Pizza on Main

87 Main St A, East Hampton
(860) 267-0326

Recent Reviews

Sort by
Chris Connelly

Came in after a long bike ride. Walked in to what I thought was a counter or host. A gentleman behind the counter said I could sit where ever I like and he called me Boss. I hate that! In fact he called everyone Boss even while on the phone taking orders. I had to get a menu myself. After what seems to be 10min the same gentleman ask me if I wanted something to drink. I ordered a club soda. He had to check if they had it. That seemed odd. Then a nice young lady server brought me my drink. I then ordered a meatball appetizer and a 10” cheese pizza and asked if they could be brought out at the same time. The meatballs came out in like 1 min. The pizza then followed in a reasonable amount of time. I took one look at the pizza and I could swear it was a frozen pizza it did not look like it was freshly made. I was very hungry so I ate it. I would say that Amy’s frozen pizza is better. Strange dinning experience.

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 2

Service: 2

Cindy Laribee

The food was really good but the service was not so good. We walked in had pre ordered the food the gentlemen brought our order and never returned. Did not ask if we wanted drinks nothing and then added a tip to the bill for literally not doing anything but dropping our food on the table. That was kinda enough to make us not want to go back . A tip is earned and why should anyone be forced to tip .

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 1

Kate Huth

I did take out, but I'd bring friends here to try more! The appetizer meatballs were light and yummy! The marinara was perfectly chunky with tomatoes.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Lloyd Spencer

Heaven is a Meatball Grinder with Provolone!

Great food, friendly service ... what more could you ask for.

Well, maybe a Sausage Grinder ... or a Bells and Whistle Pizza. Next year ❤️

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carmen Rod

I love this place . The meat balls appetizer is a plus. The calamari are so crispy and delicious.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Vincent Taylor

Pizza was 🔥 so delicious 😋

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Carey

Terrible pizza and service. We do not recommend at all. Go to DaVinci's, Rossini's or Three Fella's

Atmosphere: 2

Food: 1

Service: 1

Davey Boy

Saucy Balls…..Real nice pie. Nice bright sauce-not sweet and cloying. Crust not a thin crust but worked perfectly. Meatballs real nice and tasty-great texture-and the arugula a great finishing touch. Got takeout. We’ll be back…

Food: 5

Michael Jackson

Super expensive, have tried them 4 times. Spend over $100 each time to feed my family. Orders always messed up or they forget something. One time they offered me a $10 gift card to apologize for how bad they did. I have it away

Andrew Hill

While the food is mostly good (I actually enjoy their pizza and their pasta) when we ordered a thing of garlic bread from them, what we received was a hot dog bun covered with garlic and sliced into six pieces. That's pretty ridiculous for six bucks. Get them at your own risk.

Edit: I really appreciate the explanation and the response from the owner. Changing my review to reflect the character of the business and the owners. Their pizza and pasta is good!

Food: 5

Service: 5

Connie DeVries

They have gotten very expensive. Medium pepperoni pizza $26 tax $2 delivery (less than a mile) $7 expected/anticipated tip $5. $40 They have priced them self out of price range.

Atmosphere: 3

Food: 3

Service: 3

Chavelita Samy Ruiz

The food is always fresh and 😋 delicious

Baffled By Life

Hard to say what to say but this was extremely good pizza. Just great have been there three times in the last 2 months.

Justin Crum

Very friendly staff, good food. The long drive out here from my area was worth it.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Recommended dishes: Custom BYO Grinder

Sarah Reed

Great Nachos and even better ? margaritas.

Atmosphere: 5

Food: 5

Service: 5

Loading...