They have great pizza. This one of the few places that have cashews on any pie Mmm cashews.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mini Cannoli, Pepperoni Pizza
jimmy robinson
Wish there where negative stars. Ordered pizza. Ordered soda. Soda didn't come with pizza calked they sent soda finally. I ordered pizza with no onions and it was covered in onions. Called to get a refund for pizza instead gave me s free pizza on next order. I'm never going there again quality has really become bad pasy few.months. go to viano's it's way better.
Danny H.
Moved in to the area and we love their pizza, the service is great the only thing is I wish it wasn't so expensive. 4 stars for how pricey it is, other than that it's a 5 star.
Greg Spicer
We're new to the area and randomly tried this place for pizza. We immediately found it will be a go-to staple for us. You definitely should try the western bacon cheeseburger pizza if you're open to trying a non-traditional pizza flavor. So good!I didn’t rate service and atmosphere here simply because I didn’t dine-in and had someone else pick up the order. They mentioned only positives and no complaints though.
Food: 5
Greg S.
We're new to the area and randomly tried this place for pizza. We immediately found it will be a go-to staple for us. You definitely should try the western bacon cheeseburger pizza if you're open to trying a non-traditional pizza flavor. So good!
Michael Giove
Just moved to Orangecrest in Riverside from NYC, and this is the best New York style pizza i’ve had in the area so far. Place is small, but the food is legit.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robin W.
Way too expensive for what you get. Mostly crust and sauce with a smattering of toppings. Won't bother again. When they first opened in Woodcrest they were good, but cost has stayed the same and they are cutting back on toppings. I don't pay $50+ for two pizzas of crust and a bland sauce.Service is okay. last two times I've been there it seems there is more conversation in the kitchen than cooking.Ambiance--there isn't any.
Melissa L.
Kiddos and adults love this pizza. easy to order and not heavy on the fennel in the marinara so it's palatable by all. Good deals online, too.Only complaint - parking lot is always full and hard to stop in and pick up
Rosa b
Food is really delicious, yes, it's a bit pricey but it is worth it ? Great customer service and friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread
Josephin Garcia
Love the pizza from here! Very fresh and love how good the crust is! It’s hard to find very good crust and here it is just chefs kiss! Dematteos supreme is the best? and also the staff are very nice! Pizza comes out fast and hot!
We’ve been looking for the best pizza in Riverside, and we believe we found it!Fresh ingredients and fresh dough, Dematteo’s was absolutely delicious! We can’t wait to go back!
T M
Topping choices are great, but crust thin or regular is just ok.I have only tried the pizza. They serve lots of other things besides pizza.
Monica B.
Legit very happy to have found this place. My sister went to high school with the owner and always wanted to try the spot before she moved out of state. So we gave it a shot and I can say that I am definitely making this spot my regular pizza spot
Charlianne Yeyna
Supporting a family owned business is 100% worth the price. Best pizza in riverside and the owners are very sweet. Very accommodating and amazing food. 11/10.
Karen S.
We spent $75 on 4 pizzas. I love a good thin crust, crisp, flaky and flavorful. This thin crust was horrible! It was like eating pizza toppings on part of the box. It was dry , tough, and flavorless.UPDATE: After leaving this review Bob emailed me with his phone number to remedy the situation. He offered to remake the pizzas using their regular dough, made thin, rather than the purchased pre-made thin crusts that we got last night. The resulting pizzas were 100% better. Thin crust with a slight raised, nicely browned edge. It was great! We did end up picking it up from their other location on Magnolia at Arlington (because it's closer to the house). The only reason we ordered from the Van Buren location is because we had errands in that area.
They have great pizza. This one of the few places that have cashews on any pie Mmm cashews.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Mini Cannoli, Pepperoni Pizza
Wish there where negative stars. Ordered pizza. Ordered soda. Soda didn't come with pizza calked they sent soda finally. I ordered pizza with no onions and it was covered in onions. Called to get a refund for pizza instead gave me s free pizza on next order. I'm never going there again quality has really become bad pasy few.months. go to viano's it's way better.
Moved in to the area and we love their pizza, the service is great the only thing is I wish it wasn't so expensive. 4 stars for how pricey it is, other than that it's a 5 star.
We're new to the area and randomly tried this place for pizza. We immediately found it will be a go-to staple for us. You definitely should try the western bacon cheeseburger pizza if you're open to trying a non-traditional pizza flavor. So good!I didn’t rate service and atmosphere here simply because I didn’t dine-in and had someone else pick up the order. They mentioned only positives and no complaints though.
Food: 5
We're new to the area and randomly tried this place for pizza. We immediately found it will be a go-to staple for us. You definitely should try the western bacon cheeseburger pizza if you're open to trying a non-traditional pizza flavor. So good!
Just moved to Orangecrest in Riverside from NYC, and this is the best New York style pizza i’ve had in the area so far. Place is small, but the food is legit.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 5
Service: 5
Way too expensive for what you get. Mostly crust and sauce with a smattering of toppings. Won't bother again. When they first opened in Woodcrest they were good, but cost has stayed the same and they are cutting back on toppings. I don't pay $50+ for two pizzas of crust and a bland sauce.Service is okay. last two times I've been there it seems there is more conversation in the kitchen than cooking.Ambiance--there isn't any.
Kiddos and adults love this pizza. easy to order and not heavy on the fennel in the marinara so it's palatable by all. Good deals online, too.Only complaint - parking lot is always full and hard to stop in and pick up
Food is really delicious, yes, it's a bit pricey but it is worth it ? Great customer service and friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Bread
Love the pizza from here! Very fresh and love how good the crust is! It’s hard to find very good crust and here it is just chefs kiss! Dematteos supreme is the best? and also the staff are very nice! Pizza comes out fast and hot!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Meat Deluxe
Restaurantji Recommends
We’ve been looking for the best pizza in Riverside, and we believe we found it!Fresh ingredients and fresh dough, Dematteo’s was absolutely delicious! We can’t wait to go back!
Topping choices are great, but crust thin or regular is just ok.I have only tried the pizza. They serve lots of other things besides pizza.
Legit very happy to have found this place. My sister went to high school with the owner and always wanted to try the spot before she moved out of state. So we gave it a shot and I can say that I am definitely making this spot my regular pizza spot
Supporting a family owned business is 100% worth the price. Best pizza in riverside and the owners are very sweet. Very accommodating and amazing food. 11/10.
We spent $75 on 4 pizzas. I love a good thin crust, crisp, flaky and flavorful. This thin crust was horrible! It was like eating pizza toppings on part of the box. It was dry , tough, and flavorless.UPDATE: After leaving this review Bob emailed me with his phone number to remedy the situation. He offered to remake the pizzas using their regular dough, made thin, rather than the purchased pre-made thin crusts that we got last night. The resulting pizzas were 100% better. Thin crust with a slight raised, nicely browned edge. It was great! We did end up picking it up from their other location on Magnolia at Arlington (because it's closer to the house). The only reason we ordered from the Van Buren location is because we had errands in that area.