Antonio's Real New York Pizza

Fantastic pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Y'all make one hell of a pie. Best pepperoni pizza I have ever had. Did take out. Thanks for that great pizza after long voyage here.

Food: 5

Best pizza in town. Best pizza IN THE STATE! the Godfather pizza is one I have multiple times. Best pizza I have ever had. From the crust, to the toppings..so filling and good! I would drive out of my way to eat at this place. On our annual Estes Park trip, we literally have a Antonio's pizza night pre-planned.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

This was honestly one of the worst dining experiences I’ve ever had. The place is an absolute mess from top to bottom. First of all, the place is severely understaffed — the few employees there looked overwhelmed and stressed out, and it’s clear they’re being set up to fail. The pizza was mediocre at best and wasn’t even hot when it came out. The wings were a disaster — the sauce was just slopped on, barely any flavor, and the whole thing was a mess to eat.

And let’s talk about the prices — *are you serious?* Everything is insanely overpriced for what you actually get. They even charge for water, which is a total joke. Water should be free, period. Trying to justify it all by calling this place a “social experiment” is complete BS. That’s just a lazy, pretentious excuse to get away with bad service, poor management, and price gouging. Don’t insult customers by pretending this is some kind of meaningful concept when it’s just a poorly run restaurant.

The bathroom? Absolutely disgusting. It looked like it hadn’t been cleaned all day — overflowing trash, toilet paper on the floor, and a smell that made me want to leave immediately. Totally unacceptable for any establishment, especially one charging this much.

While we were there, we saw multiple people get up and leave before even finishing their food. Some didn’t even bother waiting to be served. That says a lot.

And the owner? From what I’ve seen in the comments and how he responds to criticism, he’s a complete jerk. Instead of taking responsibility for the chaos, he constantly blames his employees, which is disgusting. If you can’t take accountability for your own business, you shouldn’t be running one. He clearly has no idea how to manage a company or treat people with basic respect.

This place is all hype and no heart. Save your time, money, and dignity — go literally *anywhere* else. One star is generous.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 2

Service: 1

Great place to eat! They were busy and we still got great service and food. Great spot for a mid day break from the park.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Great food they have a cool robot that delivers your food!

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 5

Service: 4

Can't say enough about Antonios!! Pizza was the best we ever had, and Service was outstanding!!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Pizza And, Garlic Cheese Bread

We hit Antonio's every time we are in Estes. The food is top notch. Best calzone I've ever had! (sliced meatballs, sausage and jalepeno...ummmmm) Only complaint I have is the long wait time for seating but that's a good indicator of what you're going to get once seated.

Review Update: We were back in Estes 9/27. The evening dining moved to take out only. The process was really easy to order and pick up. Tried the Sicilian and holy cow was it good. Best pizza I’ve ever had! Well done Antonio’s!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Garlic Knots

The website was confusing, and when we arrived at the restaurant, there was an A-frame sign in front of the front door, telling you to scan the QR code and order for takeout because they were understaffed. We did that, I immediately received a text message, confirming my order and that it would be followed up by a text message when it was ready. I never received a text message so I finally went into the restaurant and they said it had been sitting there. Then the dressing they put in the bag leaked before I even got home and the entire bag was covered with salad dressing. Not a great experience.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 3

Service: 1

Antonio’s Pizza at Estes park is delicious. We are giving them a bad rating in regards to their terrible on-line ordering system when their restaurant has inside dining shutdown due to lack of staff. It was a total joke. After waiting in the parking lot for 45 minutes (with zero online updates on our order) I went inside to check status. There was a customer at the cash register before me who had the same miserable experience. Upon that customer complaining to a totally uncaring two poeple at the register mysteriously their pizza was brought from the kitchen to them. I stepped up to the register and showed my phone screen (zero updates) and the gent behind the counter (who has always presented himself as the owner) simply stayed “I am just the Pizza cook” and walked off. Another young lady stepped to the counter and told me to pick up my order I needed to step to an adjacent area. Upon doing so a young man found our order and apologized for the mess of their system. I thanked him for his honesty and mentioned their online system was not the usual great service this firm provides. He stated he would convey the thought on to the manager apologizing again. Whoever is the owner for real needs to step back and take a clear assessment of the clusterfab and learn from it. We DO look forward to our next opportunity to dine in at this restaurant but will never waste time with take out.

Atmosphere: 1

Food: 5

Service: 1

My family and I get pizza at this place once every few months and each and every time we go is a positive experience. We live about an hour and a half away and we make this trip just to get the pizza. Also to enjoy the scenery ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Excellent pizza! Very fresh and very authentic NY! My husband and I stopped in after visiting RMNP and was warmly greeted by Antonio. He explained the wait staff shortage which did not slow them down! First timed served by a robot but the food was out quickly, hot and fresh! We are from Fort Collins and I would happily drive up again for great pizza!

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

I am choosing this over dominoes any day

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Take out only due to labor shortage.

Pizza was fantastic! I hope they solve their labor issues as their pizza is worth the trip.

Food: 5

We waited 90 minutes for one pizza to go. Checked a couple times and we’re told it wasn’t done. After the 90 minutes my husband asked again. When they checked the warmer there it was under several pizza’s.

Food: 2

Service: 1