Papa Johns Pizza

8196 Colorado Blvd N4, Firestone
(303) 731-0778

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Wall Flour

Ordered 2 separate orders of boneless BBQ chicken wings and got sadness instead. Not only is the chicken dry its mostly bare of any sauce and there wasn't even any at the bottom that I could use to coat the sad chicken highly disappointed.

Food: 1

Service: 1

Joey Tru

I absolutely highly recommend this new management Joseph the GM is absolutely understandable and very polite. My driver Jacob was amazing. Food was hot as it arrived and the quality was amazing. You must not read the other reviews based off the old management staff don’t hesitate to order with this new management team Amazing and thank you

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Thaddeus Johnson

Awful service, yelled at me for an order I didn’t put in when I showed up

D Hern

Places keep wondering why they go out of business. Called to order 25 pizzas, they couldn't help me. Yeah wouldn't want you to be too busy!

Charles Staples

If you like this style of pizza it's fine. I'm not a fan. I mistyped and I wanted Papa Murphy.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Rick Parks

Almost $35 for one pizza. I was told the price included tax & delivery fees. I was then asked if I wanted to add a tip ($$). I did not add tip, because price included a delivery cost already!

Stacie R

Called to order a shaqaroni for 12.99 and an 8 piece buffalo wings pairings and we're told by the call center that because of our location the pizza is 13.99 and the wings are only 6 pieces unless we pay 3 more dollars for 2 more wings, so when my husband goes to the store to pick up the order, he explains his frustration and is told that they don't care and threaten to call police, I'm sure my husband let them have it after being told they don't care, but then to threaten to have police called on you after complaining, is really too much.

Atmosphere: 1

Service: 1

Trizzy Trayvon williams

This is my preferred location for Papa John's. The staff provides excellent service, and General Manager Gabby is exceptional. I've observed her actively working alongside her team to prepare for peak hours and engaging in community outreach to promote the restaurant. Her dedication to ensuring a positive customer experience is evident.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Krystyl Summers

Gabby the store manager deserves a promotion. She made our day so special! We were outside the area. But she added us and allowed delivery. The Food is amazing! Best pizza around. Highly recommend.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Hallie Smith

Busy nights happen. But I ordered garlic knots and got 8 plain knots of bread, no garlic butter. For 7 bucks that feels like quite a rip off.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 2

Service: 3

Abraham Benitez

great and cheap

Cody Hildebrand

Uses doordash to deliver without telling you. Took 1 hour and 45 minutes and was told 45 minutes. Just don't do delivery

raindrops

Place has always been mid but today I ordered online and was quoted a 15-20 minute wait and after 30 minutes I pulled up and they hadn't even started my order lol 45 minute wait for a light pick up order is craaaaaaaazy

Chris Burroughs

Good pizza

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Isaac Wolverton

I had an excellent carry out experience! Ordered online (don't forget to check for deals, I got an XL pep for $11). Pizza was done in 12 minutes on a Sunday evening and it tasted great. I'll definitely be returning

Loading...