Fantastic food, place and people. Rufus, Peter and Andres are always great!One thing though- Bring back the Spicy Spaghetti to the menu!! It's such a great dish, have it with peppers, onions, Italian sausage and a spicy tomato sauce....it hits the spot like nothing else does!Kid-friendliness: Great family friendly place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Laurie Tecza
Has gone down hill.Last two times food wasn't very good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Sam Beckwith
Great pizza!
Food: 5
Patricia Hernandez
We would highly recommend this pizzeria to any visitor seeking out the best
Food: 5
Amanda Faaborg
Ordered gluten free personal pizza at the counter. Was approached at my table that I needed to pay $ 5.74 more because the employee that placed the order made a mistake and I was not charged for gluten free pizza but rather regular dough.Pizza look beautiful when it arrived at my table but the crust was raw in the very center of the pie and the very outer crust was raw inside. Told the manger. He gave me a buy one pizza get one free coupon. I have little interest in 2 raw gluten free pizzas especially considering what the first one cost.So disappointing…
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad
Caleb Mandry
The person that took my order was friendly and the portions are huge! Pie is delicious !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Mike W.
Pizza was really great and service was friendly. Only (minor) negative was strip mall location but definitely worth a return visit!
Lonnie Chavez
Fun place. Pizza is thin and crispy. Quick service. I just got two slices and a drink, but the pizza was cheesy which is not typical for getting a single slice. Recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Marcie E.
Love this place! It is family friendly, perfect for a cozy night or after a sports game. Locally-owned, Colonna's is a GREAT community supporter! They often have deals, too, like half off pizzas for National Pizza Day. What fun!!! In addition to pizza, they have entrees, sandwiches, beer and wine, and the most delicious gelato.
Izabella Sterling
I got a too good to go order. The lady at the front when I entered was waving people out the door to have a good night so off the bat I knew it would be a nice interaction. I told her what I had and she went and got right in to it. She was an awesome worker didn’t catch her name but super happy to be there. They were cleaning when I came in which shows a nice clean environment. It was a little empty which is weird because it’s so good! Affordable, nice food, and good people definitely coming back:)Parking: Good parking is all
While I've had really good pizza at many places in Denver, Colonna's is the only exceptional place I've eaten at these past 46 years I have lived in Colorado. I have yet to find a better pizza in the metro area. This place, hands down, is quality through and through. The dough.. perfectly doughy and crisp, the sauce tastes like tomato instead of sickeningly sweet, good coverage of toppings and plenty of gooey cheese. The calzones are also the best in the front range.
Andrew Fleck
We wanted a local place for a quick pizza. Theirs was good. Nothing special, but definitely tasty.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Tatum L.
*This was ordered on UberEats through their ghost kitchen concept, Ferrari's Italian Restaurant, so I'm only taking off one star for now to give the restaurant another chance in person to make a better impression.* Ordered the caprese salad, garlic cheese knots, bacio mozzarella sticks, and the penny for penne ala vodka. Caprese: While the tomatoes and basil were fresh and the presentation nice esp. for delivery, quite unfortunately it was clearly not seasoned one bit and that made all the difference. The worst thing for me personally, however, was that either the oil or herbs were very old and tasted seriously off. Still edible but not the fresh caprese I was excited for. Garlic cheese knots: They were a bit too dense but the flavor was yummy! Felt like the dough might've been overworked, but overall not bad. The cheese was pretty chewy on top, so I would just prefer the simpler garlic in the future. The marinara seemed homemade and was absolutely delicious. Honestly, favorite part of the meal. Mozz sticks: Taste was amazing, that they were scratch made was clear, but unfortunately they do not travel well. Noted to try them in-restaurant but maybe not order them again. A tad bit disappointing for $10+ but the marinara absolutely made it less so. Again, their marinara is fantastic. Penne alla vodka: The pasta was a very cheap, low-quality pasta that ruined the experience from the get-go, and the sauce had potential but it seemed the sauce was either cooked off too much or the vodka cooked off too little, couldn't put my finger on it. Unfortunately, it also tasted as if it was sweetened (a decent amount) which was not what I would look for in a savory pasta. Overall: would go back, would most likely not order online again. Excited to try their pizza, and give some of their sides a try but fresher, but not going for the pasta, unfortunately. Definitely wish it was a little less $$ when I ordered as I do feel I wasted a bit of my money.
William M.
My go-to place for NY-style pizza. Delivery service is pretty average in my experience, it's either late or late and cold!!! We are 5 minutes from their ovens and still can't get consistently hot pizza. Still a very good pie...
Fantastic food, place and people. Rufus, Peter and Andres are always great!One thing though- Bring back the Spicy Spaghetti to the menu!! It's such a great dish, have it with peppers, onions, Italian sausage and a spicy tomato sauce....it hits the spot like nothing else does!Kid-friendliness: Great family friendly place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots
Has gone down hill.Last two times food wasn't very good.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Great pizza!
Food: 5
We would highly recommend this pizzeria to any visitor seeking out the best
Food: 5
Ordered gluten free personal pizza at the counter. Was approached at my table that I needed to pay $ 5.74 more because the employee that placed the order made a mistake and I was not charged for gluten free pizza but rather regular dough.Pizza look beautiful when it arrived at my table but the crust was raw in the very center of the pie and the very outer crust was raw inside. Told the manger. He gave me a buy one pizza get one free coupon. I have little interest in 2 raw gluten free pizzas especially considering what the first one cost.So disappointing…
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Greek Salad
The person that took my order was friendly and the portions are huge! Pie is delicious !!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Pizza was really great and service was friendly. Only (minor) negative was strip mall location but definitely worth a return visit!
Fun place. Pizza is thin and crispy. Quick service. I just got two slices and a drink, but the pizza was cheesy which is not typical for getting a single slice. Recommended.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Love this place! It is family friendly, perfect for a cozy night or after a sports game. Locally-owned, Colonna's is a GREAT community supporter! They often have deals, too, like half off pizzas for National Pizza Day. What fun!!! In addition to pizza, they have entrees, sandwiches, beer and wine, and the most delicious gelato.
I got a too good to go order. The lady at the front when I entered was waving people out the door to have a good night so off the bat I knew it would be a nice interaction. I told her what I had and she went and got right in to it. She was an awesome worker didn’t catch her name but super happy to be there. They were cleaning when I came in which shows a nice clean environment. It was a little empty which is weird because it’s so good! Affordable, nice food, and good people definitely coming back:)Parking: Good parking is all
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Great pizza. Always cooked right and tastes good.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
While I've had really good pizza at many places in Denver, Colonna's is the only exceptional place I've eaten at these past 46 years I have lived in Colorado. I have yet to find a better pizza in the metro area. This place, hands down, is quality through and through. The dough.. perfectly doughy and crisp, the sauce tastes like tomato instead of sickeningly sweet, good coverage of toppings and plenty of gooey cheese. The calzones are also the best in the front range.
We wanted a local place for a quick pizza. Theirs was good. Nothing special, but definitely tasty.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
*This was ordered on UberEats through their ghost kitchen concept, Ferrari's Italian Restaurant, so I'm only taking off one star for now to give the restaurant another chance in person to make a better impression.* Ordered the caprese salad, garlic cheese knots, bacio mozzarella sticks, and the penny for penne ala vodka. Caprese: While the tomatoes and basil were fresh and the presentation nice esp. for delivery, quite unfortunately it was clearly not seasoned one bit and that made all the difference. The worst thing for me personally, however, was that either the oil or herbs were very old and tasted seriously off. Still edible but not the fresh caprese I was excited for. Garlic cheese knots: They were a bit too dense but the flavor was yummy! Felt like the dough might've been overworked, but overall not bad. The cheese was pretty chewy on top, so I would just prefer the simpler garlic in the future. The marinara seemed homemade and was absolutely delicious. Honestly, favorite part of the meal. Mozz sticks: Taste was amazing, that they were scratch made was clear, but unfortunately they do not travel well. Noted to try them in-restaurant but maybe not order them again. A tad bit disappointing for $10+ but the marinara absolutely made it less so. Again, their marinara is fantastic. Penne alla vodka: The pasta was a very cheap, low-quality pasta that ruined the experience from the get-go, and the sauce had potential but it seemed the sauce was either cooked off too much or the vodka cooked off too little, couldn't put my finger on it. Unfortunately, it also tasted as if it was sweetened (a decent amount) which was not what I would look for in a savory pasta. Overall: would go back, would most likely not order online again. Excited to try their pizza, and give some of their sides a try but fresher, but not going for the pasta, unfortunately. Definitely wish it was a little less $$ when I ordered as I do feel I wasted a bit of my money.
My go-to place for NY-style pizza. Delivery service is pretty average in my experience, it's either late or late and cold!!! We are 5 minutes from their ovens and still can't get consistently hot pizza. Still a very good pie...