Blue Island Oyster Bar and Seafood

My guest and I really enjoyed the meal. It's my third visit, and I've had a good time every time. The only drawback to me is the cost. Yes, the prices are all on the menu, and I knew what I was getting into. But I spend $225 for 1 cocktail, 1 glass of wine, 6 oysters, 1 Caesar salad (split), 1 lobster roll, 1 Diver's platter (fried clams, cod, scallops, shrimp), 1 Key lime pie (split), tax and tip. For me, that's a pricey night out. Can't do it too often.

The restaurant had advertised a special. They were out of the special by 6:15 PM on a Saturday night. Manager aplogized however felt a bit like bait and switch. Probably won't return.

Scott was amazing! Quick, friendly, and fun. Amazing food. Thank you, Scott, for making our night!

So pleased to celebrate the 10th year of this remarkable restaurant, cannot recall a bad meal, brought a friend for the first time, this is our new go-to place. This discount is ridiculous, thank you for your generosity Blue Island! 

The meal was fantastic, the staff was fantastic. Our server Violetta was outstanding. Just agreed overall experience.

Our server was Luis A. Did a wonderful job celebrating our granddaughter's birthday and was very patient and helpful with our meal selections.

The place was packed on a Friday night, but we had reservations and were seated immediately -- and at a booth that exactly fit the specifications I made on the Open Table reservation. The server was consistently attentive, courteous, and friendly. Our meals (lobster roll for my wife, the filet mignon for me) were prepared reasonably quickly, considering how busy the restaurant was. Both of us considered our meals delicious; we'd definitely order the same dishes again.

Wonderful seafood, served promptly and with a smile. We had a lovely dinner and plenty of time to make our show at LTAC.

We always enjoy Blue. We tried the asian-inspired lobster roll this visit and I'm still thinking about it. Very yum!

Love the oysters! Dinner was great as usual. This spot is our go to when we want to have great food nd a good time!

Kirsten was exceptional! She made some great recommendations for us and the food was delicious!!

Food was good. Service was amazing (thanks Kaitlyn!). I can't get around $4 for an oyster that was literally the size of a quarter and $145 for crab legs that weren't even cut open. $350 for dinner for two means I expect some pretty amazing food. And this was good. But not amazing.

We always enjoy eating here. The food is delicious, staff is friendly and service has always been great. Last night, however, we ordered appetizers and waited an HOUR for our entrees. We kept looking for our waiter. Three tables that arrived after us were finished with their meals before we were even served.

Oysters were delicious as were the lobster rolls. Very noisy but good vibe - everyone having a good time.

Great drinks and food. I was there for a business meeting. Noise level was very high. Strongly recommended though.