Matthews Catering Company

15 E Main St, Central Village
(860) 564-3543

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Stanley Walker Jr.

Fantastic food !! Great service also

Sarah Clark

We couldn’t have been happier with our experience! From start to finish, the team was incredible. Lin went above and beyond helping us coordinate every detail leading up to the big day — she made everything so easy and stress-free. The staff on the day of the wedding were so friendly, professional, and attentive, and our guests couldn’t stop raving about the food. Everything was absolutely delicious — from the tender short ribs to the amazing cannolis! Thank you for helping make our day so special and memorable.

Stephanie Medine

It’s been over a year since our wedding, and I have been putting this review off because I just CAN NOT find the words to express how amazing Matthews Catering was for our wedding. Not only did they handle literally everything - from coordinating the day’s order of events, set up, helping me walk down the aisle, perfecting our menu, set down, to above and beyond by making us a surprise/special cake. They also catered so PERFECTLY to my husband’s allergies; a huge stressor for us. So many local caterers discouraged me, expecting astronomical prices to outsource pre-made meals. Matthew’s made everything from scratch, allowing us peace of mind for our day AND a reasonable price. It was fantastic and I could not believe how many people approached us afterwards about the taste and quality of the food (even the “allergy friendly” options). Special thanks to Matthew and Lin. Lin is amazing.

I work for the wedding venue I got married at. I know a LOT of caterers and have had a LOT of wedding food. Matthews is something special. From the bottom of our hearts, thank you! I can’t say it enough!

Julie Escamilla Rosa

Matthew’s catering catered my wedding at the Gwyn Careg inn. The food was superb and the servicec was exceptional.

Jonathan Quiello

Staff was very pleasant and they have great grab and go meals already prepared.

Alec Hargett

Matthew provided a generous, personalized tasting that was both thoughtful and absolutely delicious. His vodka sauce and Alfredo pastas were standouts — definitely worth considering for your menu. He's a truly talented chef.

Jillian Wagner

I love Matthew’s for their amazing gourmet style marketplace & buying dinner for my family and I on quick prep nights.i would highly recommend them for all catering, and meal needs. The quality doesn't compare to ANYWHERE else in the local area! I would choose Matthews for any future catering events.

Jenna Conkin

Matthew’s Catering Company always goes above and beyond, whether it be their prepared meals in their Market or their catered events. I highly recommend this company to anyone looking for a quick and delicious weeknight meal or for someone booking a Wedding!

meg stuy

Matthew’s is the best! Their staff is wonderful! We have never had a bad experience working with them for any of our events!

Robert Gifford

Amazing food!! Service is always top notch!

Robert Gifford

The best customer service and food I’ve had!

Elizabeth Tomlin

If I could give them 10 Star rating I would!
I ordered food from Matthew’s Catering to cater my husband’s 55th birthday. When I say they were phenomenal is an understatement. The food was delivered nice and hot and the even let me borrow their hot box to keep it hot. The service impeccable. They delivered right on time. The Food? Unbelievable! Let’s just say I had NO leftovers! I would recommend Matthews for any event you are planning.
YOU WILL NOT BE DISSAPPOINTED!
Thank you Matthew’s for making my life a little easier and making my husband’s birthday celebration a SUCCESS!

Ashley Turner-Zabulis

Matthew’s Catering made our wedding day absolutely unforgettable! The food was simply phenomenal—everything from the appetizers to the main courses was perfectly cooked and beautifully presented. Our guests couldn’t stop raving about how delicious everything was! But what truly set Matthew’s Catering apart was the incredible staff. They went above and beyond, making sure every detail was flawless, and they did it all with such warmth and professionalism. They made us feel so taken care of, and their seamless service allowed us to truly enjoy our day. If you’re looking for top-tier food and service, Matthew’s Catering is the way to go!

Taylor Mackenzie

I can’t say enough good things about Matthews Catering for my wedding! From start to finish, they were truly amazing. They brought my vision to life in the most delicious way possible. The food was absolutely incredible—everyone at the wedding and even weeks after couldn’t stop complimenting how good it was!

Lin, our coordinator, was a standout. She was so helpful, attentive, and kind throughout the entire planning process. Every step felt seamless, and it was clear she genuinely cared about making our day special. She listened to my ideas and made sure everything was executed perfectly (and I was a type A bride with a lot of requests from her!).

Matt, the caterer, and his team were equally impressive. Their professionalism and passion for what they do were evident in every detail. They worked tirelessly to ensure everything ran smoothly, and their friendly demeanor made the whole experience even better.

If you’re looking for a professional catering company for any event or wedding, I wholeheartedly recommend Matthews Catering. They exceeded all my expectations and made our celebration unforgettable! Thank you, Matthews Catering, for making our day so special!

Rachel Pierce

Matthews Catering did an amazing job at my wedding this past week. Penny helped out on my wedding today to make sure everything went smoothly. Matthew and his team did awesome with the food and serving. Nothing but compliments from my guests!

Loading...