Sugar Mamas' Bakeshop and Cafe

I have only had the Italian Stallion but it was probably the best sandwich I have ever eaten.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Pastry’s were good but the cashier was on her phone when i was getting my money. I handed it to her and she was STILL on her phone and didnt noticed for a minute that i had my cash. I think she could’ve waited till after the customer had left to get on her phone not while she was waiting for me to get my cash out.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 4

Service: 1

Had to wait close to an hour, then they did not give us utensils

Under staffed. Only one employee trying best to keep up.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

The bakery was great to work with on some large orders we had to make for a company retreat. Great pastries, great coffee, would visit again!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent sandwich, Talk to Me Spicy, and the mac-n-cheese.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

My heart sank this morning. I stopped in before work, not in a rush, but my order still took about 15 minutes—which would have been fine if not for watching another customer who ordered after me get his food and drink first.😔

I ordered a breakfast (~$10) and added a chai latte that brought my total to $16. For that price, I expected something crafted in-house or at least a higher-quality drink. Instead, I was handed a 3/4 full cup of pre-made TAZO chai. 🫤Since they didn’t have ice, the drink felt… almost empty.

I don’t mind paying $6+ for a latte when it’s worth it, but this was sad. Maybe just stick to baked goods…

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 2

Service: 4

Really slow service even if no one’s there and the lunch menu isn’t very good; mainly just overpriced sandwiches you can make at home.
But coffee and breakfast menu are really good!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 3

Service: 3

“The cinnamon roll rivals Cinnabon”and “keep baking the Parmesan bagels”!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great little place, good food. Bathrooms are fairly hard to find.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food!

I looked at the mixed reviews before our road trip to Cedaredge to visit this coffee shop and decided to give it a chance. The picture shows our lunch which also included a small lemonade that was basically out of a jug from city market. This was $48. My chicken salad sandwich was basically half a sandwich and the bread was so dry it crumbled with every bite so I gave up and ate the chicken with a fork. We really wanted to like this place because we enjoy visiting the area but unfortunately we won't be back.

This place is AMAZING!

Staff was nice, coffee was like water with some flavoring, will not go here again for coffee. Horrible.

My husband and I have been to Sugar Mamas’ multiple times over the years they’ve been in business at the Apple Shed. Several times I’ve wanted to write an honest review, but haven’t because I want to support our local businesses.
This morning I stopped by to pick up two pastries, a Nutella croissant and a Blueberry turnover. The chocolate was bone dry (see picture). Hardly any Nutella to be seen and it cost over $4. This isn’t the first time one of their Nutella or chocolate pastries has been like this, but every 6-12 months I try them again because they’re my favorite. The blueberry turnover was soggy and not very good, but at least it had filling. It’s so disappointing because we got some pastries from here on Mothers Day and they were delicious, so I know they can make good pastries. I also don’t love that they charge full price for dry, two day old products. Give a little discount if they’re not fresh.
Anyway, this is my honest review from a long time customer. I hope some improvements can be made because I want to keep coming here.