Sweet Mustache

407 Broadway St, Eagle
(970) 432-1522

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Alexandra Calia

I had to pick up some last minute treats for a friend’s birthday this past Friday (2/21) and the employees were so sweet, helpful and all around good energy. They helped me pick some options that were a huge hit! I will definitely be back to try some of the tiramisu.

Justin

Bought two mini cakes, went to eat them a couple hours later and after unwrapping it discovered mold on not one, but both of them. Completely unacceptable given they were pulled from their display case. Would not recommend given that they can’t monitor whether their baked goods are still good when they’re sold.

Food: 1

The Merks

I got 3 slices of different cake and each one was horrendous. They looked so good but I literally could not eat them. They tasted old and stale and one of them tasted like straight cleaning product. Very disappointed.

Nicole Sanderson

The sweets here are absolutely delightful!! And I had high hopes for the boba here but was severely disappointed. I can only compare it to the boba I had in prepackaged cans. It wasn’t chewy and broke apart in your mouth. The texture tasted like halloween eyeballs. Unfortunately I would *not* recommend this as a boba spot for boba enthusiasts.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 3

Service: 5

Workspace Administration

Cake pops and Marshmallow Bombs - so delicious!!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Cake

Ness G

Half of our candies were expired and hard. ?

Sarah Goto

Great little spot for pastries and cakes. Lots of options including boba, ice cream, bubble waffles, and candy. Their caramel eclair and dulce de leche cake were really good!

Dietary restrictions: Lots of Gluten free options. They have labels for dietary restrictions which is super helpful!

Atmosphere: 4

Food: 5

Service: 5

jaime fernandez

This place is very good and very fast it didn’t even take 5 minutes to get my boba made and very good service

Parking: Very easy to find parking most time

Kid-friendliness: Very kid friendly

Wheelchair accessibility: Has a wheelchair available sidewalk with flag floors inside

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Wedding Cake, Valentine Cake of the Day, Blondies, Pastries, Oreo Cheesecake, Apple Pie, Specialty Cakes, Cake, Chocolate Pastry, Birthday Cake

Todd & Michelle Heasty

So, my son and I stopped by for some ice cream at 6:40pm. Website and sign on the door says open until 7pm. We start to walk in and the young lady working says “Oh, I’m sorry, we are about to close.” So I asked her if that meant we can’t get any ice cream and she said “Yes, we are about to close.” So apparently being open until 7 doesn’t mean being open until 7. We went down the street to another ice cream place that was actually open (Dulce) and had a great experience. Thanks to your employee, we will never be back. Date of 5/3/24 at 6:40pm for the manager or owner.

Service: 1

Todd \u0026 Michelle Heasty

So, my son and I stopped by for some ice cream at 6:40pm. Website and sign on the door says open until 7pm. We start to walk in and the young lady working says “Oh, I’m sorry, we are about to close.” So I asked her if that meant we can’t get any ice cream and she said “Yes, we are about to close.” So apparently being open until 7 doesn’t mean being open until 7. We went down the street to another ice cream place that was actually open (Dulce) and had a great experience. Thanks to your employee, we will never be back. Date of 5/3/24 at 6:40pm for the manager or owner.

Stella Stevenson

It has vary good pastry’s

Paulina Rodriguez

Wow it is a spectacular place!!! The attention of all the people who work there is great and everything they sell has incredible flavors ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Atrévetee a Vivir S

My favorite place in

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Danielle Huidekoper

Hands down the best apple pie I have ever eaten!!! Beyond that; great service, always very responsive and able to fill orders (even at that last minute). My go to in Eagle for sure.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Gabriela Resnicoff

Beautiful place and delicious pastries, I ordered a birthday cake plus cupckaes and everything was great ?

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...