Fantastic pizza with a wonderful and friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Caprese Salad
Tim Pastelak
Great pizza, really nice staff, great service and drink options. I will always recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Traffic Jam
Your Mom
The food here was amazing!!! ? Everything was beautiful and the staff was so kind and funny, I go with my family every so often and the community just makes me want to go back all the time. I recommend this place to all my friend, it brings me back to my high school days when I worked at the local pizza shop! ☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Salad, Pie, Caesar Salad
Robert Lemus
The service we received was 1st class and the food was prepared exceptionally well. We had the meat lovers Pizza and a magnificent salad . Tim's entire staff was on point and exceptionally friendly.
S K.
This place needs more reviews. What a hidden gem. I had heard from a friend it was good and they were right. Tasty pizza, friendly service, and lots of options. The pizza was great and my 3 small kids finished off a large. They have a hot infused oil that you can put on as well, super tasty. They had a special just for this past week too, strawberry cannolis in a chocolate shell. So good, very different from the original. Overall, I'd like to go back and try their limoncello margaritas or other drinks. They even had a TV for games. Good stuff for sure.
Tanner Knochenmus
Nono is a fantastic GM!! Terrific pies and excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Vika Grindle
Delicious food and excellent service!!! Traditional style Italian pizzeria with that classic thin crust hand tossed crust. Try their Italian sodas!! And their garlic infused olive oil is awesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Savory Pannini, Pizza
Kevin Yao
The pizza crust was very thin and it was mostly burnt. The ingredients appeared to be pretty fresh. It was almost $45 for a medium and large pizza and they secretly added ‘Employ Benefits Charge’ which is lame. Mod Pizza down the street could have been way better. We will not come back again.
Food: 2
Service: 3
Amy Frederick
First off, when you walk into an establishment, and you see the person who's going to be making your food and she has a scowl on her face, can't simply acknowledge you or fails to smile, I recommend turning around and walking out. And that's what we should have done today. While the person who we ordered our to go pizza with was very nice, the cook wasn't and the pizza she made was horrible! It was burnt in spots, flatter than paper, had very little to no toppings in most spots and was probably the hardest piece of cardboard I've ever been handed. I will be disputing the charge for this "pizza" and I won't step foot in this place again. There are many other places that know how to make a $25 pizza edible.
Food: 1
Janice Imanaka Schade
Embarrassed to say we’ve lived in Lafayette for 4 years and this is our first visit. Pizzas (Angel’s Pie and the Fri/ Sat special clam pizza) were delish. Their red sauce is exceptional and their salad special was flavorful and perfect with our pizza. The staff (the fellows manning the pizza oven), Nono and Ashley were very friendly, helpful and super personable. They also gave us really great recommendations. Nono made us the perfect (not so dirty) dirty martini. We will definitely be seeing this lovely Proto’s family again!
I cannot believe how bad this was. I ordered five pizzas, picked them up, took them home, and they were awful. Inedible. We would have gotten more enjoyment eating the box. The pizza was cold, dried out, almost like it was baked the day before and left out all night. We literally threw away pizza because it was so sh*tty. It was sadness in a box. Caveat emptor.
Glenn D
Great pizza, unusual versions. Fantastic desserts.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Gordon A.
Oredred a Proto Pie(basil and sausage). Good crust,good ingredients. But,12 pieces of sausage on a large pizza. Had one piece with 1/2 a piece of sausage on it. Looked like maybe 5 basil leaves torn up on the entire pizza. $26 for the pie. Horrible value. Won't be back.
FashioNation / Babysitter's Nightmare
We went for the first time and it was AMAZING. The only thing better than the food was our lovely bartender/waitress. She was giving us amazing recommendations, letting us know what fun menu items were coming, and was overall wonderful to talk to. Would make the 40 minute drive to this location just for her drinks again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Peter Weiss
The pizza is very good, plenty of choices for toppings, including white anchovies. The only gripe I have is that the pizza is very expensive. Maybe as much as New York City.Vegetarian options: Pizza and salads available
Fantastic pizza with a wonderful and friendly staff.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Caprese Salad
Great pizza, really nice staff, great service and drink options. I will always recommend this place!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Traffic Jam
The food here was amazing!!! ? Everything was beautiful and the staff was so kind and funny, I go with my family every so often and the community just makes me want to go back all the time. I recommend this place to all my friend, it brings me back to my high school days when I worked at the local pizza shop! ☺️
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Salad, Pie, Caesar Salad
The service we received was 1st class and the food was prepared exceptionally well. We had the meat lovers Pizza and a magnificent salad . Tim's entire staff was on point and exceptionally friendly.
This place needs more reviews. What a hidden gem. I had heard from a friend it was good and they were right. Tasty pizza, friendly service, and lots of options. The pizza was great and my 3 small kids finished off a large. They have a hot infused oil that you can put on as well, super tasty. They had a special just for this past week too, strawberry cannolis in a chocolate shell. So good, very different from the original. Overall, I'd like to go back and try their limoncello margaritas or other drinks. They even had a TV for games. Good stuff for sure.
Nono is a fantastic GM!! Terrific pies and excellent
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Delicious food and excellent service!!! Traditional style Italian pizzeria with that classic thin crust hand tossed crust. Try their Italian sodas!! And their garlic infused olive oil is awesome.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Savory Pannini, Pizza
The pizza crust was very thin and it was mostly burnt. The ingredients appeared to be pretty fresh. It was almost $45 for a medium and large pizza and they secretly added ‘Employ Benefits Charge’ which is lame. Mod Pizza down the street could have been way better. We will not come back again.
Food: 2
Service: 3
First off, when you walk into an establishment, and you see the person who's going to be making your food and she has a scowl on her face, can't simply acknowledge you or fails to smile, I recommend turning around and walking out. And that's what we should have done today. While the person who we ordered our to go pizza with was very nice, the cook wasn't and the pizza she made was horrible! It was burnt in spots, flatter than paper, had very little to no toppings in most spots and was probably the hardest piece of cardboard I've ever been handed. I will be disputing the charge for this "pizza" and I won't step foot in this place again. There are many other places that know how to make a $25 pizza edible.
Food: 1
Embarrassed to say we’ve lived in Lafayette for 4 years and this is our first visit. Pizzas (Angel’s Pie and the Fri/ Sat special clam pizza) were delish. Their red sauce is exceptional and their salad special was flavorful and perfect with our pizza. The staff (the fellows manning the pizza oven), Nono and Ashley were very friendly, helpful and super personable. They also gave us really great recommendations. Nono made us the perfect (not so dirty) dirty martini. We will definitely be seeing this lovely Proto’s family again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Pizza, Salad
Restaurantji Recommends
I cannot believe how bad this was. I ordered five pizzas, picked them up, took them home, and they were awful. Inedible. We would have gotten more enjoyment eating the box. The pizza was cold, dried out, almost like it was baked the day before and left out all night. We literally threw away pizza because it was so sh*tty. It was sadness in a box. Caveat emptor.
Great pizza, unusual versions. Fantastic desserts.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza
Oredred a Proto Pie(basil and sausage). Good crust,good ingredients. But,12 pieces of sausage on a large pizza. Had one piece with 1/2 a piece of sausage on it. Looked like maybe 5 basil leaves torn up on the entire pizza. $26 for the pie. Horrible value. Won't be back.
We went for the first time and it was AMAZING. The only thing better than the food was our lovely bartender/waitress. She was giving us amazing recommendations, letting us know what fun menu items were coming, and was overall wonderful to talk to. Would make the 40 minute drive to this location just for her drinks again!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The pizza is very good, plenty of choices for toppings, including white anchovies. The only gripe I have is that the pizza is very expensive. Maybe as much as New York City.Vegetarian options: Pizza and salads available
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Pizza