Phenomenal pizza! I drove down from upstate ny & I have to tell you that was hands down the best pizza I have had since my childhood pizzeria in ct! I actually travel a lot and have had pizza all over ny & ct and I had to show restraint and save some for the family at home -nothing to me is better than true Italian made with love & from scratch pizza - true comfort food 😘 you simply have to try it for yourself and you will thank me for recommending this gem of a pizzeria! It smells like Italian heaven!a slice of heaven on earth!
Nina Velez-Seeley
Absolute BEST pizza around!! And we’ve tried them all!! Perfectly thin crust, flavorful sauce and just the right amount of cheese!! It has become our family’s Friday night favorite!! You won’t be disappointed!! Five Stars!! ✨
Judyth Gladstein Powers Stavans
We had a fabulous meal here today! Our group had a house salad, meatballs, dough knots, a Margherita pizza and the especially amazing cheeseburger pizza. Everything was extremely yummy! And the service was above and beyond. Thank you, Sheryl, for a delightful experience!
Kid-friendliness: Kid- friendliness - parents watch them close; Main Street can be dangerous & Construction areas
Wheelchair accessibility: Limited front parking across the street there's plenty to park.
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Dave Stec
Unbelievable place! Top shelf pizza plus the service and atmosphere is amazing!!! Family locally owned and gives back to kids must try! Thank u guys again
Anji H
This was the best pizza I have had in the last 20 years!!!! From the taste to size need I say the pie was so big the box didn't close!I had to use 2 hands to hold it .The perfect amount of that amazing sauce cheese with meat in every bite...With the crispy bottom & edges!!!I know your mouth is watering by now stop reading and go get you some and tell your neighbors about this hidden gem they deserved to be blessed by this establishment they cook with Love!
Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger Pizza
James Mason
I need to try this in house. This is the best pizza I have ever had delivered in my life. I have very high standards with food, especially if I can make something better than I'm buying. This was absolutely amazing pizza and I can't wait to try it fresh out of the oven.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Alex Sayan
The food here is DELICIOUS, have ordered take-out here so many times. Decided to Dine-In and as expected, pizza was delicious. We ordered some garlic knots that had a very doughy, raw bottom and the owner came out to serve us a new batch and telling us "by the way they weren't raw, they're supposed to be like that". Too bad, won't be dining-in there again but absolutely will order take-out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Mark Dickinson
Decided to skip the other popular place in Derby to try out Bartones...I wasn't able to get pics of my order, but I got 4 different pies plus 2 orders of knots... loved them all...will definitely be back soon
Food: 5
Service: 5
Karen Orazietti
Best pizza ever. The size and value for the pizza is awesome. I highly recommend them.
Our first time at Bartones. Great Italian style pizza with thin & crispy crust. For those with gluten issues they have a dedicated gluten free oven. Had a nice crispy crust for once! Will be our new go to for pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Sausage, Cheese Pizza
Frank Cavaliere
First time ordering, take out pizza from here.It was excellent thin crust new haven style cooked perfectly. We had the beef cake, the has-been, and the stuffed shrimp. Will def be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Madison Craytor
They have the best pizza I've ever had. My boyfriend and I visited Bartone's for the first time last week and we tried a basic bacon pizza and a specialty Dollys Delight. Both were absolutely out of this world good. The Dollys Delight pizza is like if you decided to combine lasagna flavors with a pizza and it did not disappoint.
We enjoyed our first visit so much that we decided to visit them again tonight. We tried the Derby Cheesesteak and the Pulled Pork specialty pizzas. Once again, these are some of the best pizzas I've ever had.
I can't recommend this place enough. Definitely stop by if you want pizza that gives the famous places in New Haven a run for their money.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Chris Morin
Get the "Has Been" pizza. Like garlic bread pizza with sauce. So good !! Crust and sauce are amazing. Cooked to perfection.
Vegetarian options: They have a couple of different veggie pizzas, and of course you can pick your toppings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Nee-Nee D'Onofrio
Awesome place for their stuffed breads. The plain cheese pizza was a bit too salty my hubby said. I loved the steak & cheese sub.
Parking: Because of the new state road project going thru downtown Derby CT. Prking sucks It's kinda like jumping a curb. Stupid set up. Derby needs more street prking. To help out these businesses want to thrive.
Phenomenal pizza! I drove down from upstate ny & I have to tell you that was hands down the best pizza I have had since my childhood pizzeria in ct! I actually travel a lot and have had pizza all over ny & ct and I had to show restraint and save some for the family at home -nothing to me is better than true Italian made with love & from scratch pizza - true comfort food 😘 you simply have to try it for yourself and you will thank me for recommending this gem of a pizzeria! It smells like Italian heaven!a slice of heaven on earth!
Absolute BEST pizza around!! And we’ve tried them all!! Perfectly thin crust, flavorful sauce and just the right amount of cheese!! It has become our family’s Friday night favorite!! You won’t be disappointed!! Five Stars!! ✨
We had a fabulous meal here today! Our group had a house salad, meatballs, dough knots, a Margherita pizza and the especially amazing cheeseburger pizza. Everything was extremely yummy! And the service was above and beyond. Thank you, Sheryl, for a delightful experience!
The Best pizza & amazing Eggplant in Connecticut
Vegetarian options: Monday - Friday hours 4pm - 9pm
Weekends 2pm - 10,om
Kid-friendliness: Kid- friendliness - parents watch them close; Main Street can be dangerous & Construction areas
Wheelchair accessibility: Limited front parking across the street there's plenty to park.
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Unbelievable place! Top shelf pizza plus the service and atmosphere is amazing!!! Family locally owned and gives back to kids must try! Thank u guys again
This was the best pizza I have had in the last 20 years!!!! From the taste to size need I say the pie was so big the box didn't close!I had to use 2 hands to hold it .The perfect amount of that amazing sauce cheese with meat in every bite...With the crispy bottom & edges!!!I know your mouth is watering by now stop reading and go get you some and tell your neighbors about this hidden gem they deserved to be blessed by this establishment they cook with Love!
Recommended dishes: Cheeseburger Pizza
I need to try this in house. This is the best pizza I have ever had delivered in my life. I have very high standards with food, especially if I can make something better than I'm buying. This was absolutely amazing pizza and I can't wait to try it fresh out of the oven.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
The food here is DELICIOUS, have ordered take-out here so many times. Decided to Dine-In and as expected, pizza was delicious. We ordered some garlic knots that had a very doughy, raw bottom and the owner came out to serve us a new batch and telling us "by the way they weren't raw, they're supposed to be like that". Too bad, won't be dining-in there again but absolutely will order take-out.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 3
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
Decided to skip the other popular place in Derby to try out Bartones...I wasn't able to get pics of my order, but I got 4 different pies plus 2 orders of knots... loved them all...will definitely be back soon
Food: 5
Service: 5
Best pizza ever. The size and value for the pizza is awesome. I highly recommend them.
Restaurantji Recommends
Our first time at Bartones. Great Italian style pizza with thin & crispy crust. For those with gluten issues they have a dedicated gluten free oven. Had a nice crispy crust for once! Will be our new go to for pizza!
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Large Sausage, Cheese Pizza
First time ordering, take out pizza from here.It was excellent thin crust new haven style cooked perfectly. We had the beef cake, the has-been, and the stuffed shrimp. Will def be back.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Recommended dishes: Cheese Pizza
They have the best pizza I've ever had. My boyfriend and I visited Bartone's for the first time last week and we tried a basic bacon pizza and a specialty Dollys Delight. Both were absolutely out of this world good. The Dollys Delight pizza is like if you decided to combine lasagna flavors with a pizza and it did not disappoint.
We enjoyed our first visit so much that we decided to visit them again tonight. We tried the Derby Cheesesteak and the Pulled Pork specialty pizzas. Once again, these are some of the best pizzas I've ever had.
I can't recommend this place enough. Definitely stop by if you want pizza that gives the famous places in New Haven a run for their money.
Atmosphere: 5
Food: 5
Service: 5
Get the "Has Been" pizza. Like garlic bread pizza with sauce. So good !! Crust and sauce are amazing. Cooked to perfection.
Vegetarian options: They have a couple of different veggie pizzas, and of course you can pick your toppings.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 5
Service: 5
Awesome place for their stuffed breads. The plain cheese pizza was a bit too salty my hubby said. I loved the steak & cheese sub.
Parking: Because of the new state road project going thru downtown Derby CT. Prking sucks It's kinda like jumping a curb. Stupid set up. Derby needs more street prking. To help out these businesses want to thrive.
Atmosphere: 4
Food: 4
Service: 4
Recommended dishes: Buffalo Chicken
Loading...