The family that owns this restaurant are wonderful! The food is delicious. I love the calzones. They have many toppings for calzones, including but not limited to green olives, sun dried tomatoes, cashews, black olives, garlic, etc. They are amenable to special requests (I don't like marinara on the side or inside my calzone). They give me multiple containers of ranch. The onion rings are so good! Mozzarella sticks not as good. The manicotti is also good. I would recommend paying in cash vs. card. If you pay with card, they mark up 3 or 4 percent. I just try to always remember cash.Vegetarian options: You can choose your own pizza/calzone toppings. They have regular toppings and upgraded ones (green olives, sun dried tomatoes, cashews) that cost an additional fee.Dietary restrictions: I prefer no marinara and they always honor this request.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
jr guzman
Good food it's amazing food underrated.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, New Yorker
Saul Amaral
First time eating pizza ? at the Redlands New York pizzeria I love the pizza at two other locations by that name, I enjoyed the Meat lovers pizza it was delicious a good crispy crust, delectable meats, sweet savory sauce and good cheese I hope to visit again. My mother enjoyed the antipasto salad and Italian dressing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Meatballs, Potato Wedges, Marinara Sauce, Spaghetti and Meatballs with a Sausage Side, Mozzarella Sticks 8 with Marinara, New Yorker
Eddie Garcia
I ordered a New York style large size on their menu it says $21.99 and it was sold to me for 23.99 as you can see the receipt and he told me there was ham in there pizza there wasn’t any ham in it he lied to me .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Keith K.
Their pizza is fine but I like my pizza crust a little thicker. Hadn't been there in a while. The last time we were there, the Family Meal was $39.99 for 2 lg pizzas, a salad, and a liter of soda. Now, $34.99, you only get one pizza, potatoes, salad, and soda. The new total was $62.00 to add another pizza. A little expensive for what you get but so is everything these days.
Diane M.
Pepperoni pizza was delicious Mozzarella sticks were ok and the salad had too much mushroom not enough lettuce Service was fast! I wish they had music playing or something it was way too quiet but besides that this place is worth a try!! PS we just placed our mozz sticks next to the pizza
Lisa B.
Quiet spot with really good pizza. They have a lunch special with pizza and either a salad or drink for $7.99. Totally worth it.
Magali M.
I could've bought a frozen pizza!!! I order 3 toppings and barely got the 3rd one I counted two. Very dead inside. Don't get me wrong the flavor wasn't bad but it was just equivalent of School pizza. The guy behind the counter was nice. I don't like eating off a Styrofoam because the heat singes the plate. But that's what they serve you on Styrofoam plates. I think if you were broke and you need some thing this is the place but this is not the place you would go to for New York pizzeria or for any gourmet pizza. This is just not it. I think I would've been better off with a hot and ready.
Jeff J.
We ordered pizza from here that we go and pick up. It's only a couple of Blocks from my house. It's my opinion that this is the best Pizza in Redlands. that is, for mainstream pizza.
Wade Terwilliger
Like it’s aight, the wait was 15-20 minutes the food was hot and fresh, overall the chicken parm like a 6.5
Horrible meatball sandwich spit it oit and salad was just ok just threw $25.00’ away never
Food: 1
Kevin Huynh
Great service and great price! It’s a family owned shop with some great pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Crystalina Prado
Deliciousness!! We went on a Saturday night amazing family outing. My children are picky eaters and we had no issues. Very hospitable atmosphere. Pizza was by far the best we have had. Amazing small business. Definitely coming back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mei Cai
Great mom and pop shop with some solid pizza and good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Sydney Flood
For 30+ years, delicious pizza. My favorite. My only choice.
The family that owns this restaurant are wonderful! The food is delicious. I love the calzones. They have many toppings for calzones, including but not limited to green olives, sun dried tomatoes, cashews, black olives, garlic, etc. They are amenable to special requests (I don't like marinara on the side or inside my calzone). They give me multiple containers of ranch. The onion rings are so good! Mozzarella sticks not as good. The manicotti is also good. I would recommend paying in cash vs. card. If you pay with card, they mark up 3 or 4 percent. I just try to always remember cash.Vegetarian options: You can choose your own pizza/calzone toppings. They have regular toppings and upgraded ones (green olives, sun dried tomatoes, cashews) that cost an additional fee.Dietary restrictions: I prefer no marinara and they always honor this request.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Good food it's amazing food underrated.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, New Yorker
First time eating pizza ? at the Redlands New York pizzeria I love the pizza at two other locations by that name, I enjoyed the Meat lovers pizza it was delicious a good crispy crust, delectable meats, sweet savory sauce and good cheese I hope to visit again. My mother enjoyed the antipasto salad and Italian dressing.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza, Meatballs, Potato Wedges, Marinara Sauce, Spaghetti and Meatballs with a Sausage Side, Mozzarella Sticks 8 with Marinara, New Yorker
I ordered a New York style large size on their menu it says $21.99 and it was sold to me for 23.99 as you can see the receipt and he told me there was ham in there pizza there wasn’t any ham in it he lied to me .
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Their pizza is fine but I like my pizza crust a little thicker. Hadn't been there in a while. The last time we were there, the Family Meal was $39.99 for 2 lg pizzas, a salad, and a liter of soda. Now, $34.99, you only get one pizza, potatoes, salad, and soda. The new total was $62.00 to add another pizza. A little expensive for what you get but so is everything these days.
Pepperoni pizza was delicious Mozzarella sticks were ok and the salad had too much mushroom not enough lettuce Service was fast! I wish they had music playing or something it was way too quiet but besides that this place is worth a try!! PS we just placed our mozz sticks next to the pizza
Quiet spot with really good pizza. They have a lunch special with pizza and either a salad or drink for $7.99. Totally worth it.
I could've bought a frozen pizza!!! I order 3 toppings and barely got the 3rd one I counted two. Very dead inside. Don't get me wrong the flavor wasn't bad but it was just equivalent of School pizza. The guy behind the counter was nice. I don't like eating off a Styrofoam because the heat singes the plate. But that's what they serve you on Styrofoam plates. I think if you were broke and you need some thing this is the place but this is not the place you would go to for New York pizzeria or for any gourmet pizza. This is just not it. I think I would've been better off with a hot and ready.
We ordered pizza from here that we go and pick up. It's only a couple of Blocks from my house. It's my opinion that this is the best Pizza in Redlands. that is, for mainstream pizza.
Like it’s aight, the wait was 15-20 minutes the food was hot and fresh, overall the chicken parm like a 6.5
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 4
Restaurantji Recommends
Horrible meatball sandwich spit it oit and salad was just ok just threw $25.00’ away never
Food: 1
Great service and great price! It’s a family owned shop with some great pizza!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Deliciousness!! We went on a Saturday night amazing family outing. My children are picky eaters and we had no issues. Very hospitable atmosphere. Pizza was by far the best we have had. Amazing small business. Definitely coming back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Great mom and pop shop with some solid pizza and good
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
For 30+ years, delicious pizza. My favorite. My only choice.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza