Definitely not the same pizza ? since the change in ownership! It’s unfortunate because we were fans for nearly 20 years!
Food: 1
Kathy Tee
The pasta combo came with a large garlic bread and dinner salad for $15! Pretty good amount of food! The meat sauce was delicious! So good with the garlic bread!
The garlic bread had a crispy crust and soft bread! Every bite was soo good!
Jersey’s pizza was yummy and fluffy! I like it when there is a crisp in the crust and the dough is soft! Very fresh out of the oven!
The guy at the bar as really nice! He’s so friendly and upbeat! Really good service and helpful!
The ambiance is very relaxing! We sat st the bar and I love that there’s a raised step for our feet!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza
Jordan Hou
Waited 2.5 hrs for 1 pizza and caprese bread. Ordered before it was busy as well. Dont know if it was just negligence from the staff or if they simply forgot my order existed. After getting my order it was borderline inedible for my little cousins as it was all burnt in a bad way.
Jade O'Dell
The bar itself is quite nice, a gorgeous piece of Redlands history, and the staff were very nice. We ordered our pizza and waited an hour for all of them to come out while other customers came in, ordered, ate, and left before we got our food. It isn’t the biggest deal, sometimes things happen, but what struck us was how we had two separate staff members come up to our and ask if we were still waiting for our food (we were), and I had to go up and ask twice as well. The first staff member to talk to us (the owner or manager?) sat down at the bar with the other customers and were loudly talking and swearing while we were waiting. I truly don’t mind if there’s a mixup or a rush, I’ve worked in kitchens before and I get it, but sitting at your own bar hanging out with the guys shouldn’t take priority over making sure all your customers have actually gotten their food.
When the pizzas did come they were nice!
Dietary restrictions: They were super knowledgeable when I asked about a nut allergy and made me feel very reassured about safety.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza
John Swift
Absolutely some of the best pizza in the area! Quaint and cozy spot in downtown Redlands.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza
Eric Lopez
This pizza is always good. The people are patient and are willing to customize for you. Thanks jerseys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza
Kimberly Koonce
The best pizza around
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nick Gauthier
Ordered delivery through door dash. Delivery driver has been waiting on them for a half hour past the pickup time. Not sure of the pizza cuz it’s not here. Taking a very long time.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Paul Galindo
The BEST damn pizza in the world. Nothing comes close. Been coming to Jerseys since the doors opened. UPDATE 06/26/24 - New ownership but the have carried on the traditional Jerseys way...OUTSTANDING...
Parking: Of street and parking lot is busy, there is a parking structure just east of Jerseys
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread, Jerseys Special Pizza, Marinara Sauce
Edwin Lorenzo
I guess Jerseys has new owners. The pizza is still the same which I love, maybe a little thinner than the original. Calzones are a no cost almost as much as a pizza and they're underdone with almost no toppings not what we remembered them to be. And also the hours are terrible.
This is my first time going since the new owner, Chris, took over and wow! The place looks great, definitely an upgraded look but kept the local teams on the walls. The food was great and he was awesome to talk to! I had the Jersey special and he definitely tweaked the recipes for the better. The pizza was great and I’m excited to go back to try the other pizzas!
Also, the leftovers are even better the next day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Peppers
Tracy Yniguez
This was my very first time coming here and I am from out of town so I was very open minded coming here because sometimes small business like this are very hot or miss and I can tell you from my point of view the food was EXTREMELY GOOD. I did have some problems with the service taking longer then most people would like; I was actually very close to getting up and asking how much longer, but then my order of cheese bread with marinara sauce came to the table and shortly after my pizza. The ingredients used on the pizza was clearly fresh adding a nice touch to a traditional Italian pizza place so it was enjoyable to eat. The one other problem I had was it was very clear from my stand point that as a new unfamiliar face I was not treated as friendly as there other guest. There were multiple workers going out of there way to talk amongst people how there week had been going and catching up on general things and I was only approached to receive my food and that was it. Another thing to keep in mind is I would more define the atmosphere as an Italian sports bar and grill. There is a lot of sports memorabilia and flat screens around and half of the place is a bar so I wouldn't consider it necessarily family friendly but there wouldn't be anything wrong about bringing your child here either if you didn't mind that. All together is actually rate this place a 3.5
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread
Jadon
BEWARE THE WATER! Literally the worst water ive ever had in my life it was just a cup of mystery chemicals. Food was good tho.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
BsForReels
Loved this place for years and years Dave was the Man always a 5 out of 5. These new owners are smart to keep the recipe the same. But these hours come on you are open 22hrs a week now.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Tania Orozco
Love the Crust on this pizza and how cheesy it is, But the flavor was a bit blend…Still really good Though I would come again. The marinara sauce that came with the cheese bread…OH MY it was one of the best Ive had. That marinara sauce is definitely tasty and most likely homemade
Definitely not the same pizza ? since the change in ownership! It’s unfortunate because we were fans for nearly 20 years!
Food: 1
The pasta combo came with a large garlic bread and dinner salad for $15! Pretty good amount of food! The meat sauce was delicious! So good with the garlic bread!
The garlic bread had a crispy crust and soft bread! Every bite was soo good!
Jersey’s pizza was yummy and fluffy! I like it when there is a crisp in the crust and the dough is soft! Very fresh out of the oven!
The guy at the bar as really nice! He’s so friendly and upbeat! Really good service and helpful!
The ambiance is very relaxing! We sat st the bar and I love that there’s a raised step for our feet!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza
Waited 2.5 hrs for 1 pizza and caprese bread. Ordered before it was busy as well.
Dont know if it was just negligence from the staff or if they simply forgot my order existed. After getting my order it was borderline inedible for my little cousins as it was all burnt in a bad way.
The bar itself is quite nice, a gorgeous piece of Redlands history, and the staff were very nice. We ordered our pizza and waited an hour for all of them to come out while other customers came in, ordered, ate, and left before we got our food. It isn’t the biggest deal, sometimes things happen, but what struck us was how we had two separate staff members come up to our and ask if we were still waiting for our food (we were), and I had to go up and ask twice as well. The first staff member to talk to us (the owner or manager?) sat down at the bar with the other customers and were loudly talking and swearing while we were waiting. I truly don’t mind if there’s a mixup or a rush, I’ve worked in kitchens before and I get it, but sitting at your own bar hanging out with the guys shouldn’t take priority over making sure all your customers have actually gotten their food.
When the pizzas did come they were nice!
Dietary restrictions: They were super knowledgeable when I asked about a nut allergy and made me feel very reassured about safety.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza
Absolutely some of the best pizza in the area! Quaint and cozy spot in downtown Redlands.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza
This pizza is always good. The people are patient and are willing to customize for you. Thanks jerseys!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Jersey Pizza
The best pizza around
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Ordered delivery through door dash. Delivery driver has been waiting on them for a half hour past the pickup time. Not sure of the pizza cuz it’s not here. Taking a very long time.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
The BEST damn pizza in the world. Nothing comes close. Been coming to Jerseys since the doors opened.
UPDATE 06/26/24 - New ownership but the have carried on the traditional Jerseys way...OUTSTANDING...
Parking: Of street and parking lot is busy, there is a parking structure just east of Jerseys
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread, Jerseys Special Pizza, Marinara Sauce
I guess Jerseys has new owners. The pizza is still the same which I love, maybe a little thinner than the original. Calzones are a no cost almost as much as a pizza and they're underdone with almost no toppings not what we remembered them to be. And also the hours are terrible.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
This is my first time going since the new owner, Chris, took over and wow! The place looks great, definitely an upgraded look but kept the local teams on the walls. The food was great and he was awesome to talk to! I had the Jersey special and he definitely tweaked the recipes for the better. The pizza was great and I’m excited to go back to try the other pizzas!
Also, the leftovers are even better the next day!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Peppers
This was my very first time coming here and I am from out of town so I was very open minded coming here because sometimes small business like this are very hot or miss and I can tell you from my point of view the food was EXTREMELY GOOD. I did have some problems with the service taking longer then most people would like; I was actually very close to getting up and asking how much longer, but then my order of cheese bread with marinara sauce came to the table and shortly after my pizza. The ingredients used on the pizza was clearly fresh adding a nice touch to a traditional Italian pizza place so it was enjoyable to eat. The one other problem I had was it was very clear from my stand point that as a new unfamiliar face I was not treated as friendly as there other guest. There were multiple workers going out of there way to talk amongst people how there week had been going and catching up on general things and I was only approached to receive my food and that was it. Another thing to keep in mind is I would more define the atmosphere as an Italian sports bar and grill. There is a lot of sports memorabilia and flat screens around and half of the place is a bar so I wouldn't consider it necessarily family friendly but there wouldn't be anything wrong about bringing your child here either if you didn't mind that. All together is actually rate this place a 3.5
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread
BEWARE THE WATER! Literally the worst water ive ever had in my life it was just a cup of mystery chemicals. Food was good tho.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 4
Loved this place for years and years Dave was the Man always a 5 out of 5. These new owners are smart to keep the recipe the same. But these hours come on you are open 22hrs a week now.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 3
Love the Crust on this pizza and how cheesy it is, But the flavor was a bit blend…Still really good Though I would come again. The marinara sauce that came with the cheese bread…OH MY it was one of the best Ive had. That marinara sauce is definitely tasty and most likely homemade
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 4
Service: 5
Loading...