Big Bill's New York Pizza

The food here is sooooo good!!!! Atmosphere and service are both 10 out of 10! We went with friends and can't wait to go back.

You cannot get ahold of anybody on the phone. Place needs to modernize and figure out how to take more order over the phone or incorporate o line ordering.

We love it here! Best pizza around!

Friendly staff, great food, truly reminds me of growing up in NY/NJ. Highly recommend to anyone looking for some classic food, it's like being with grandma.

Big Bill’s was busy on Friday night! The food was definitely worth the wait. Everything we had was really good and the service was exceptional! Will be back next time I am in CO!

I ordered the Combo Pie and it was delicious. It was ready in 18 minutes. The crust was not too thin as I would have expected with a New York style pizza. The crust thickness was perfect. I definitely recommend.

Great pizza, I especially love the sausage that they use. Calzones and lasagna are really great as well. The quality is consistent which speaks of professionalism and pride that they take in their pies.

Idk why so many people mention that they're from NY when reviewing this place. Anyone not from NY who has visited there knows that their pizza is exactly what you'd expect: cheap and with ingredients made for a big population such as that one, with the price to match for a reason. There are a few gems actually worth visiting there, just like in Denver and anywhere else 😂

Big Bill's is one of the gems around Denver, and don't let the pretentious wannabe's persuade you otherwise! Try it!

I've written here before. This pizza is great! The staff is great! Get a calzone or pizza Teagan Style (bacon, peperioni, salami, sausage) best combo ever!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Been going to Big Bills for over 15 years. I started coming here as a kid when visiting grandparents in town and now come here as I live in town now. I drive 25 minutes just to dine in or get carry out. Their meatball shells are phenomenal!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: NY Pizza

We stopped here on the way down from a long ski day. So pleasantly surprised by the excellent atmosphere, family vibes, and delicious pizza. Definitely recommend! Cozy for

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots, NY Pizza

Guy working the pickup counter was nice enough.
I phoned in and requested well done; they missed the memo on this completely - see pics (adjusted service score to reflect this).
NY-style pizza was underdone and SUPER GREASY.
Sicilian slice was solid, and had a good crunch, but was lukewarm. It was clear that that they had this premade and just threw the toppings on without running it through the oven again.
A little spendy for a spot that has the conveyor-belt style ovens, but the flavors are good. If they had run the NY-style through the oven one more time, it would be a completely different pizza for the better, same goes for the Sicilian slice.

Food: 3

Service: 3

Recommended dishes: NY Pizza

Great. I liked the pizza a lot. The crust is skinny, and there is a good ratio of crust, sauce, and cheese. The chicken wings were perfectly fried, had good flavor, and were meaty.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: NY Pizza

Closest thing to a NY or NJ pie. Everything is really good, can’t beat the service and the nostalgic feel is such a great environment. My buddy from NJ & I come down all the way from Westminster almost every month

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Baked Ziti, Garlic Knots, Wings, NY Pizza, New York Style

Some of the best food in the area. You can't go wrong with anything.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

The center of the pizza was a little undercooked and the crust was lacking in flavor. Pizza was still good overall

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 4

Service: 5