The pizza was ok stuck to the cardboard box the crust isn't that great the sauce was the best part. The ravioli was decent the garlic bread wasn't so much, overall it was decent
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian, Half Order of Cheese Ravioli
Clara Kelley
I love Roma's carolis! They're the best.
Food: 5
Service: 5
H Lyons
Needed my pastafarian fix so I stopped in for lasagna.
First try it was cold in the center. Second delivery was much better.
Taste was good but the meat was sliced mild sausage which was not that tasty.
Overall experience was pizza shop average. The server, Courtney if I remember correctly, was excellent.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
Jennie Cttn
So I order a ceaser salad and added extra croutons and added Chicken and 2 meatball sliders on the side. I pick up and I am excited for the salad and I just go all in you know lol to my surprise the prior cooked chicken is just thawing out on top of my salad 🤢. I mean I get that the chicken needed to be cold to be on the salad but the chicken was colder than the salad, like I said just thawing. I'm so grossed out at this point I toss the $15 salad out yep threw away $15 just like that! The sliders were good though!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
Ed Tynczuk
bottom of the pizza was stuck to the cardboard. Had to scrape it off.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
Ryan Corey
I DoorDashed this one. Now look, I get it, I’ve worked the food industry before, but 1. PINEAPPLE DOESN’T BELONG ON PIZZA, and 2. IT ESPECIALLY DOESN’T BELONG IN A CAROLI THAT WAS ONLY SUPPOSED TO HAVE CHICKEN AND PEPPERONI... I’m not actually that mad, but please, pay attention when you’re making the food. I’m so disappointed….
Also, I wouldn’t have had this issue if I had ordered from one of the ones in Greeley (I imagine), but DoorDash wouldn’t let me for some reason…. Apologies if that’s my bad.
And yes, I am petty and picked out most of them, but who can blame me, THEY DON’T BELONG IN A CAROLI.
Food: 2
Dave Scott
Love this place! Jamie was taking care of us and she is so nice and took great care of us. The Caroli was great! Bazooka Bloody Mary! We had a great time! Thanks to Jamie for taking great care of us!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Robin May
We ordered off the lunch menu and the homemade spaghetti was a child’s portion. And still $11 plus til and tax. Sauce was very acidic. And we both ordered to go meals and one was completely wrong. The waitress was great. The rest….not so good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 3
Clint Schoeman
Good food. Decent service. Family place with liquor.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Jonna Herring
Food was fantastic. The place is set up like an old diner. It was a totally casual vibe and the customer service was on point.
Old school pizza place. Come hungry. A good light crust and a ton of options. Don't come here for the decor if you want modern. This place is straight out of the 80s. Good prices also
Carolyn McDonald - Realtor
Lunch specials are yummy!! 😁
Marc Zeller
loved the lasagna nice thick tomatoe sauce. The server was very attentive and well mannered. Very pleasant place.
Warren Wright
I ordered online an hour and a half before pickup on a Sunday night. Got there and they didn’t even have the pizza started. No offer to compensate for their mistake. Would not recommend.
The pizza was ok stuck to the cardboard box the crust isn't that great the sauce was the best part. The ravioli was decent the garlic bread wasn't so much, overall it was decent
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 2
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Hawaiian, Half Order of Cheese Ravioli
I love Roma's carolis! They're the best.
Food: 5
Service: 5
Needed my pastafarian fix so I stopped in for lasagna.
First try it was cold in the center. Second delivery was much better.
Taste was good but the meat was sliced mild sausage which was not that tasty.
Overall experience was pizza shop average. The server, Courtney if I remember correctly, was excellent.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 3
Service: 5
So I order a ceaser salad and added extra croutons and added Chicken and 2 meatball sliders on the side. I pick up and I am excited for the salad and I just go all in you know lol to my surprise the prior cooked chicken is just thawing out on top of my salad 🤢. I mean I get that the chicken needed to be cold to be on the salad but the chicken was colder than the salad, like I said just thawing. I'm so grossed out at this point I toss the $15 salad out yep threw away $15 just like that! The sliders were good though!
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 1
Service: 4
bottom of the pizza was stuck to the cardboard. Had to scrape it off.
Atmosphere: 2
Food: 1
Service: 1
I DoorDashed this one. Now look, I get it, I’ve worked the food industry before, but 1. PINEAPPLE DOESN’T BELONG ON PIZZA, and 2. IT ESPECIALLY DOESN’T BELONG IN A CAROLI THAT WAS ONLY SUPPOSED TO HAVE CHICKEN AND PEPPERONI... I’m not actually that mad, but please, pay attention when you’re making the food. I’m so disappointed….
Also, I wouldn’t have had this issue if I had ordered from one of the ones in Greeley (I imagine), but DoorDash wouldn’t let me for some reason…. Apologies if that’s my bad.
And yes, I am petty and picked out most of them, but who can blame me, THEY DON’T BELONG IN A CAROLI.
Food: 2
Love this place! Jamie was taking care of us and she is so nice and took great care of us. The Caroli was great! Bazooka Bloody Mary! We had a great time! Thanks to Jamie for taking great care of us!!!
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
We ordered off the lunch menu and the homemade spaghetti was a child’s portion. And still $11 plus til and tax. Sauce was very acidic.
And we both ordered to go meals and one was completely wrong. The waitress was great. The rest….not so good.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 2
Service: 3
Good food. Decent service. Family place with liquor.
Atmosphere: 3
Food: 4
Service: 4
Food was fantastic. The place is set up like an old diner. It was a totally casual vibe and the customer service was on point.
Restaurantji Recommends
Old school pizza place. Come hungry. A good light crust and a ton of options. Don't come here for the decor if you want modern. This place is straight out of the 80s. Good prices also
Lunch specials are yummy!! 😁
loved the lasagna nice thick tomatoe sauce. The server was very attentive and well mannered. Very pleasant place.
I ordered online an hour and a half before pickup on a Sunday night. Got there and they didn’t even have the pizza started. No offer to compensate for their mistake. Would not recommend.
Food was amazing, service was incredible!!!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Calzone, Garlic Bread
Loading...