Montezuma Roadhouse

91 River Run Rd, Keystone
(970) 262-2202

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Markeis Hobbs

Closed at 9

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 1

Service: 1

chris wolf

It took an hour to get our food and we were one of the few groups eating. We had to find our server multiple times. Food was average.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Jordan Merillat

We were 1 of 5 tables in the restaurant. We walked in at 8:00 (2 hours before they close) looks like all of the staff had already got sent home. We waited an hour for our food & we finally still didn’t get it so we asked them to box it up. Service was not good, food was not worth coming back. Even if it rains you should think about keeping more than one server on the floor. The server also didn’t check on us once. When we got home with our food (1 minute walk) we looked at the food and looks like a $5 meal that actually costed $30 each. Coming from someone who works in a restaurant this was terrible

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 1

Jeff Burley

Lemon chicken was great. The prime dip was nice as well. Our sides were pretty cold, but otherwise a decent experience. We visited in the off season, so we expected a little slow service.

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 4

Service: 3

Mory Larson

The Bison steak was probably the best steak I’ve ever eaten. Great atmosphere with service and quality meals for a price you’d expect to be double. Montezuma’s will always be on my top 5.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

colin

Can’t even make a coke right, chicken wings were tough and fries had no seasoning, for the amount of money you spend you’d expect to have a coke that actually taste like coke and fries that at least have salt on them

Food: 1

Jennifer Otavsky

The food was great and my kids loved the games, but it was the service that was exceptional. We sat in the bar area and our waiter Matt hustled like no other. He had a full section but stayed on top of things like we were his only table. Thanks Matt for the wonderful service!

Matt Finley

Great place for happy hour when you get off the slopes. All the apps are very good. We haven’t had anything bad here. Great service as well. Our server Haley was awesome!

Gena “Dr. Gena Lee” Schultheis

This was one of BEST restaurant I've ever been to, to start there waiters are one of a kind. Super nice and will make sure you are having a great time.They have food from the bottom of the sea (like salmon), to the farm lands (like chicken strips). Over all this has been a huge experience.Also, if you have so kids that will not stop bothering you, then send them to the arcade (and it is in the restaurant) to have some fun. This is a grate place to have family time, eating food that is out of this world, playing in the arcade, with stunning people serving your food. 100/100 total recommend.

Spencer Lombardo

We had the filet and the ribeye. Pretty good steaks. Glad I got the sauce on the side because the steaks did not need sauce. Great service especially considering how packed they were.

Simon Bayle

what is truly the worst is the hostess. Also every meal should be half priced. Fries are clearly made the day before

Thomas Welch

Great food

Michelle

Food was fantastic a nice variety on the menu atmosphere was lively interior is semi upscale but casual with a big fireplace near the main entrance a few televisions in the bar area. Definitely a keeper on my list of restaurants when in keystone.

Jolanta Serrano

We’ve come here 3 days in a row for dinner, it’s that good!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Mark Yev

Food is not great.
Cold soup, cold spinach dip.
Not sure what the cook is thinking when giving cold food out.
Waitress can't do anything but if they would pay attention to the food they serving to people maybe they could speak with the kitchen and to the owners. People come and spend thousands of dollars on these vacations and get no quality food or service.
Disappointed!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 1

Service: 4

Loading...