The WORST experience! Didn’t get bread served to us. All the waiters running around like chickens with their heads cut off. We sat for 2 hours on Father’s Day and didn’t get our food. Got charged someone else’s bill $80 more. The list goes on. I DO NOT recommend this place.
Chris Cornelius
Fantastic dinner, chicken parm reminded me of The Hill in STL. Caesar salad was outstanding also
Jim Young
Wow what a find. Fun menu. Great wine list.
Isabelle McGee
Amazing vibes, friendly and knowledgeable service, and the best food I've had in weeks! My server knew the menu extremely well and was able to guide me through allergen safe menu items.
P K
Just had a great meal here. Perfectly cooked filet mignon with wonderfully textured mashed potatoes and amazing Brussel sprouts ( hard to do as I am pretty meh most of the time on them). Outstanding service by Nathan. 5 stars.
Doreen Ward
We just had the most amazing dinner at Garlic Mikes! The mushroom soup was wonderful, the Prime Rib done perfectly, and the Shrimp Scampi was cooked and seasoned exactly as one would expect. The shrimp were fresh, large, and very tender. Delicious! Nona’s lemon cake was an exquisite ending to the meal along with two warm cups of Nutty Monks. We enjoyed watching one dish after another being prepared by the talented chef and his assistants. Every dish looked so appetizing we wished we were staying in Gunnison longer so we could sample more of the menu. From the receptionist to the young gentleman filling water glasses, and the two waiters, all of the wait staff were friendly, attentive and made wonderful recommendations. How lucky Garlic Mike’s is to have them. We have had several dining experiences all over the country that so memorable that we still reminisce about them - Garlic Mike’s will definitely be added to that list. Thank you so much. We are looking forward to a time when we can return to Gunnison and enjoy another meal with you again.
Ksenia F
We chose this place for my dad’s birthday dinner while visiting from Dallas, and it was a mixed experience. The main meal was good, but the orange juice was spoiled, and the forks were dirty, which was off-putting. It also seemed like they were understaffed, as service was a bit slow. Overall, the restaurant is overpriced for what it offers.
Edit: People who don't drink alcohol. Thanks for responding to my review and revealing your true colors and providing unsolicited advice. Changing my rating from 3 to 1 star. Best of luck!
Kasey E
Absolutely pissed and grossed out right now. Ordered takeout at 6:30, the lady on the phone said it would be ready at 7:45. We then show up and are greeted with a weird “glad you made it” comment, has us thinking she meant 6:45 and not 7:45. So our food was sitting there for an hour and we are only 5 min away. If she did mean 7:45, the food was super cold and seemed old. The steak fettuccini was gritty and tasted like water, no cheese, steak tasted like soy sauce. The meatballs and tasted old and flavorless. I cannot express the lack of seasoning, I’m not very picky but there was not one seasoning on that fettuccini, $90 later and we practically threw it all away. I would’ve rather ate McDonald’s I can’t even make that up. So disappointed by one of the “best” restaurants in town. Food channel should be embarrassed 🤣 Garlic mikes needs to use some garlic or something, so bland. Also the salad came dressed so it was all mushy and wilted. Despite the possible miscommunication. The food was absolutely tasteless and inedible.
Susan Ray Gressett
Whenever I’m in Gunnison, I enjoy eating at Garlic Mike’s. I was excited to have my 75th birthday dinner there on January 5, 2025. The cream of mushroom soup and flatiron steak were very good, however the Alfredo sauce was thin and tasteless. We weren’t offered freshly grated Parmesan cheese which is standard for an Italian restaurant! I was disappointed there was no free offer of a birthday dessert or just a scoop of ice cream. They were aware it was my birthday! Also the two young men in the kitchen had a rather loud conversation about a sexual predator that could be heard in the dining area!! So my visit there did not meet my expectations, but I’ll probably dine there during future visits
The WORST experience! Didn’t get bread served to us. All the waiters running around like chickens with their heads cut off. We sat for 2 hours on Father’s Day and didn’t get our food. Got charged someone else’s bill $80 more. The list goes on. I DO NOT recommend this place.
Fantastic dinner, chicken parm reminded me of The Hill in STL. Caesar salad was outstanding also
Wow what a find. Fun menu. Great wine list.
Amazing vibes, friendly and knowledgeable service, and the best food I've had in weeks! My server knew the menu extremely well and was able to guide me through allergen safe menu items.
Just had a great meal here. Perfectly cooked filet mignon with wonderfully textured mashed potatoes and amazing Brussel sprouts ( hard to do as I am pretty meh most of the time on them). Outstanding service by Nathan. 5 stars.
We just had the most amazing dinner at Garlic Mikes! The mushroom soup was wonderful, the Prime Rib done perfectly, and the Shrimp Scampi was cooked and seasoned exactly as one would expect. The shrimp were fresh, large, and very tender. Delicious! Nona’s lemon cake was an exquisite ending to the meal along with two warm cups of Nutty Monks. We enjoyed watching one dish after another being prepared by the talented chef and his assistants. Every dish looked so appetizing we wished we were staying in Gunnison longer so we could sample more of the menu.
From the receptionist to the young gentleman filling water glasses, and the two waiters, all of the wait staff were friendly, attentive and made wonderful recommendations. How lucky Garlic Mike’s is to have them.
We have had several dining experiences all over the country that so memorable that we still reminisce about them - Garlic Mike’s will definitely be added to that list. Thank you so much. We are looking forward to a time when we can return to Gunnison and enjoy another meal with you again.
We chose this place for my dad’s birthday dinner while visiting from Dallas, and it was a mixed experience. The main meal was good, but the orange juice was spoiled, and the forks were dirty, which was off-putting. It also seemed like they were understaffed, as service was a bit slow. Overall, the restaurant is overpriced for what it offers.
Edit: People who don't drink alcohol. Thanks for responding to my review and revealing your true colors and providing unsolicited advice. Changing my rating from 3 to 1 star. Best of luck!
Absolutely pissed and grossed out right now. Ordered takeout at 6:30, the lady on the phone said it would be ready at 7:45. We then show up and are greeted with a weird “glad you made it” comment, has us thinking she meant 6:45 and not 7:45. So our food was sitting there for an hour and we are only 5 min away. If she did mean 7:45, the food was super cold and seemed old. The steak fettuccini was gritty and tasted like water, no cheese, steak tasted like soy sauce. The meatballs and tasted old and flavorless. I cannot express the lack of seasoning, I’m not very picky but there was not one seasoning on that fettuccini, $90 later and we practically threw it all away. I would’ve rather ate McDonald’s I can’t even make that up. So disappointed by one of the “best” restaurants in town. Food channel should be embarrassed 🤣 Garlic mikes needs to use some garlic or something, so bland. Also the salad came dressed so it was all mushy and wilted. Despite the possible miscommunication. The food was absolutely tasteless and inedible.
Whenever I’m in Gunnison, I enjoy eating at Garlic Mike’s. I was excited to have my 75th birthday dinner there on January 5, 2025. The cream of mushroom soup and flatiron steak were very good, however the Alfredo sauce was thin and tasteless. We weren’t offered freshly grated Parmesan cheese which is standard for an Italian restaurant! I was disappointed there was no free offer of a birthday dessert or just a scoop of ice cream. They were aware it was my birthday! Also the two young men in the kitchen had a rather loud conversation about a sexual predator that could be heard in the dining area!! So my visit there did not meet my expectations, but I’ll probably dine there during future visits
Excellent food
Restaurantji Recommends
Whenever you in town it’s a must you stop here. Best food in town hands down
We had a great dinner! Great service
Good service
Great place to eat
Very nice place
Loading...