Cowboy Cookie & Ice Cream
174 Pomeroy Ave, Pismo Beach
(805) 295-6467
Recent Reviews
Sort by
174 Pomeroy Ave, Pismo Beach
(805) 295-6467
Ice cream is great. Cookies....not so much. Not sure how fresh they are. The girl had to put the cookie cup into the microwave and to be honest, it was still very hard. They just didn't seem fresh. The ones on the tray in the case looked worse. Bummer.
The ice cream was decent. Not the best I've ever ate.
Bro they have some decent creamy treats in cookie bowls. Frickin try it.
Amazing customer service. They stayed open just a few minutes longer for us and packed the cups full of delicious ice cream. Made for a very enjoyable stroll on the Pismo pier after and a perfect end of the evening.
Will definitely be back!!
We tried two different cookies, over a dollar a piece. They weren't terrible, buy they were kinda small and unmemorable. For a place that primarily sells cookies, these were kind of a let down.
The staff members were friendly but I found the ice cream disappointing. The banana ice cream flavor tasted artificial and the toffee ice cream didn’t really taste like anything. The cookie I had was pretty good but not remarkable. I also tasted the rocky road ice cream which was icy. I ordered a half cookie sandwich and it was huge, way bigger than the picture. It was enough for 2 people. The concept is interesting but it seems like it needs a little more attention to quality.
Just stopped in to grab a couple of cookies. The place was packed and the desserts were delicious!!
Excellent ice cream and recommended the cookies and cream. The cookies are a little tough so make sure it gets soaked by the ice cream.
If you love cookies and ice cream, I definitely recommend this spot. If you are down at the pier in pismo, it is a must try. Love love, love it!
Sucks they didn't have pistachio but rocky-road was awesome sauce!!
Restaurantji Recommends
Dessert coma!! That’s fr what be happening it’s so good!! I love the cookie bowl with cookie dough ice cream
Such an interesting idea! Cookie bowl?
Fresh cookies in house made ice cream made an amazing treat
Nice, unique dessert place. How can you top extra creamy ice cream in a bowl made of freshly baked chocolate chip cookie? 🍪
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cookie Cup
The cookies are really fresh and chocolate chip cookie was fabulous. The ice creams here are home made and the flavors are really good. The coffee flavor is super good. Moose tracks flavor is also really good.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...