Stopped here on a whim travelling to see our family in Cheyenne and I'm so glad we did. This place was phenomenal!!! Best crab cakes I've ever had (they were a special so I dont think you can get them anytime.) If you're wanting some amazing Italian food, look no further! We will DEFINITELY be coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jacob Mares
Hands down the best lasagna I've ever had! Love the family that runs this place. You can taste the love in every bite. A true hidden gem in Wellington!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Debbie Sullivan
My husband and I stumbled upon this gem!
Excellent Italian food. I highly recommend.
Carolyn Blechschmidt
The food was delicious. The atmosphere was cozy, and the service was good. We would definitely eat there again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Donald Foos
We just moved into the area. This is the best Italian food we have ever had. It is very authentic and delicious. Great food great prices. Great service. And a beautiful dining room. We will be coming here many times in the future.
Laurie Stell
The food was delicious. We started with Mussels Angelo- yum, salad was very fresh, Swordfish served Sicilian style was amazing. Veal Picatta (schnitzel style) was loaded with capers and lemon. The portions were generous without being too much. Chocolate mousse was rich and creamy. The staff/owners were very friendly and welcoming. If you’re in the Wellington/Ft Collins area- I would highly recommend Papa’s Table.
Martin Gelfand
An old-school Italian joint. I can't believe I had overlooked this spot for so many years. Definitely worth the drive from Fort Collins.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Jeffrey
Outstanding! Great food great people quiet and cozy little "neighborhood" restaurant. Date night or Sunday family lunch here's the place for you and you don't have to drive to Ft Collins!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Merle Nicholson
Closed, for sale
Elizabeth Parker (Rayne726)
After having lived in Fort Collins for the past few years, we moved to Wellington a few months ago, where we discovered Papa's Table. We have been a few times, (my kids' favorite was during the summer when they had special menu items). Tonight, we attended a fundraiser for Samaritan's Purse, raising money for hurricane victims on the East Coast. As always, the food was amazing, despite the limited menu, of which all proceeds were donated. Drinks and desserts went back to the restaurant, which we also happily purchased. The owners and their daughter have always been friendly, but tonight, being mostly loyal patrons, and local residents, it felt like an almost familial atmosphere. It was the small-town, homey vibes I have missed since we moved to Colorado a few years ago. I have never felt this welcomed since moving.
As I hope I have made clear, it is a family-owned/operated restaurant, which means a small staff. Service can be a little slower than some people like in modern society, and the always-on-the-move culture we have created. We don't mind because we know it is worth it, both the amazing food and supporting a local business. As I finish the tiramisu that we ordered to go, I can't wait to go back soon! (Next, we plan to go on their Asian fusion night, which will highlight the wife's culture, as well as her husband's!)
After having lived in Fort Collins for the past few years, we moved to Wellington a few months ago, where we discovered Papa's Table. We have been a few times, (my kids' favorite was during the summer when they had special menu items). Tonight, we attended a fundraiser for Samaritan's Purse, raising money for hurricane victims on the East Coast. As always, the food was amazing, despite the limited menu, of which all proceeds were donated. Drinks and desserts went back to the restaurant, which we also happily purchased. The owners and their daughter have always been friendly, but tonight, being mostly loyal patrons, and local residents, it felt like an almost familial atmosphere. It was the small-town, homey vibes I have missed since we moved to Colorado a few years ago. I have never felt this welcomed since moving.
As I hope I have made clear, it is a family-owned/operated restaurant, which means a small staff. Service can be a little slower than some people like in modern society, and the always-on-the-move culture we have created. We don't mind because we know it is worth it, both the amazing food and supporting a local business. As I finish the tiramisu that we ordered to go, I can't wait to go back soon! (Next, we plan to go on their Asian fusion night, which will highlight the wife's culture, as well as her husband's!)
Amber Hogsett
Kid-friendliness: My daughter had her 5m old and it was no issue.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Peaches and Chicken, Chicken Parmesan, Ravioli
Jeremiah Taylor
It was excellent from the time we walked in the doors until I wobbled back to my car.
We got the kids the spaghetti and eat balls and the chicken strips (also came with spaghetti). I got the founder special, qitj a sode of clam chowder, and my wife got the Ferlazzo. We also ordered a few of the peach desserts.
The service from everyone was incredible. They brought us bread and butter, even a 2nd, when I smashed the first. The food came out hot and was clearly fresh and high-quality ingredients; it was made with passion for sure.
I'd definitely recommend the trip if you're passing through. Saved us from driving all the way to Denver to have a nice dinner. We drove down from Casper WY as there aren't great food options up this way, unfortunately.
I can't find the picture of my flounder, but ill.edit post if I find it. All around 10/10 on the food and service.
Stopped here on a whim travelling to see our family in Cheyenne and I'm so glad we did. This place was phenomenal!!! Best crab cakes I've ever had (they were a special so I dont think you can get them anytime.) If you're wanting some amazing Italian food, look no further! We will DEFINITELY be coming back!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Hands down the best lasagna I've ever had! Love the family that runs this place. You can taste the love in every bite. A true hidden gem in Wellington!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
My husband and I stumbled upon this gem! Excellent Italian food. I highly recommend.
The food was delicious. The atmosphere was cozy, and the service was good. We would definitely eat there again.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
We just moved into the area. This is the best Italian food we have ever had. It is very authentic and delicious. Great food great prices. Great service. And a beautiful dining room. We will be coming here many times in the future.
The food was delicious. We started with Mussels Angelo- yum, salad was very fresh, Swordfish served Sicilian style was amazing. Veal Picatta (schnitzel style) was loaded with capers and lemon. The portions were generous without being too much. Chocolate mousse was rich and creamy. The staff/owners were very friendly and welcoming. If you’re in the Wellington/Ft Collins area- I would highly recommend Papa’s Table.
An old-school Italian joint. I can't believe I had overlooked this spot for so many years. Definitely worth the drive from Fort Collins.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Outstanding! Great food great people quiet and cozy little "neighborhood" restaurant. Date night or Sunday family lunch here's the place for you and you don't have to drive to Ft Collins!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Closed, for sale
After having lived in Fort Collins for the past few years, we moved to Wellington a few months ago, where we discovered Papa's Table. We have been a few times, (my kids' favorite was during the summer when they had special menu items). Tonight, we attended a fundraiser for Samaritan's Purse, raising money for hurricane victims on the East Coast.
As always, the food was amazing, despite the limited menu, of which all proceeds were donated. Drinks and desserts went back to the restaurant, which we also happily purchased.
The owners and their daughter have always been friendly, but tonight, being mostly loyal patrons, and local residents, it felt like an almost familial atmosphere. It was the small-town, homey vibes I have missed since we moved to Colorado a few years ago. I have never felt this welcomed since moving.
As I hope I have made clear, it is a family-owned/operated restaurant, which means a small staff. Service can be a little slower than some people like in modern society, and the always-on-the-move culture we have created. We don't mind because we know it is worth it, both the amazing food and supporting a local business.
As I finish the tiramisu that we ordered to go, I can't wait to go back soon! (Next, we plan to go on their Asian fusion night, which will highlight the wife's culture, as well as her husband's!)
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Restaurantji Recommends
Great food great service
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 4
Food and wine were fabulous
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheesecake, Ravioli
After having lived in Fort Collins for the past few years, we moved to Wellington a few months ago, where we discovered Papa's Table. We have been a few times, (my kids' favorite was during the summer when they had special menu items). Tonight, we attended a fundraiser for Samaritan's Purse, raising money for hurricane victims on the East Coast.
As always, the food was amazing, despite the limited menu, of which all proceeds were donated. Drinks and desserts went back to the restaurant, which we also happily purchased.
The owners and their daughter have always been friendly, but tonight, being mostly loyal patrons, and local residents, it felt like an almost familial atmosphere. It was the small-town, homey vibes I have missed since we moved to Colorado a few years ago. I have never felt this welcomed since moving.
As I hope I have made clear, it is a family-owned/operated restaurant, which means a small staff. Service can be a little slower than some people like in modern society, and the always-on-the-move culture we have created. We don't mind because we know it is worth it, both the amazing food and supporting a local business.
As I finish the tiramisu that we ordered to go, I can't wait to go back soon! (Next, we plan to go on their Asian fusion night, which will highlight the wife's culture, as well as her husband's!)
Kid-friendliness: My daughter had her 5m old and it was no issue.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Peaches and Chicken, Chicken Parmesan, Ravioli
It was excellent from the time we walked in the doors until I wobbled back to my car.
We got the kids the spaghetti and eat balls and the chicken strips (also came with spaghetti). I got the founder special, qitj a sode of clam chowder, and my wife got the Ferlazzo. We also ordered a few of the peach desserts.
The service from everyone was incredible. They brought us bread and butter, even a 2nd, when I smashed the first. The food came out hot and was clearly fresh and high-quality ingredients; it was made with passion for sure.
I'd definitely recommend the trip if you're passing through. Saved us from driving all the way to Denver to have a nice dinner. We drove down from Casper WY as there aren't great food options up this way, unfortunately.
I can't find the picture of my flounder, but ill.edit post if I find it. All around 10/10 on the food and service.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Loading...