Delicious pie and cookies! Our new family favorite in Granby!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Melissa Wallentine
The pie was so-so. We are pie people, and maybe we got a subpar sample, but the crust was gummy and the pie flavor (blueberry) just OK.
An entire pie is $40 and up, and a slice is $9 after tax, so they aren't cheap
We drove through, so atmosphere isn't applicable.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Derek Miller
Excellent food. We’ve had their pies several times, the lasagna, and most recently the cinnamon raisin bread which we made into French toast. Always fantastic. My kids always beg to pick up from here when we visit Grand County!
Jeremy McMillen
Sherry is an absolute sweetheart, and her pies are amazing! Thank you for being in the valley!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Shanna Eklund Tibbetts
We stopped by on Thursday late afternoon. She made us a fresh, hot apple pie. It was delicious!
Bill Holt
I really wanted to like this place because pie shops are hard to find these days and I LOVE pies. Super cute set up with a drive-through window. I had high hopes. Unfortunately, as other reviewers have mentioned, the pie is soggy and just not good and extremely overpriced. Kind of a joke actually. I gotta think the locals laugh the tourists like me stopping at this place. Nobody would repeat. Avoid.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
Kathy Anastasov
I thought it was extremely expensive for a slice of pie they were $8 a piece Crest was mushy very disappointing. And who can afford $40 a pie that's ridiculous if that's the case drive to Denver a place called taste of Denmark they have the best homemade pies and they're $17 will not go here again and not recommend it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Jodie Swift
Drive by pie. No way. Don't even have to get out of the car. Service was great. I assume she was the owner and baker extraordinaire was VERY nice. Solid 10. Pie was $50 which I get you have to make a living. HOWEVER I would think this would deter people. We got the mixed berry. My hubby gives it a 6/10. I give it a 4/10. Village inn at home charges $15 for fruit pie and it tastes better. $25 would be more affordable. Pie did have somewhat of a salty flavor maybe the crust? I wish our baker much success but feel more fruit in the pie and less salt and maybe slightly lower prices will bring more business your way.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Tom G
Way overpriced Pie did not taste fresh. Very dissapointed
Digital Nick
Something about this joint feels like a total scam. I think it's because by the time you realize the outrageous prices, it's too late as the sweet old lady has already started chatting you up by then. Then you feel guilty and pay the highway robbery (literally) prices of $18 bucks for 2 small slices of apple pie. And sadly the apple pie was far from the best pie I've ever had. The apples were mushy and unflavorful, and overall seemed like it had been sitting out for a while. I imagine this is just part of the Grandby experience that you have to say you did once and learned your lesson. I highly doubt any locals are ever stopping by here.
Best pie in Colorado hands down! Can’t say enough good things about Sherry’s pies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Raisin Bread
JM D
This place has to be a scam/money laundering joint, right?
We are staying in Granby over the holiday and my wife and I stopped by today to try their pie of the day-- Maine Blueberry pie. Sounds good!
The pie is listed at $8 a slice, but the total we were charged for 2 slices was rounded up with a tip to $18 instead of $16. Ok... guess it's a nice tip for the older owner. Oh, also it's cash only. No cash? No problem, they can take Venmo for an additional $1 (call it $19 for two slices of pie).
The pie slices come. They are plastic wrapped on a tiny styrofoam plate (yay, environment). They are tiny. They are the length of 3/4 of a dollar bill, and the height of about 1/2 of a dollar bill.
We drive away feeling like we got scammed. But at least we have pie, right?
We sit down to have the pie after dinner. We pair it with a Madagascar vanilla gelato. The gelato is the only thing that makes the pie edible. The pie filling is bland. It has no sweetness. It has a strange salty flavor. We try the crust. The crust is dense. It tastes slightly of butter, and heavily of salt. The combination, without gelato, is not good.
I throw away $4.75 of pie into the trash.
Skip this place. You can get better pie in a hospital.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Katie Lillo
Very expensive
skyleigh taylor
We stopped by randomly and got the slice of the day which was apple pie. Our car of 4 unanimously concluded it was the best pie we’ve ever had. The owner Sherry was a ray of sunshine and chatted with us for multiple minutes in the drive through giving us advice on our drive back home. Unfortunately she does no longer offer breakfast burritos :(
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Fielding Graeber
Way overpriced pies is what they should call this place.
Delicious pie and cookies! Our new family favorite in Granby!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pie was so-so. We are pie people, and maybe we got a subpar sample, but the crust was gummy and the pie flavor (blueberry) just OK.
An entire pie is $40 and up, and a slice is $9 after tax, so they aren't cheap
We drove through, so atmosphere isn't applicable.
Food: 3
Service: 4
Excellent food. We’ve had their pies several times, the lasagna, and most recently the cinnamon raisin bread which we made into French toast. Always fantastic. My kids always beg to pick up from here when we visit Grand County!
Sherry is an absolute sweetheart, and her pies are amazing! Thank you for being in the valley!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We stopped by on Thursday late afternoon. She made us a fresh, hot apple pie. It was delicious!
I really wanted to like this place because pie shops are hard to find these days and I LOVE pies. Super cute set up with a drive-through window. I had high hopes. Unfortunately, as other reviewers have mentioned, the pie is soggy and just not good and extremely overpriced. Kind of a joke actually. I gotta think the locals laugh the tourists like me stopping at this place. Nobody would repeat. Avoid.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 2
Service: 3
I thought it was extremely expensive for a slice of pie they were $8 a piece Crest was mushy very disappointing. And who can afford $40 a pie that's ridiculous if that's the case drive to Denver a place called taste of Denmark they have the best homemade pies and they're $17 will not go here again and not recommend it.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Drive by pie. No way. Don't even have to get out of the car. Service was great. I assume she was the owner and baker extraordinaire was VERY nice. Solid 10. Pie was $50 which I get you have to make a living. HOWEVER I would think this would deter people. We got the mixed berry. My hubby gives it a 6/10. I give it a 4/10. Village inn at home charges $15 for fruit pie and it tastes better. $25 would be more affordable. Pie did have somewhat of a salty flavor maybe the crust? I wish our baker much success but feel more fruit in the pie and less salt and maybe slightly lower prices will bring more business your way.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 2
Service: 5
Way overpriced Pie did not taste fresh. Very dissapointed
Something about this joint feels like a total scam. I think it's because by the time you realize the outrageous prices, it's too late as the sweet old lady has already started chatting you up by then. Then you feel guilty and pay the highway robbery (literally) prices of $18 bucks for 2 small slices of apple pie. And sadly the apple pie was far from the best pie I've ever had. The apples were mushy and unflavorful, and overall seemed like it had been sitting out for a while. I imagine this is just part of the Grandby experience that you have to say you did once and learned your lesson. I highly doubt any locals are ever stopping by here.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 2
Restaurantji Recommends
Best pie in Colorado hands down! Can’t say enough good things about Sherry’s pies!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cinnamon Raisin Bread
This place has to be a scam/money laundering joint, right?
We are staying in Granby over the holiday and my wife and I stopped by today to try their pie of the day-- Maine Blueberry pie. Sounds good!
The pie is listed at $8 a slice, but the total we were charged for 2 slices was rounded up with a tip to $18 instead of $16. Ok... guess it's a nice tip for the older owner. Oh, also it's cash only. No cash? No problem, they can take Venmo for an additional $1 (call it $19 for two slices of pie).
The pie slices come. They are plastic wrapped on a tiny styrofoam plate (yay, environment). They are tiny. They are the length of 3/4 of a dollar bill, and the height of about 1/2 of a dollar bill.
We drive away feeling like we got scammed. But at least we have pie, right?
We sit down to have the pie after dinner. We pair it with a Madagascar vanilla gelato. The gelato is the only thing that makes the pie edible. The pie filling is bland. It has no sweetness. It has a strange salty flavor. We try the crust. The crust is dense. It tastes slightly of butter, and heavily of salt. The combination, without gelato, is not good.
I throw away $4.75 of pie into the trash.
Skip this place. You can get better pie in a hospital.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 1
Service: 1
Very expensive
We stopped by randomly and got the slice of the day which was apple pie. Our car of 4 unanimously concluded it was the best pie we’ve ever had. The owner Sherry was a ray of sunshine and chatted with us for multiple minutes in the drive through giving us advice on our drive back home. Unfortunately she does no longer offer breakfast burritos :(
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Way overpriced pies is what they should call this place.
Atmosphere: 1
Food: 2
Service: 1
Loading...