Huge pizza pie. Nom. Not the best pizza by any means, but above average and fast. For Colorado it's pretty good. Nice thin ny style. Waffle fries were excellent. Very good service. Nice atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries
Lora Mae
Pizza is ok.Asked for extra cheese - paid for it - got LESS cheese. ? and over cooked, dry, hard pizza. ?Pizza HAS GONE DOWNHILL! It’s almost cracker thin now and the cheese stops 2 inches before the crust starts. I wouldn’t recommend going here to buy pizza for almost $50. Support local instead.Called the restaurant and spoke to Lo. She is processing our refund
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
Stephanie Sadri
We have two feral children who never agree on where we get pizza but Fat Sullys has become a middle ground.I was super jazzed after a long week of work travel to order from there tonight and we had a slight miss on the final product. But they made it right and I cannot be more grateful. We will continue to support and champion this amazing and tasty local spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
ross fountain
I ordered online and went to pick up my food. I received a text after I ordered saying they would text me when it was ready. I sat in my car waiting.. and waiting and no text. I finally decided to just pull through to the drive through window and see if my food was ready. after I pulled up I made eye contact with three people and watched them walk away without bothering to help me. finally a woman came to the window and sure enough, the order was ready. not very good customer service.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Lance Keller
Had 3 different servers visit my table no refill on the tea. Had to ask for ketchup and mustard. Food was good. The burger was really good. Probably won’t be back to the Lone tree location.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Waffle Fries
Ethan k
Some of the best pizza and burgers I've had. A great place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jake
Excellent hamburger!Waffle fries good but overly salty.Drink was ok.Nice place.Would like to try the pizza next time.Service was good.The salad not so good. Chicken was over cooked. Made my wife sick afterwards. Bummer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Laura Baggett
Great service, great food, great people! Thank ya'll for a wonderful experience on one of your busiest days and times of the week!!
Vinny Carmody
Walked in to a half full restaurant with my wife and 6 year old daughter to enjoy a Fat Sullys pizza. I lived across the street from your Colfax spot for 3 years so I know the quality. Hostess placed us on a waitlist for a table for 3 and then sat the 2 dudes that walked in after us. I asked why and the response was this… “ you’ll need to wait because we’re not able to seat large parties at this time”. When did 3 people… including a 6 year old become a large party? We left and spent our $$ at Spice Brewing Company instead and had a great experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Nick
We usually get a pizza from here. They are amazing but even more amazing is the way the staff goes above and beyond to help out. Thank you all so much.
Delivered by Uber Eats, ordered 20” with pepperoni, olives, green peppers, mushrooms costed $36. It was OK, could’ve had more amount of toppings for the $. Tasted good, will I seek it out again? No. Will I finish the pizza a solid yes, I’m still looking for that killer pizza joint.
Food: 3
A
We ordered the 26" pizza with pepperoni and sausage. What came out was not a pizza. There was hardly any sauce and cheese on the super thin, flat crust that was burnt. Our pizza box was the same thickness as the pizza. The pizza was so dry we used their hot sauces to try to eat it. My daughter liked her chicken sando but the pizza was absolutely terrible. For over $35 for it, definitely don't recommend it unless you like dry burnt flatbread. Service was inattentive for being 1 of 3 tables there.
Pizza wasn't good. It was hard and barely any cheese on it. The garlic knots were burnt. Ceaser salad was weird and tasted like pickles.... We won't order from here again.
Jese S.
Good stuff. I have been to the original location but that was a good 10+ years ago. Shopping in the area and suddenly remembered knowing this location was here. Stopped in the hopes it wasn't too busy on a Friday night. Surprisingly it wasn't. Every other placed we stopped had a very long wait. I wanted the giant pizza..like really badly, but settled on a giant slice with Italian Sausage and a Cesar salad. Quick, it came out so fast. That was a good thing. The slice is really large as was the salad. I love a thin real crust and this fit the bill of giant, floppy have to fold and eat with 2 hands and a side head tilt pizza. The salad is for 1 was pretty damn big. Packed with croutons and big fresh parm pieces. It was a little heavy on the dressing for me, so I know to ask for it a bit lighter next time. It's served family style so the more who order the bigger bowl to share. One salad for 1 is plenty to share between 2 ppl. The staff was attentive and multiple checked on us frequently, but not so much as to be annoying. There are a bunch of board games there you can play if your in the mood to chill and hang. Overall a fun, active place on a Friday night. They even have an open air patio which would be great on warmer winter days and summers.
Sean Fahey
Our waitress was amazing and patient with our large group.Food was delicious, loaded garlic knots with the white cheddar dip is so
Huge pizza pie. Nom. Not the best pizza by any means, but above average and fast. For Colorado it's pretty good. Nice thin ny style. Waffle fries were excellent. Very good service. Nice atmosphere.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Fries
Pizza is ok.Asked for extra cheese - paid for it - got LESS cheese. ? and over cooked, dry, hard pizza. ?Pizza HAS GONE DOWNHILL! It’s almost cracker thin now and the cheese stops 2 inches before the crust starts. I wouldn’t recommend going here to buy pizza for almost $50. Support local instead.Called the restaurant and spoke to Lo. She is processing our refund
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 1
We have two feral children who never agree on where we get pizza but Fat Sullys has become a middle ground.I was super jazzed after a long week of work travel to order from there tonight and we had a slight miss on the final product. But they made it right and I cannot be more grateful. We will continue to support and champion this amazing and tasty local spot.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
I ordered online and went to pick up my food. I received a text after I ordered saying they would text me when it was ready. I sat in my car waiting.. and waiting and no text. I finally decided to just pull through to the drive through window and see if my food was ready. after I pulled up I made eye contact with three people and watched them walk away without bothering to help me. finally a woman came to the window and sure enough, the order was ready. not very good customer service.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 1
Had 3 different servers visit my table no refill on the tea. Had to ask for ketchup and mustard. Food was good. The burger was really good. Probably won’t be back to the Lone tree location.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 4
Service: 1
Recommended dishes: Waffle Fries
Some of the best pizza and burgers I've had. A great place.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Excellent hamburger!Waffle fries good but overly salty.Drink was ok.Nice place.Would like to try the pizza next time.Service was good.The salad not so good. Chicken was over cooked. Made my wife sick afterwards. Bummer.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Great service, great food, great people! Thank ya'll for a wonderful experience on one of your busiest days and times of the week!!
Walked in to a half full restaurant with my wife and 6 year old daughter to enjoy a Fat Sullys pizza. I lived across the street from your Colfax spot for 3 years so I know the quality. Hostess placed us on a waitlist for a table for 3 and then sat the 2 dudes that walked in after us. I asked why and the response was this… “ you’ll need to wait because we’re not able to seat large parties at this time”. When did 3 people… including a 6 year old become a large party? We left and spent our $$ at Spice Brewing Company instead and had a great experience.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
We usually get a pizza from here. They are amazing but even more amazing is the way the staff goes above and beyond to help out. Thank you all so much.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pepperoni Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
Delivered by Uber Eats, ordered 20” with pepperoni, olives, green peppers, mushrooms costed $36. It was OK, could’ve had more amount of toppings for the $. Tasted good, will I seek it out again? No. Will I finish the pizza a solid yes, I’m still looking for that killer pizza joint.
Food: 3
We ordered the 26" pizza with pepperoni and sausage. What came out was not a pizza. There was hardly any sauce and cheese on the super thin, flat crust that was burnt. Our pizza box was the same thickness as the pizza. The pizza was so dry we used their hot sauces to try to eat it. My daughter liked her chicken sando but the pizza was absolutely terrible. For over $35 for it, definitely don't recommend it unless you like dry burnt flatbread. Service was inattentive for being 1 of 3 tables there.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 1
Service: 2
Recommended dishes: Chicken Sando, Pepperoni Pizza
Pizza wasn't good. It was hard and barely any cheese on it. The garlic knots were burnt. Ceaser salad was weird and tasted like pickles.... We won't order from here again.
Good stuff. I have been to the original location but that was a good 10+ years ago. Shopping in the area and suddenly remembered knowing this location was here. Stopped in the hopes it wasn't too busy on a Friday night. Surprisingly it wasn't. Every other placed we stopped had a very long wait. I wanted the giant pizza..like really badly, but settled on a giant slice with Italian Sausage and a Cesar salad. Quick, it came out so fast. That was a good thing. The slice is really large as was the salad. I love a thin real crust and this fit the bill of giant, floppy have to fold and eat with 2 hands and a side head tilt pizza. The salad is for 1 was pretty damn big. Packed with croutons and big fresh parm pieces. It was a little heavy on the dressing for me, so I know to ask for it a bit lighter next time. It's served family style so the more who order the bigger bowl to share. One salad for 1 is plenty to share between 2 ppl. The staff was attentive and multiple checked on us frequently, but not so much as to be annoying. There are a bunch of board games there you can play if your in the mood to chill and hang. Overall a fun, active place on a Friday night. They even have an open air patio which would be great on warmer winter days and summers.
Our waitress was amazing and patient with our large group.Food was delicious, loaded garlic knots with the white cheddar dip is so
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Loaded Garlic Knots