Otto's
450 US Hwy 285, Fairplay
(719) 839-5393
Customers' Favorites
Hot Honey Chicken Sandwich and Sweet Potato Fries with Cajun Seasoning
Otto's Special Chicken Sandwich
The Hot-Honey Chicken Sandwich
Ottos Special Chicken Sandwich
The Original Chicken Sandwich
Philly Cheese Steak Sandwich
The Colossal Cajun Chicken
Cheesy Bacon Cowgirl Fries
Colossal Chicken Sandwich
Carolina BBQ Pulled Pork
Menu
Photos
+14 photos
+13 photos
Add a photo
Recent Reviews
Otto’s Sandwich Shop in Fairplay is an absolute gem! The sandwiches are fresh, generously portioned, and packed with flavor—clearly made with quality ingredients and real care. The bread is excellent, the meats and veggies are fresh, and everything tastes homemade rather than rushed. The shop has a cozy, welcoming vibe that fits perfectly with the mountain-town feel, and the service is friendly and genuine. Whether you’re passing through or a local, Otto’s is the kind...
We arrived on a Monday afternoon and the place was packed. This was the best chicken sandwich I’ve ever had! Hot honey chicken with blue cheese. Sweet potato fries were also amazing.
Otto's is awesome. Ordered the colossal chicken sandwich as recommended by the guy up front with Cajun fries neither of which disappointed. Had to split the sandwich because it was so big. Loved the atmosphere from the music playing to the art for sale displayed on the wall.
You May Also Like
J.R.'s Pizza Place - 400 US Hwy 285
![]()
Pizza, Food Trucks, Caterers, Pet Friendly
Highside Brewing - Fairplay - 411 US Hwy 285
![]()
Brewery, Brewpubs, Barbeque, Pet Friendly
Yummies Food Stand - 531 US Hwy 285
![]()
Food Court