Lil Nicks Pizza is the perfect pizza spot in my opinion. When you walk in the lights are dim and the red/brown tones inside provide a calm and cozy atmosphere and feeling. The first time I walked in was to pick up a pizza and when I came in I knew I had to come back to actually eat inside. Lil Nicks is my favorite pizza spot and I go often, their pizza is chefs kiss! They have multiple specialty pizzas and they also make sandwiches, salads and pastas I have yet to try. If you go here I recommend trying the Casper specialty pizza, although it has an oil base it does not disappoint. I like to add on jalapeño’s and pineapples to make it even better. You also need to try their mozzarella sticks and buffalo wings. If you are tired of the regular Dominos, Lil ceasars and Marcos pizza definitely try Lil Nicks because I know you will fall inlove just like I did.
JOHN TAYLOR
Great food wonderful place and great people.
April Eversole
I love the pizza,but the pasta and salads are good too. Wish they had more for a drink menu like specials.
Autumn Gordon
Stopped in for dinner, amazing service from Shar and Maddy and amazing food. I’m an Italian snob, and I was super happy. 10/10 will be back!
Jordan Amos
Pasta trio was great. Can't wait to come back.
tracy garner
It was my 1st time in. Service was slow, it appeared to be just 1 person working the bar, restaurant, and phone/take out. My pizza came out not quite cooked all the way, the dough was gooey in the center. I do plan on returning to try a pasta dish and sub.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Shannon Chandler
Won't allow service animals during dinner rushes. Great food.
Kid-friendliness: Not service animal friendly during meal times.
Recommended dishes: Calzone
Rob Martin
Staff was friendly, food was hot and timely, ingredients seemed top notch, sauce flavor was off. As a native to NY this pizza fell flat on flavor unfortunately. Needs more Italian zest in the sauce and dough was tad bit wet. Definitely dissapointing for the price (100$ for 2 pizzas and 20 wings). Wings were great though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Ibra Jimenez
Good pizza and beer
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Joan Guischard
Great pizza, atmosphere, and really welcoming staff!
The most bland, disappointing meal I have ever spent money on.
Not a speck of seasoning to be tasted and the portion for my $18 pasta looked like it was a kids portion.
The noodles were so over cooked they barely kept shape and the ‘roasted’ chicken breast tasted like it was boiled in unsalted water and set in the sun til browned.
Truly the most disappointing, less than mediocre experience I have ever had with a plate of pasta.
If you are hoping for a delicious, comforting meal on a cold winter night, I suggest you go literally anywhere else.
The cozy atmosphere and pleasant staff are lovely. Doesn’t make up for the food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Zack Brooke
Great pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza, Garlic Knots
Antonio J
This cozy, family-owned joint has been around for ages, and it's easy to see why. Their pizza is seriously good, and the rest of the Italian-American menu looks equally promising. It's the kind of place where you feel right at home.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
Sawyer Wilson
2 for 2 on food poisoning. Will not be eating here again. Sad part is it actually tasted pretty good, guessing this place is lacking quality control in their ingredients.
Food: 2
Arlene Shin
We read all the positive reviews and the pictures of food looked great so we finally made it there today for lunch. We were so impressed with the excellent service with a smile by the hostess/waitress, pizza was so delicious 😋. Definitely won us over and will return to try other items on the menu. Super clean women's bathroom too.
Lil Nicks Pizza is the perfect pizza spot in my opinion. When you walk in the lights are dim and the red/brown tones inside provide a calm and cozy atmosphere and feeling. The first time I walked in was to pick up a pizza and when I came in I knew I had to come back to actually eat inside. Lil Nicks is my favorite pizza spot and I go often, their pizza is chefs kiss! They have multiple specialty pizzas and they also make sandwiches, salads and pastas I have yet to try. If you go here I recommend trying the Casper specialty pizza, although it has an oil base it does not disappoint. I like to add on jalapeño’s and pineapples to make it even better. You also need to try their mozzarella sticks and buffalo wings. If you are tired of the regular Dominos, Lil ceasars and Marcos pizza definitely try Lil Nicks because I know you will fall inlove just like I did.
Great food wonderful place and great people.
I love the pizza,but the pasta and salads are good too. Wish they had more for a drink menu like specials.
Stopped in for dinner, amazing service from Shar and Maddy and amazing food. I’m an Italian snob, and I was super happy. 10/10 will be back!
Pasta trio was great. Can't wait to come back.
It was my 1st time in. Service was slow, it appeared to be just 1 person working the bar, restaurant, and phone/take out. My pizza came out not quite cooked all the way, the dough was gooey in the center. I do plan on returning to try a pasta dish and sub.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 3
Service: 3
Won't allow service animals during dinner rushes. Great food.
Kid-friendliness: Not service animal friendly during meal times.
Recommended dishes: Calzone
Staff was friendly, food was hot and timely, ingredients seemed top notch, sauce flavor was off. As a native to NY this pizza fell flat on flavor unfortunately. Needs more Italian zest in the sauce and dough was tad bit wet. Definitely dissapointing for the price (100$ for 2 pizzas and 20 wings). Wings were great though.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 3
Service: 5
Good pizza and beer
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 5
Great pizza, atmosphere, and really welcoming staff!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Restaurantji Recommends
The most bland, disappointing meal I have ever spent money on.
Not a speck of seasoning to be tasted and the portion for my $18 pasta looked like it was a kids portion.
The noodles were so over cooked they barely kept shape and the ‘roasted’ chicken breast tasted like it was boiled in unsalted water and set in the sun til browned.
Truly the most disappointing, less than mediocre experience I have ever had with a plate of pasta.
If you are hoping for a delicious, comforting meal on a cold winter night, I suggest you go literally anywhere else.
The cozy atmosphere and pleasant staff are lovely. Doesn’t make up for the food.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 1
Service: 4
Great pizza
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza, Garlic Knots
This cozy, family-owned joint has been around for ages, and it's easy to see why. Their pizza is seriously good, and the rest of the Italian-American menu looks equally promising. It's the kind of place where you feel right at home.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 3
2 for 2 on food poisoning. Will not be eating here again. Sad part is it actually tasted pretty good, guessing this place is lacking quality control in their ingredients.
Food: 2
We read all the positive reviews and the pictures of food looked great so we finally made it there today for lunch. We were so impressed with the excellent service with a smile by the hostess/waitress, pizza was so delicious 😋. Definitely won us over and will return to try other items on the menu. Super clean women's bathroom too.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Great Pizza
Loading...