell us the history of his family and journey of creating his menu. And lemme tell y'all the food is outstanding every time I get something it's like a little piece of heaven. After I had the creme brulee I kept craving it and bought two in one day afterwards. With all the pizza I've throughout my travels and in Petaluma Mad Sicilian is absolutely the best I've had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Catalina B.
very pricey pizza, not as great as yelpers say. This place is also hard to find unless you know Petaluma super good Was told they are not "allowed" to do white sauce on pizza - WHAT?!
SnmaGal
Fantastic pizza! Very fresh ingredients with more than ample amount on each pizza. Just a little place with a few tables. Great people run this very authentic pizza place. This is our place to go for pizza in Petaluma.
Tammy Dailey
The Palermo was the best Pizza that we've ever had! Crispy light crust with No grease. Plenty of delicious toppings loved the ratio of meat with vegetables! Too many places skimp on the bellpeppers and mushrooms but I had some in Every Bite! The Chef came out of the kitchen to chat and he makes a Killer Creme Brule! Perfect ending to a Fantastic meal!Unfortunately we live in Fresno and they don't deliver here! I've been craving it ever since then! Can't wait for our next trip to Petaluma because I'm bee lining to the MAD SICILIAN! 10 out of 10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Yeas Yeas
The pizza is good. I think the seeds or whatever they place under the deep dish pizza is pointless in my personal opinion, give it a weird texture and adds no flavor. Deserts are great, toppings on pizza are good quality, same with the cheese, the cheese was great. Would say the sauce is okay. Bland besides the seasonings placed on top. Overall would recommend, good prices as well
All great! Last evening it was Sicilian salad with "The Bomb" pizza. I would definitely have it again, but think there will be a new delicious equivalent to order next time we order from The Mad Sicilian!
We shopped hungry, but we'll have amazing lunches this week! I had the Sicilian with pancetta and my wife had the Green Door! Absolutely fresh and delicious!
It was my niece's birthday today and we stopped by Starbucks next door to grab a hot drink. The owner of the Mad Sicilian approached us while we were parking with a big smile. He told us that they were testing out their Pizza of the Month and invited us inside to try it. We happily obliged! And wow, it was D-Licious! The crust was crunchy and chewy at the same time and the pizza sauce was perfect. You could tell all the ingredients were of real high quality. They couldn't have been more friendly and I'll happily come back to try their other offerings, including yummy pasta! Thanks again Mad Sicilian- what a treat!
After Little Star, I never thought I'd fall in love with another deep dish pizza place, until Mad Sicilian. We've been getting deep dish from Mad Sicilian for a couple of years now. And it is for sure one of, if not, the best deep dish pizza in the Bay Area. Yes, better than Zachary's. For sure better than Patxi's. And sadly, as of late, better than Little Star. (Only because the last couple of times I went there, the quality seemed to have slipped). What makes it so good? The mountains of cheese stuffed inside this pizza. You can't tell right away because of the beautiful sauce on top. But it is loaded. And of course, the crust. Flavorful, slightly dusted with corn meal and brushed with an herb topping. It is sooo good. How much do we like it? We ordered Mad Sicilian for our wedding rehearsal dinner. You can tell that the owners love pizza, and they love THEIR pizza. They seem like the type of people who would never trade on quality. My wish is that they open a bigger location where there are more than 2 tables so that we can eat in more often. Being in Novato, the traffic deters us from going there to pick up a pizza and bring it back. But if there is a bigger location, we'd be okay with fighting traffic to eat in. Besides the deep dish, we've also had the sicilian which is also delicious with their herb coating all over the crust. Really yummy. And their service is also always excellent. Once the pizza was taking longer than expected, and they gave us some free dessert. You can just tell the owners want to take care of their customers and give them the best they can give you. I super appreciate that as well. Anyhow, if you like deep dish, give them a try! We've heard their regular pizzas are delicious too - but how do we not get the deep dish?!
Just happened to walk by and the delicious enticing aroma caught my nose and we had to stop in for a taste. Found two lovely women, one a fellow Michigander, very pleasant and helpful with the menu. The pizza was very delicious and flavorful., the aroma didn't lie! The garlic breadsticks were especially yummy and the newly made pesto dip topped it off wonderfully. The owner had us try a new menu item, the flavor of the month pizza, I will be back to get another one. Very good!!! Stop in for a sniff of the delicious aromas and stay for a bite, you won't be disappointed!
Solid pizza. Killer service and bomb pizza. Go Chicago.
So delicious!
I was so excited to try Mad Sicilian so I put it on the list for my wife's birthday pizza crawl. This was our second stop and we came to celebrate our shared Chicago heritage with their stuffed pizza. We opted for a large with spinach, mushrooms and artichoke hearts.new settled in and waited for our pie. After about half an hour it was time. The pizza was beautiful with tasty sauce and gooey cheese. Unfortunately the vegetable fillings were scant and the whole thing needed another 5-10 minutes in the oven as the center was only warm and the bottom was soggy (Paul Hollywood would not have been pleased). They also only have bottled drinks, no cups or glasses. Staff were friendly and attentive. They have the basic Chicago style concept down, it just needs a little fine tuning.
Good pizza and really good menu with lots of options for everyone. They rotate a few creative recipes for anyone who is looking for something fun and different. Recommend ordering to go verses delivery. Crust just isn't quite right when it sits.
We've ordered for delivery twice now. The Sicilian pizza crust was bland and chewy. They screwed up our order but even the correct toppings would not have saved it. Skip the Sicilian style pies. The Mad pizzas are among the best we've had in town. High quality ingredients and a flavorful chewy crust. Recommend! I would not normally yelp about a salad from a pizza joint, but the Greek Salad is exceptional. The feta they use is creamy and salty and the Kalamata olives were plump. The dressing is pink colored (red wing vinegar?), loaded with herbs, and super tangy. Also highly recommended. Would have been an easy 4 stars, if the Sicilian had not been such a disappointment. Looking forward to ordering from them again and trying other menu options.
Restaurantji Recommends
Food is outstanding and the owner is so nice!!! He was so kind to tell us the history of his family and journey of creating his menu. And lemme tell y'all the food is outstanding every time I get something it's like a little piece of heaven. After I had the creme brulee I kept craving it and bought two in one day afterwards. With all the pizza I've throughout my travels and in Petaluma Mad Sicilian is absolutely the best I've had.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
very pricey pizza, not as great as yelpers say. This place is also hard to find unless you know Petaluma super good Was told they are not "allowed" to do white sauce on pizza - WHAT?!
Fantastic pizza! Very fresh ingredients with more than ample amount on each pizza. Just a little place with a few tables. Great people run this very authentic pizza place. This is our place to go for pizza in Petaluma.
The Palermo was the best Pizza that we've ever had! Crispy light crust with No grease. Plenty of delicious toppings loved the ratio of meat with vegetables! Too many places skimp on the bellpeppers and mushrooms but I had some in Every Bite! The Chef came out of the kitchen to chat and he makes a Killer Creme Brule! Perfect ending to a Fantastic meal!Unfortunately we live in Fresno and they don't deliver here! I've been craving it ever since then! Can't wait for our next trip to Petaluma because I'm bee lining to the MAD SICILIAN! 10 out of 10!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is good. I think the seeds or whatever they place under the deep dish pizza is pointless in my personal opinion, give it a weird texture and adds no flavor. Deserts are great, toppings on pizza are good quality, same with the cheese, the cheese was great. Would say the sauce is okay. Bland besides the seasonings placed on top. Overall would recommend, good prices as well
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5